What a head-hop is
Here are two sentences from the middle of a scene.
Two sentences, two heads
Orla watched the lawyer read the will, sure that he was skipping something.1 Mr Quarles wondered how soon he could decently leave.2
- Behind Orla’s eyesSuspicious of the lawyer
- Suddenly inside the lawyerLooking back at her; nothing marked the move
Orla watched the lawyer read the will, sure that he was skipping something. Mr Quarles wondered how soon he could decently leave.
Each sentence is fine alone. Together they are a head-hop. For the first, the reader is behind Orla’s eyes, suspicious of the lawyer. For the second, the reader is suddenly inside the lawyer, looking back at her. Nothing marked the move.
A head-hop is a change of viewpoint character inside a scene, made without preparing the reader. It is not the same thing as omniscient narration, where one steady narrator stands above everybody from the first line. In a head-hop there is no such narrator. The scene just swaps one inside view for another.
What it costs, and where slips hide
A reader settles into a viewpoint the way you settle into a seat. From there they know whose worries to share and whose face to watch. Each hop makes them get up and sit down somewhere else. After enough hops they stop sitting down, and watch the scene from the aisle, close to nobody. Hops also spend your secrets. Once we are told what the lawyer is thinking, Orla’s suspicion has no work left to do.
- A feeling stated for him“Mr Quarles was bored”; she could only see he looked bored
- A motive on an action“…to hide the last paragraph”; the folding she sees, the purpose is his
- The camera turned on her“Orla’s eyes darkened”; “Orla did not notice…”
The obvious slip states another person’s thought. The quieter ones are worth learning to see. One is a feeling stated flatly for someone else: “Mr Quarles was bored”, where the viewpoint character could only report that he looked bored. Another is a motive attached to an action: “He folded the page to hide the last paragraph.” Orla can see the folding; the purpose is his. A third turns the camera on the viewpoint character: “Orla’s eyes darkened”, or “Orla did not notice the clerk slip out.” If she did not notice, who is telling us? An omniscient narrator could say it, and so could a first-person narrator looking back who tells us how they found out. In a scene held inside one head, moment by moment, there is nobody to say it.
The repair is much the same each time. Give the viewpoint character something to see or hear, and let her, and the reader, draw the conclusion.
Example
One head, two people
The lawyer in this scene is hiding something and is nervous about it. We are told neither thing. Everything comes through Orla.
Orla had chosen the chair nearest the door, and regretted it. From there she could see only the back of the page.1 Mr Quarles read in a flat, quick voice. The house to her brother. The orchard to the church. He turned the sheet over, and for the length of a breath he said nothing at all2.
His thumb moved up the margin and stopped.3
“There are some small bequests,” he said, “which need not detain us.” He squared the pages against the desk, twice, and a drop of sweat ran from his hairline into his collar, though the room was cold enough for coats4.
Her brother was already reaching for his hat. Orla stayed where she was. Lawyers, in her experience, did not sweat over small bequests.5
- “From there she could see only the back of the page.”An anchor. Her position in the room limits what she can see, which tells us in the first lines whose eyes we are using.
- “for the length of a breath he said nothing at all”A pause can be observed. We are not told what caused it.
- “His thumb moved up the margin and stopped.”Behaviour only. A head-hop would have written “He found the clause he had been dreading.”
- “a drop of sweat ran from his hairline into his collar, though the…”His nerves are plain, and they are shown from outside. “Cold enough for coats” is Orla’s sense of the room, so even the weather stays in her head.
- “Lawyers, in her experience, did not sweat over small bequests.”The conclusion is drawn by the viewpoint character, in her own terms. The reader has reached it a moment before her, which is a pleasure a head-hop would have taken away.
Before and after
The same scene, hopping and holding
The one faultThe scene begins in Wystan’s head and twice jumps into the captain’s.
Wystan laid the sword on the cloth and stepped back, the way he had been taught. His hands wanted to go on holding it. Three weeks of work, and the groove down the blade was still not quite straight. He could see the flaw from here.
The captain picked it up. She noticed the crooked groove at once and decided it did not matter, because the balance was the best she had felt in years. She cut the air twice.
“Who made this?” she said.
“I did.” Wystan’s ears were burning. She thought he looked about twelve, and wondered whether the old smith knew what he had in his forge.
“Then you’ll make me nine more,” she said.
The first paragraph is Wystan’s: his hands, his three weeks, his view of the flaw. Then the first version hops. We are told that the captain notices the groove and decides it does not matter, and later that she thinks he looks about twelve. Both are her private thoughts. The scene’s only question is whether she will like the sword, and the hop answers it two lines early. Her last line arrives with no surprise in it.
The second version shows the same two moments from where Wystan is standing. Her eye stops on the blade at the place he feared. Her eyebrows go up. She looks him over like a doubtful buyer. He does not know what any of it means, and so neither do we, until she speaks. Nothing about the captain has been lost. It has only been moved to the outside of her.
The exception
When to break it
You can change viewpoint as often as the story needs at a scene or chapter break. Name the new viewpoint character in the first line or two and give them a perception that could only be theirs, and the reader will move with you.
Changing heads the reader can follow
- At a scene or chapter breakAs often as the story needs
- Name the new viewpointIn the first line or two
- A perception only theirsAnd the reader moves with you
A narrator that is omniscient from page one is not head-hopping when it visits several minds; that is its job.
Some writers also shift viewpoint inside a scene on purpose, most often where both sides of a moment matter, as in a love scene. A shift of this kind tends to work when it happens once, at a clear turning point, in a new paragraph that opens with the new character’s name. It tends to fail when it goes back and forth line by line. Comedy sometimes uses a quick hop for a punchline. In each case the test is whether the reader can tell it was meant.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which line hops?
This scene is told from Katya’s viewpoint. She is sitting across a café table from Pavel. Which sentence leaves her head?
Key takeaway
Within a scene, choose one person and stay behind their eyes. Other people’s thoughts, feelings and motives belong on the outside of them, as things your viewpoint character can see and hear and wonder about. If you need another head, take it at a break and say at once whose it is.
