The scene the whole story has been walking towards
Early on, a story raises one main question. Will she win the farm back? Will he tell the truth about the fire? Writers call this the dramatic question, and it usually has a yes-or-no answer.
Question, answer, aftermath
- The dramatic questionWill she win the farm back?
- The climaxThe last and hardest confrontation answers it for good
- The resolutionThe new state of things: a chapter, a paragraph or a line
The climax is the scene where that question is answered for good. It is the last and hardest confrontation between the protagonist (the person the story is mainly about) and whatever stands in their way.
The resolution is what comes after: a short stretch that shows the reader the new state of things. It can be a chapter, a paragraph or a single line.
What makes a climax feel earned
A climax feels earned when the protagonist decides it. Three common endings take the decision out of their hands.
An earned climax
- They chooseWhen they could have done otherwise
- It costs themSomething they care about
- It was already thereEverything it uses, where the reader could have seen it
Coincidence: luck settles it. The storm arrives, or the gun jams.
Rescue: somebody else settles it. The cavalry rides in.
New information: a fact or ability the reader has not seen before settles it. The hero turns out to be immune to the poison.
The complaint is an old one. In the Poetics, Aristotle says the unravelling of a plot should come out of the plot itself and not from the crane that lowered a god onto the Greek stage. That crane gave us the term deus ex machina, “god from the machine”.
The repair is the same in all three cases. Put the outcome back in the protagonist’s hands, and make sure three things are true. They choose, when they could have done otherwise. The choice costs them something they care about. And everything the choice uses was already in the story, where the reader could have seen it.
Example
A choice, a cost, an aftermath
By this point in the novel the reader knows two things. The marsh bell can be heard right across the drowned road. And it is cracked: Aveline’s old master made her promise not to ring it until it could be recast.
The lanterns of the salt caravan were already out on the drowned road, forty of them strung across the marsh in the dark, and the tide was coming in behind the fog where no driver could see it.
Aveline had the mallet in her hand. She had carried it up the tower to wedge the shutters, nothing more.1
The bell hung above her with the crack running down its lip like a seam in a sleeve. Old Hesk had made her promise. Ring it cracked and it splits.2 Ring it cracked and the marsh has no bell at all, girl, not in your time and not in your children’s.
She could run down and shout.3 They would not hear her from the first bridge, let alone the road.
She set her feet, and swung.4
The note went out flat and enormous. On the second stroke something in the bronze gave with a sound like a plank breaking, and she struck it a third time anyway5, and a fourth, until the lanterns on the road began, one after another, to turn.
In the morning the bell lay in two pieces on the tower floor, and the caravan master’s daughter was asleep in Aveline’s bed.6
- “She had carried it up the tower to wedge the shutters, nothing more.”The means is already in her hand, and it got there for an ordinary reason. Nothing arrives at the last minute.
- “Ring it cracked and it splits.”The price, named before the choice. The reader knows exactly what a yes will destroy.
- “She could run down and shout.”An easier way out is looked at and ruled out. Without it, ringing the bell would be the only thing to do, and no choice at all.
- “She set her feet, and swung.”The climax, in six words. Nobody tells her to do it and nobody does it for her.
- “she struck it a third time anyway”She goes on choosing after the cost has started to fall due.
- “In the morning the bell lay in two pieces on the tower floor, and…”The resolution: what was lost and what was saved, in one sentence, with no comment.
Before and after
The same car park, decided two ways
The one faultThe outcome is decided by a rescuer who turns up by chance. Noemi herself decides nothing.
Level three of the car park was empty except for her car and his.
“The drive, Ms Sarkis.” Kreutz held out a gloved hand. “Then you go home, and on Monday you are a senior accountant again.”
Noemi had the drive in her coat pocket and her phone in her fist. The file was attached. The address of the fraud office was typed in. She had not pressed send in four days, because page nine carried her own signature, on eleven transfers.
“Monday,” Kreutz said. “Your desk. Your pension.”
Her thumb would not move.
Then headlights swung up the ramp. A security van on its hourly round slowed beside them, and the guard wound his window down. “Everything all right, miss?”
Kreutz looked at the van, at the camera on its roof, and lowered his hand. He walked to his car without hurrying.
Noemi got into hers and locked the doors. The email was still sitting there, unsent.
The two versions are word for word the same down to “Her thumb would not move.”
In the first version a security van arrives and Kreutz leaves. Noemi is safe, but the email is still unsent. The question the story has been asking (will she give them up, knowing it gives her up too?) has not been answered. It has been postponed by a man on his hourly round.
In the second version nobody comes. She looks at her own signature and sends the file anyway. Kreutz leaves for a different reason: there is nothing left to take. The last paragraph has changed as well, because the outcome has. She needs a lawyer now. That is the cost.
The exception
When to break it
Not every good ending is a win the protagonist chooses. In tragedy the protagonist’s choice decides the outcome, and the outcome is ruin. That is still an earned climax. Stories about powerlessness, which include a good deal of horror and war fiction, may put the outcome beyond anyone’s control on purpose. The climactic choice then becomes how the character meets what they cannot stop.
Endings the rule allows
A rescue can work when the protagonist earned the rescuer earlier, by sparing them or winning them over, so that the help is the late result of a choice. Bad luck is easier to accept than good: a coincidence that makes things worse rarely feels like cheating.
Resolutions vary just as much. A long novel with many threads may need a chapter of aftermath. A short story may stop on the climax’s last beat and trust the reader to feel the rest.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Who decides?
Four climaxes, each in one sentence. In which one does the protagonist’s own choice decide the outcome?
Key takeaway
At the climax, find the sentence after which the outcome is certain and look at who is acting in it. If it is the weather, a rescuer or a convenient new fact, give the moment back to your protagonist: let them choose, let it cost them, and let them use only what the story already holds. Then show, briefly, what is different afterwards.
