Work back from the solution
The lesson on mystery, under Genre conventions, covers fair play and how to hide a single clue in plain sight. This lesson is about the whole trail: which clues the book needs, and where they go.
A solution as a chain
- The questionWho did it, or how
- Step oneRests on a fact the reader has seen
- Step twoRests on another fact, or on plain logic
- The solutionEvery step can be found on an earlier page
Start from the end. Write the solution as a chain of small steps, each following from the one before. The clock was stopped by hand; so she died later than everyone thinks; so the organist’s alibi covers nothing; and only he could get into the tower.
Now ask of each step: what fact on the page lets a reader take it? Some steps are plain logic and need nothing. The rest need at least one clue, placed before the reveal. Set it out as a clue map: the step, the fact that supports it, and the chapter where the reader meets the fact. A step with no fact beside it is a hole in the trail, and readers who go back looking will fall into it.
Spread them out
Once you have the clues, place them across the book. Clues bunched together near the end have two costs. The middle of the book has nothing for the investigation to find, so it seems to stand still. And a cluster of facts just before the reveal tells the reader where to look.
Bunched or spread
A few habits help. Put some clues in the opening chapters, before the reader knows which facts will matter. Place a clue while attention is on something else: another suspect, a quarrel, a meal. Keep the decisive clue well clear of the reveal, so the reader has had time to file it under something ordinary. And check for long gaps; a stretch with no clue at all is often a stretch where the detective has stopped detecting.
More than one road
Readers miss things. That is the point of hiding them. But if the step the whole solution depends on rests on a single clue, a reader who missed it will feel cheated at the reveal, however fair the book was.
So give the key steps more than one road. Two or three small, separate facts, in different scenes, each pointing the same way. A reader who catches one can reach the conclusion; a reader who catches none will, at the reveal, remember at least one of them and feel the click. Several small clues also make the detective’s conclusion feel earned rather than lucky, because it no longer hangs on a single find.
The less important steps can live on one clue, or on logic alone.
Example
A clue map
A writer’s map for a village mystery, made before the second draft.
The solution, in four steps.1
1. The church clock was stopped at 3.40 by hand, not by the frost.
2. So she died later than everyone thinks.
3. So the organist’s alibi, which runs from 3.30 to 4.00, covers nothing.
4. And only the organist has a working key to the clock tower.
Step 1. Chapter 3: the verger, listing his winter jobs, says the clock never stops in frost because the works are indoors.2 Chapter 11: a smear of organ-loft dust on the inside of the clock glass.
Step 2. Chapter 6: the vicar’s wife hears the dog bark at a quarter to five. Chapter 9: the tea in the dead woman’s flask is still warm when she is found.
Step 3. Follows from step 2.3 Chapter 14: the organist gives his alibi before anyone has asked for it.
Step 4. Chapter 2: the tower key is on the organist’s ring among a dozen others, seen when he locks the vestry.4 Chapter 15: the spare key is found rusted into its lock.
Clues fall in chapters 2, 3, 6, 9, 11, 14 and 15. The reveal is chapter 19.5
- “The solution, in four steps.”The map starts from the end, with the reasoning broken into steps small enough to check.
- “Chapter 3: the verger, listing his winter jobs, says the clock nev…”An early clue, placed inside a list about something else, long before the reader knows the clock matters.
- “Step 3. Follows from step 2.”A step of plain logic needs no clue of its own. The writer adds one anyway, a small oddity of behaviour.
- “Chapter 2: the tower key is on the organist’s ring among a dozen o…”The decisive fact, placed in chapter 2, in a crowd of other keys, while he is doing something ordinary.
- “Clues fall in chapters 2, 3, 6, 9, 11, 14 and 15. The reveal is ch…”The spacing check. No long gaps, no cluster beside the reveal, and every step that needs a fact has two.
Before and after
The same clues, placed twice
The one faultThe clues are bunched into the two chapters before the reveal.
The reveal is chapter 20.
Step 1. The wards were opened from inside. Clue: scorch marks on the inner face of the archive door. Chapter 17.
Step 2. So the killer was inside when the archive was sealed. Clue: a second cup, still wet, in the reading room. Chapter 17.
Step 3. Only the copyist stays past the sealing. Clue: the copyist’s green ink on the dead man’s cuff. Chapter 18.
Step 4. The dawn bell, which can only be rung from inside, rang an hour early. Clue: the baker complains that the bell got him up in the dark. Chapter 18.
The steps and the clues are identical. Only the chapters have changed.
In the first map, the scorch marks, the cup, the ink and the bell all arrive in chapters 17 and 18. For sixteen chapters the investigation has nothing to find, and then the reader is handed four facts in quick succession, just before the explanation. They will feel signposted, and they are.
In the second, the same facts are spread from chapter 3 to chapter 16. Each one has time to be filed under something ordinary (scorch marks on a warded door, a baker grumbling about the bell) before the reveal gathers them up.
The exception
When to break it
Some mysteries put many clues in one early scene on purpose: the full inventory of a locked room, or the first walk through the crime scene. That is not bunching in the harmful sense, because the clues arrive early, among dozens of ordinary details, and the conclusions are drawn much later.
A thriller usually has no puzzle for the reader to solve, so it has no clue map. It has something close to one: the setups its climax will use, which need the same planning and the same spacing.
And a short story cannot always afford two roads to every step. In a very short mystery a single well-hidden clue, with a reveal that recalls it plainly, may be all the form can carry.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The clue nobody saw
The step your whole solution depends on rests on one clue, in chapter 6. Two early readers missed it, and both said the reveal felt like a cheat. What is the best fix?
Key takeaway
Write the solution as a chain of small steps, and give each step that is not plain logic a fact on the page before the reveal. Spread the clues from the early chapters on, keep the decisive one well clear of the reveal, and give the step everything depends on more than one road.
