Every extra head has a price
The lesson on POV discipline ended with a permission: change viewpoint at a scene or chapter break, and say at once whose head it is. A novel that uses that permission as a plan faces decisions a single-viewpoint novel does not.
Does this head pay for itself?
- Knowledge nobody else has
- A place nobody else can go
- A way of seeingThat changes what the events mean
The first is the cast. Each viewpoint gives the reader another person to be close to, and takes time away from the rest. With one viewpoint the reader stays put. With six, every return is after an absence, and the reader has to pick up five dropped threads in turn. So each viewpoint should pay for itself. A fair test is to ask what the reader gets from this head that they could get from no other: knowledge nobody else has, a place nobody else can go, a way of seeing that changes what the events mean.
A character who narrates only one or two scenes deserves the hardest look. Sometimes that scene is the only way to show something the book needs. Often it is a convenience: the writer needed a camera in a room, and promoted whoever was standing there.
Whose scene, and how to hand it over
The second decision comes scene by scene. When two or three viewpoint characters are in the room, who tells it?
Whose scene, and the handoff
- The most at stake tells itThe one who stands to lose, to choose or to be caught
- A tie? Who knows leastA discovery is strongest from inside
- Hand over in the first linesName them, place them, say when
- A thought only they would haveEvery line read in the wrong head is read again
The usual answer is the person with the most at stake in that scene: the one who stands to lose something, who has to choose, or who is hiding something and might be caught. Their fear and their reasoning are what the scene has to offer, and only their head has them. A second question helps when the first is a tie: who knows least? A discovery is strongest from inside the person making it.
The third decision is the handoff. After the break the reader does not know they have changed heads until you tell them, and every line read in the wrong head has to be read again. So do it in the first sentence or two. Name the new viewpoint character. Place them, and say when this is in relation to what we have just read. Then give them a perception or a thought that could only be theirs.
The handoff is easier when the heads sound different: each viewpoint needs its own vocabulary and opinions. Ideally a reader could open the book at random and know within a paragraph whose section it is.
Example
A break, and what it buys
The asterisks mark a section break between two viewpoint characters. Notice what the reader knows at the end that Naoko does not.
Whoever had been in the flat had watered the plants. Naoko stood in the hall with her keys still in her hand and looked at the wet soil, and could not think of one person who would break in to do that1.
* * *
Deniz had been parked across the road since four.2 His coffee was cold, and he was fairly sure he had killed the fern3. You were supposed to water them from underneath. His mother had told him so often enough.4 But he had been in a hurry, with the microphone still to fix behind the bookcase, and the plants had looked so dry.
The hall light came on behind her blind.5 He wrote 19.42 in the notebook, and under it, because nobody else read the notebook: she looks tired6.
- “could not think of one person who would break in to do that”Her section ends on a question she cannot answer. Another head can, and that is the reason to change heads here.
- “Deniz had been parked across the road since four.”The handoff, in nine words: a name first, then where he is and for how long. The reader is out of the flat before the sentence ends.
- “he was fairly sure he had killed the fern”The question from the last section is answered inside two sentences. From here the reader knows more than Naoko, and every scene in her flat will be read with that knowledge.
- “His mother had told him so often enough.”A thought only he could have, in a rueful voice that is nothing like hers. A second viewpoint should sound like a second person.
- “The hall light came on behind her blind.”The same moment that ended her section, seen from the street. One line ties the two sections together in time without retelling anything.
- “she looks tired”What this viewpoint is for. The man watching her is not what she would imagine, and only his head can show that.
Before and after
The same handoff, late and early
The one faultThe new section does not say whose head it is, or where, until its last sentence.
Selma counted the sails twice from the harbour wall. Eleven. There had been twelve when they left.
* * *
There were so many of them, and from here they all looked alike. It would have been worth a year’s pay to be able to signal. That was not allowed. There was nothing to do but hold on and watch the wall come nearer, and try to work out how to say the name of the ship that was missing. His mother would be third from the steps, because she always was. Leon Coates shifted his grip on the mainmast of the Providence.
After the break both versions give the same facts in almost the same sentences. The first puts them in an order that hides the change.
A reader coming off Selma’s count of the sails takes “There were so many of them” as hers, and “them” as the ships. “Watch the wall come nearer” makes no sense for a woman standing on it, and “his mother” is a jolt. Only the final sentence gives a name and a mast, and the reader has to go back and read the paragraph again as someone else.
The second version leads with the place, the name and one linking phrase, “was counting too”, which echoes the last section and tells us this is the same minute seen from the water. Every sentence after that is read in the right head the first time.
The exception
When to break it
The person with the most at stake is the default, not the only choice. Tell a scene from the watcher when the one at the centre has to keep a secret from the reader, as with a detective whose reasoning you want to hold back. Or when the watching is the point: someone who can only stand by while a person they love decides.
Defaults, not rules
A viewpoint used once can earn its place. Some thrillers open with a chapter from a character who never narrates again. The test is unchanged: the reader gets something there that no regular viewpoint could give.
Retelling an event from a second head is usually a stall. It is worth doing when the second account changes what the first one meant.
Viewpoints do not need equal shares, or a fixed rotation. And a chapter headed with the character’s name makes the handoff simple, though the first lines should still sound like that person.
If you find you want every head in every scene, consider whether the book wants an omniscient narrator, set up from the first page, and not a crowd of limited ones.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
The cleanest handoff
A novel alternates between Willa, a ferry pilot, and Oskar, her estranged brother. The last section was Willa’s, on the river. Which first sentence of the next section hands over to Oskar most clearly?
Key takeaway
Give a character a viewpoint only if their head offers something no other can. Give each scene to the person with the most at stake in it. At every change, name the new viewpoint character in the first sentence or two, place them in space and time, and let them sound like themselves.
