Lesson 17 of 22
Plot Bridges · stone 17Intermediate6 minute read

The crime and the investigation

A crime novel holds two stories: what the culprit did, worked out in full and mostly hidden, and the investigation that uncovers it, which is the story on the page.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-14

Plot Bridges: three different bridges hopping across small islands, each leading on to the next.
Plot Bridges · Plot and structure, stone 17 of 22

Two stories, one on the page

A crime novel tells two stories at once. The first is the crime: what the culprit wanted, what they did and what they did afterwards to stay hidden. It happens mostly before the book opens, or out of sight while it runs. The second is the investigation: someone noticing that something is wrong and working out what. That is the story the reader watches.

The investigation runs backwards over the crime story, and it can only find what the crime story left behind.

The two run in opposite directions. The crime story moves forward from a plan to a body. The investigation moves backwards from the body towards the plan, and the reader feels the crime story only as it is pieced together.

This is why a mystery is hard to write by discovery alone. The investigation can only find what the crime story left behind. If you do not know what happened, every clue is a guess, and the solution has to be made to fit afterwards. Readers can often feel the joins.

Write the culprit’s timeline

Before you draft, write the crime story as a timeline: actions, with times and places, from the culprit’s point of view. Three stretches matter.

Every action in the crime story leaves a trace, and the list of traces is where your clues come from.

The plan: what they did to get ready. Things bought, borrowed, arranged or lied about.

The act: what happened, where, and in what order.

The cover-up: what they did afterwards to hide it. An alibi built, a thing destroyed, a story told. Writers often skip this part, and it is the richest, because every attempt to hide something is an action, and actions leave traces.

Then list the traces. Each action in the timeline leaves something behind: a receipt, a smell, a lie that does not match another lie, a habit broken. That list is your menu of clues. The investigation will find some of them, miss some, and misread one or two. Add the movements of anyone else who was near the crime, because innocent people with something to hide make your false trails.

Example

A crime story on one page

A writer’s timeline for a village mystery, written before chapter one. None of it appears on the page in this form.

The Lamb at Hallow Cross: the crime storymystery

Culprit: Owen Pryce, the landlord’s brother-in-law. Victim: Dilys Rowe, who keeps the inn’s books.

Why: Dilys has found that Owen sells the inn’s spirits out of the back door and keeps the money. She tells him she will go to his sister on Friday.

Thursday, 14.00. Owen buys rat poison at the farm supplier in town. He signs the poisons book in his own name, because he buys it every autumn.1

19.30. He offers to take Dilys her cocoa, as he sometimes does. Poison in the cocoa. He washes the pan and hangs it back on the wrong hook.2

21.00. He drives to the darts match at the Feathers and makes sure he is seen buying a round3.

Friday, 08.00. Dilys has been found dead. Owen arrives with the others and is the first to say “her heart”, before the doctor has been4.

11.00. He burns her ledger in the incinerator behind the stables. A brass corner of the ledger survives in the ash.

Traces left: the poisons book; the pan on the wrong hook; the round at the Feathers; the brass corner; “her heart”.5

  1. “He signs the poisons book in his own name, because he buys it ever…”A trace with a reason. Owen is not careless; he does what he always does, which is why the act will not stand out until someone looks.
  2. “He washes the pan and hangs it back on the wrong hook.”The cover-up leaves its own trace. Someone who knows the kitchen will see the pan before they know why it matters.
  3. “makes sure he is seen buying a round”An alibi is an action too. Anything built can be tested, and the effort that went into building it can itself look odd.
  4. “is the first to say “her heart”, before the doctor has been”A trace made of words. Lies and premature answers are as useful to an investigation as objects.
  5. “Traces left: the poisons book; the pan on the wrong hook; the roun…”The menu of clues. The investigation story will be built from this list.

The hidden story keeps moving

The crime story does not stop when the crime is done. The culprit is still there while the investigation runs, and they know more about it than anyone. When the detective asks for the ledger, the culprit burns it. When a witness starts to remember, the culprit visits her. Each of those acts is a new event in the hidden story, and each one pushes the story on the page: a new problem for the investigator, and a new trace.

In a thriller the hidden story is often the antagonist’s plan, still in motion, and the reader may be shown parts of it directly. The principle is the same. Know what the other side is doing at every stage, even when you show none of it, and let the lead’s progress provoke a response.

Before and after

Who broke the alibi?

The one faultThe alibi breaks because of something from outside the crime story, not because of anything the culprit did.

Weaker versionThe concert programme (first version)

Inspector Carrow had Mrs Dunmore’s statement in front of him. Her husband had been at the chapel concert all evening; she had sat beside him. It was a good alibi, and it held until the Tuesday, when a carter who happened to pass the Dunmore yard that night came forward. He had seen a lamp lit in the workshop at nine, and a man at the bench.

“You’re sure of the time?” Carrow asked.

“Sure as I’m sitting here.”

Showing the weaker version.

Both versions break the same alibi at the same point in the story.

In the first, it breaks because a carter happened to pass the yard. He has no connection to the crime, and the writer could have sent him at any time. The investigation has not found anything; it has been handed something.

In the second, it breaks because of Dunmore himself. To build his alibi he went to the afternoon concert to get a programme, and he kept it carefully, because a careful man would. The proof of the alibi becomes the proof against it. The clue came from the crime story, so it feels found rather than delivered, and it tells us something about Dunmore as well.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Some writers find their culprit while drafting, and some of them do it well. If you discover your crime story as you go, write the timeline as soon as you know it, then revise the earlier chapters so every clue traces back to it. The timeline still has to exist by the final draft.

Some crime stories show the crime story first. In an inverted mystery the reader watches the culprit plan and act in the opening chapters, and the pleasure lies in watching the investigator close in. The two stories are the same; only the order of telling has changed, and the timeline matters even more, because the reader knows it too.

And not every thriller has a culprit with a timeline. A storm, a pandemic or a failing dam can be the threat. Even then, write down what the threat does and when, so the lead has something definite to race.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

The warm kettle

A writer plans a scene in which her detective finds the victim’s kettle still warm, two hours after the time of death the culprit wants everyone to believe. Before she drafts the scene, what does she most need to know?

Key takeaway

A crime novel is two stories: the crime, told forwards and mostly hidden, and the investigation that works backwards over it. Write the culprit’s timeline first, including the cover-up, and list the traces each action leaves. Your clues come from that list, and the culprit keeps acting while the investigation runs.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Your crime story

Write your culprit’s timeline (the plan, the act and the cover-up), list the traces each action leaves, and note what the culprit does once the investigation starts.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.