Words that do no work
Clutter is any word that can leave a sentence without the sentence losing anything. The test is that simple. Take the word out. If the meaning, the picture and the sound are all still there, the word was doing no work.
The test
- Take the word out
- Read the sentence againIs the meaning, the picture and the sound still there?
- If so, it did no workLeave it out
The advice is old. William Strunk’s The Elements of Style, first printed in 1918, gives it in three words: “Omit needless words.” William Zinsser’s On Writing Well has a whole chapter called “Clutter”.
It matters because a reader pays for every word with a little attention. Words that give nothing back wear that attention down, and they crowd the words that do matter.
Five kinds you can learn to see
Saying it twice. Nodded his head. Shrugged her shoulders. Whispered softly. Stood up. The second part is already inside the first.
- Saying it twiceNodded his head. Whispered softly.
- Scaffolding“She began to run” is nearly always “She ran”
- Wind-upsIt was at that moment that…
- Hedges and boostersRather, sort of; very, really, actually
- Directions for the obviousShe reached out her hand and picked up the cup
Scaffolding. Began to, started to, proceeded to, was able to. These stand in front of the real verb and delay it. “She began to run” is nearly always “She ran”.
Wind-ups. It was at that moment that. The fact was that. There was a man who. The sentence clears its throat before it speaks.
Hedges and boosters. Rather, somewhat, a little, sort of, on one side; very, really, quite, actually, absolutely, on the other. Hedges take back half of what you said. Boosters try to add force and usually take it away: “very tired” is weaker than “tired” said plainly, and far weaker than “asleep on her feet”.
Stage directions for the obvious. “She reached out her hand and picked up the cup” is “She picked up the cup”. The reaching is already inside “picked up”.
What cutting is not
Cutting clutter is not the same as making everything short. A detail that gives the reader a picture is doing work, however many words it takes. So is an “and” that keeps the rhythm.
How hard to cut
- ClutterWords that give nothing back
- Every word workingA detail, an “and” for the rhythm
- Cut too hardClipped sentences, joining words gone
Cut too hard and prose turns into notes: clipped sentences of the same length, with the joining words gone. The aim is a page where every word is working, which is a different thing from a page with the fewest words.
Example
A first draft, marked up
This paragraph is as its writer first typed it. Nothing in it is wrong. Count how many words you could lift out.
It was at that moment that1 Leontine began to realise2 that she had actually3 left her phone behind on the counter of the bakery. She turned around and looked back down the street behind her4. The baker himself was already standing there in the doorway, holding it up in his hand5 and smiling a very wide smile. She nodded her head, and started to walk6 back towards him.
- “It was at that moment that”A wind-up. Six words go by before anything happens. Start with Leontine.
- “began to realise”Scaffolding. Realising is instant. “Realised” says it.
- “actually”A booster that adds no fact. She left her phone, with or without it.
- “back down the street behind her”Said twice. “Back” already tells us the street is behind her.
- “in his hand”A stage direction for the obvious. What else would he hold it up in?
- “nodded her head, and started to walk”A doubled pair and a piece of scaffolding in one clause. “She nodded and walked back” loses nothing.
Before and after
The same climb, with and without padding
The one faultWords that do no work pad every sentence.
In order to get to the roof, Zoltan first had to climb up the fire escape, which was completely rusted through in a number of places. He reached out his hand and tested each and every rung before he put any of his weight on it. At the very top he paused for a brief moment and listened. Down below him in the alley, a car door closed shut, and then there was the sound of footsteps starting to come towards the ladder.
The first version is 83 words and the second is 51. Every fact survives: the roof, the rust, the testing of each rung, the pause, the car door, the footsteps.
Look at what went. “In order to” became “to”. “Climb up” became “climb”, since there is no other way to climb a fire escape to a roof. “Completely rusted through” lost its booster, because rusted through is already complete. “Reached out his hand”, “each and every”, “very”, “for a brief moment” and “closed shut” all say a thing twice or direct the obvious. “There was the sound of footsteps starting to come” is a wind-up and a piece of scaffolding wrapped round two words: footsteps came.
The second version is also more frightening. With the padding gone, the footsteps arrive sooner.
The exception
When to break it
Speech is the first exception. People hedge, repeat themselves and take run-ups, and a character who says “I just sort of thought, maybe” is being drawn by those words. Trim dialogue for pace, but leave people their habits.
Voice is the second. A first-person narrator may ramble, fuss or take the long way round, and that manner can be the pleasure of the book. Ask whether the extra words sound like the narrator or like the writer warming up.
Some phrases on the list have honest uses. “Began to” is right when the action is cut off: she began to speak, and the lights went out. A doubled phrase can be kept for its beat in a speech or a spell.
And a slow scene needs room. Do not cut the detail that lets a quiet moment breathe just because a count says you can. Cutting belongs to revision. In a first draft, write the padding and keep going.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Already clean
Three of these sentences carry words that do no work. Which one has nothing to cut?
Key takeaway
Take a word out and see whether anything is lost. If nothing is, leave it out. Watch for things said twice, helper verbs such as “began to”, sentences that wind up before they start, hedges and boosters, and directions for the obvious. Stop cutting when the next cut would cost a fact, a picture or the rhythm.
