Who does what
Take one event: a dog and a postman. English can report it two ways.
One event, two ways
The dog bit the postman. That is the active form. The one who acts comes first.
The postman was bitten by the dog. That is the passive. The one acted upon comes first, and the actor moves to the end after “by”, or drops out altogether: The postman was bitten.
The event is the same. What changes is where the reader is looking. The active sentence keeps its eye on the dog. The passive keeps its eye on the postman.
How to recognise a passive
A passive is built from a form of “to be” (is, was, were, been, being) and the form of the verb that follows “has”: bitten, opened, taken, cut. In speech “got” often stands in for “was”: he got arrested.
The “by someone” test
The quick test is to add “by someone” after the verb. The window was broken (by someone): passive. If the addition makes no sense, the sentence is something else.
That test matters because “was” alone proves nothing. She was tired: “was” with a describing word, and no action at all. He was running: “was” with an -ing word, which is active, since he is the one running. The house had stood for a century: active again. None of these is passive, and none needs fixing on that account.
A default and four good reasons
Active is the usual choice in fiction. It is shorter, it says who is responsible, and stories are mostly about people doing things.
Four good reasons
- The actor is unknownThe lock had been forced.
- The actor does not matterThe road was closed every winter.
- The actor is kept backMistakes were made.
- We follow the one acted onNina was shoved from behind.
The passive is the right tool in four cases. The actor is unknown: The lock had been forced. The actor does not matter: The road was closed every winter. The actor is being kept back, by the narrator or by a character dodging blame: Mistakes were made. Or the reader is following the person on the receiving end: Nina was shoved from behind.
If a passive fits none of the four, turn it round.
Example
Passives with a job
A police surgeon examines a body in a park. Watch which sentences name an actor and which hold one back.
Dr Eberhardt knelt beside the body and lifted the collar1 with one finger. The man had been strangled2, and not here: the grass under him was dry3, though it had rained since midnight. His pockets had been emptied.4 Someone had taken the trouble5 to fold his coat and lay it over his feet.
Eberhardt looked up at the constable. “Who moved him?”6
Nobody answered.
- “Dr Eberhardt knelt beside the body and lifted the collar”Active. We know who is acting, and the scene is his, so he comes first.
- “had been strangled”Passive, and rightly. Nobody knows who did it. That is the mystery, and the sentence keeps its eye on the dead man.
- “was dry”Not a passive. “Was” with a describing word reports a state. Try adding “by someone” and it makes no sense.
- “His pockets had been emptied.”Passive again, for the same reason. Two in a row make the unknown actor feel like a gap in the scene.
- “Someone had taken the trouble”Now the writer switches to active with “someone”. The actor is still unknown, but this time we are made to picture a person doing it.
- ““Who moved him?””An active question. It demands the one thing the passives have been holding back.
Before and after
The same boarding party, twice
The one faultActions by people we know are written in the passive.
The hatch was opened by Lieutenant Vandersteen at 0400. The corridor beyond had been sealed for sixty years. A lamp was held up by the engineer behind her, and the dust was disturbed by their boots as they went in. At the far end a second hatch was found by them. It was pushed by Vandersteen. It had been welded shut from the inside.
In the first version, five actions are done by people we can see, and each is written back to front: the hatch was opened by the lieutenant, a lamp was held up by the engineer, and so on. Each time the reader has to wait until the end of the sentence to find out who acted. “Was found by them” is the clumsiest. Nobody would say it aloud.
The second version turns those five round, so the actor leads. Nothing else has changed, and the passage is ten words shorter.
Two passives are the same in both versions: the corridor had been sealed, and the second hatch had been welded shut. Nobody present knows who did either. The last one is the point of the scene, and it hits harder once it is the only kind of sentence in the passage that hides its actor.
The exception
When to break it
Do not hunt passives down for being passives. A grammar checker may flag every one, including those that are working.
Three more jobs for a passive
Beyond the four cases, there are three more places where a passive may serve you. One is to hold a subject steady. “Moira crossed the square. She was stopped at the gate, searched and sent back” keeps us with her. The active version would change subject to the guards and back again.
Another is to put the actor at the end, where the stress falls: The king was poisoned by his own daughter. Here the actor is known and matters a great deal, and the passive saves her for last.
The third is voice. Official reports, legal notices and laboratory notes lean on the passive, and a narrator or character drawn from one of those worlds can too. An evasive character may speak in passives all day long, and the reader will hear the evasion.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is passive?
Only one of these four sentences is passive. Which?
Key takeaway
Put the actor first when the reader knows who it is and cares. Keep the passive for an actor who is unknown, unimportant or held back, and for moments when the reader should stay with the one on the receiving end. To spot a passive, try adding “by someone”. “Was” alone tells you nothing.
