Lesson 7 of 22
Plot Bridges · stone 7Intermediate6 minute read

Try-fail cycles

Attempts that end “yes, but” or “no, and” so progress always costs something.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

Plot Bridges: three different bridges hopping across small islands, each leading on to the next.
Plot Bridges · Plot and structure, stone 7 of 22

Four ways an attempt can end

Between the moment a protagonist commits and the moment the story is decided, they try things. Each attempt asks a small question: does this work? There are four possible answers.

The two answers with a second half leave the story somewhere new, and that is where the next scene begins.

Yes. The attempt works and nothing goes wrong.

No. The attempt fails and nothing else changes.

Yes, but. The attempt works, and it brings a cost or a new problem with it. She gets the letter, but she is seen taking it.

No, and. The attempt fails, and it makes things worse. She does not get the letter, and now they have changed the lock.

The phrases are widely taught in writing workshops and podcasts. Nobody seems sure who first applied them to plotting.

A plain yes lets the tension out, because the problem has shrunk and nothing has taken its place. A plain no is a dead end, since the character is back where they stood with one fewer idea. The other two answers both leave the story somewhere new, and that new place is where the next scene begins.

What a cycle should leave behind

A run of attempts is called a try-fail cycle, and three things make one work.

A run of attempts works when each one changes the situation, causes its own trouble and tries something new.

Each attempt changes the situation. After it the character has gained or lost something: information, an ally, time, a hiding place, the use of an arm.

The complication grows out of the attempt. If she is caught because she chose the front gate, she did that, and the chain of cause holds. If she is caught because a storm happened to bring the guards indoors, the author did it.

Each attempt is a different approach. A character who tries the same door three times looks slow, and one who tries the door, then the window, then the person holding the key is learning.

A warning for anyone who takes this up with enthusiasm: an unbroken run of “no, and” is as flat as a run of “yes”. The protagonist begins to look incompetent and the reader goes numb. “Yes, but” is what lets a story make real progress and still keep its pressure.

Example

Three tries at one card

A sequence from a thriller. Name the answer at the end of each attempt.

The key cardthriller

Ignacio Barros needed the night clerk’s key card, and he needed the clerk not to know it was gone.

He tried the simple way first. He carried a coffee across the lobby, stumbled, and put a hand on the clerk’s jacket to steady himself. The card was not in the jacket. And the clerk, mopping his sleeve, now knew his face.1

So the face had to become useful.2 Ignacio came back at two with a story about a friend in room 412 who was not answering her phone. The clerk took him up to the fourth floor himself and opened the corridor door with the card, which hung on a cord inside his shirt. But he did not go back down.3 He waited in the corridor to see the friend open her door.

Nobody was in 412. Ignacio knocked, shrugged, turned with an apology ready, and walked into the clerk shoulder first. This time he knew where the card was. He had it in his palm4 before they had finished saying sorry to each other. But the clerk would reach for it at the next locked door, and the next locked door was thirty steps away5.

  1. “The card was not in the jacket. And the clerk, mopping his sleeve,…”No, and. He fails, and he has spent his anonymity. The second sentence is the “and”.
  2. “So the face had to become useful.”The next attempt is built from the cost of the last one. He cannot be a stranger now, so he becomes a guest with a story.
  3. “But he did not go back down.”Yes, but. He has learned where the card is kept and reached the fourth floor. The price is a witness at his elbow.
  4. “He had it in his palm”Yes. This is the first thing he has won outright, and it is his third method: a collision, after a spill and a story.
  5. “the next locked door was thirty steps away”But. The win comes with a clock. He has the card for as long as it takes the clerk to walk thirty steps.

Before and after

Three refusals, twice

The one faultEvery attempt ends in a plain no, so nothing carries from one attempt to the next.

Weaker versionThe list, version one

Ragnhild Aas had three days to get her brother’s name off the conscription list.

On the first day she went to the parish clerk and asked him to strike it out. He refused.

On the second day she took her mother’s savings to the recruiting officer. He would not take them.

On the third day she went to the colonel’s wife, who would not see her.

On the fourth morning the soldiers came.

Showing the weaker version.

In both versions Ragnhild goes to the same three people on the same three days, and none of them gives her what she asks for.

In the first version each refusal is a shut door. On the second morning she is exactly where she was on the first, a day older. The three attempts could be put in any order, or cut to one, and the fourth morning would be the same.

In the second version every answer leaves something behind. The clerk’s no comes with a rule (names can only be replaced) and a cost (her address in the book). The rule shapes the second attempt. The officer’s answer is a yes that turns into a loss. The third no comes with a door she had not known was there. By the fourth morning her position has changed three times, and the last line follows from all of it. The events are the same refusals. What has been added is the “and” or the “but” after each.

The exception

When to break it

Plain answers have their uses.

Keep the clean yes and the flat no for the places where you want the tension to drop.

A clean yes early in a book shows that the protagonist is good at something, which earns trust and makes later failures mean more. It also gives the reader a rest. Comedy and heist stories are fond of a clean yes that turns out, three scenes on, to have been a trap.

A plain no can be used on purpose to close off the easy answer. If the reader is wondering why she does not simply go to the police, one short scene in which the police say no settles it, and it needs no “and”.

Gentler books, such as a cosy mystery or a quiet romance, tend to keep the costs small. That is a choice of scale. A lost afternoon can be a real “but” if the afternoon mattered.

At the climax and after it, clean answers are what the reader has been waiting for. The pattern belongs to the middle.

And treat the four labels as a way of reading a draft. They are poor material for building one. If you plot by alternating them, the reader will hear the machinery.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Which is “yes, but”?

A thief tries to open a safe. Which of these outcomes is a “yes, but”?

Key takeaway

In the middle of a story, give each attempt an answer with a second half: yes, but something is lost, or no, and something is worse. Let that second half come from the way the character tried, and let it shape what they try next. Keep the clean yes and the flat no for the places where you want the tension to drop.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Try it on your own pages

Choose a passage from your own book where this matters: try-fail cycles. Read it against the checklist, then revise the weakest part.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.