A second story with a job to do
A subplot is a second, smaller line of story running through a book. It has its own want and its own outcome, and it usually belongs to a secondary character or to another part of the protagonist’s life.
A subplot’s three jobs
- PressureMakes the main problem harder: time, money, an ally
- MirrorThe same problem, the same answer: where that road leads
- ContrastThe same problem, the other way: what is given up
A subplot earns its pages by doing something to the main plot. There are three common jobs.
Pressure. The subplot makes the main problem harder. It takes away time, money or an ally, or it adds a deadline.
Mirror. Someone else faces a version of the protagonist’s problem and answers it the same way. The reader sees where that road leads.
Contrast. Someone faces the same problem and goes the other way. The reader sees what the protagonist is giving up, or escaping.
A quick test is to lift the subplot out. If the main plot’s ending does not change and does not mean less, the subplot is running beside the story and not through it.
Braiding
Braiding is the order in which you cut between the lines. Three habits help.
Cutting between the lines
- Leave on a questionNot at a point of rest
- Come back in timeBefore the question goes stale
- Let the lines collideOnce to complicate, once near the end
- Settle smaller lines firstThe main question is the last one standing
Leave a line when it has just raised a question. If you cut away at a point of rest, nothing pulls the reader back.
Come back before the question goes stale. A line left alone for a hundred pages has to be introduced almost from scratch.
Let the lines collide. A collision is a scene where people or consequences from both lines are in the same room, and one line changes the other. A subplot that meets the main plot at least twice, once to complicate it and once near the end, tends to feel woven in. One that does not meet it at all feels like a second book.
As the climax nears, the lines usually draw together. Smaller lines are commonly settled first, just before the climax or inside it, so that the main question is the last one standing.
Example
A collision
The main plot of this historical novel is Bethan’s hearing for a midwife’s licence. The subplot, followed through earlier chapters, is her brother’s debt to the quarry agent.
Bethan had the testimonials in order by the time the board sat down: nine mothers, the curate, and Dr Lloyd-Pugh in his own hand. She had practised her answers all the way down from Cwm Isaf.
The third chair was the one she had not planned for.1 Mr Scrope, the quarry agent, took it, laid his hat on the table and smiled at her as if they had met at chapel.
“Miss Prys. Your brother is well, I hope?2”
“He is working, sir.”
“I am glad. He will need to be.” Scrope turned a page of her testimonials without reading it. “Fourteen pounds is a long winter’s work.3 I had thought of going to the magistrate on Monday. But a family with a licensed midwife in it is a family with prospects, and I am a patient man with such families.” He looked up. “Or I am not. That rather depends on the board, which is to say on this afternoon.4 Shall we begin with the Hughes confinement?”
The Hughes confinement was the one that had gone wrong.5
- “The third chair was the one she had not planned for.”The collision. A man from the subplot sits down inside the main plot.
- “Your brother is well, I hope?”One line brings the whole subplot into the room. There is no recap, because the reader has followed the debt already.
- “Fourteen pounds is a long winter’s work.”The subplot’s own stake, kept exact.
- “That rather depends on the board, which is to say on this afternoon.”Now the two lines share one outcome. If she loses the licence, her brother goes before the magistrate. The subplot has raised the stakes of the main plot: that is pressure.
- “The Hughes confinement was the one that had gone wrong.”The scene hands back to the main plot, which is harder than it was a page ago.
Before and after
One subplot, outlined twice
The one faultThe subplot does not touch the main plot at any point. The four Kasia beats could be lifted out and the pump story would not change.
1. Main plot. A coolant loop on the orbital greenhouse starts to fail. Wanda has nine days before the wheat dies.
2. Subplot. Her daughter Kasia, a marine engineer, arrives for a visit, their first in six years. Dinner is polite and short.
3. Main plot. The spare pump is faulty. Wanda orders another from the surface.
4. Subplot. Kasia finds her own childhood drawings in a locker and asks why they were kept.
5. Main plot. The new pump arrives. Fitting it means shutting the loop down for a risky hour.
6. Subplot. Mother and daughter argue about the divorce, then make peace over tea.
7. Main plot. Wanda fits the pump with minutes to spare. The wheat lives.
8. Subplot. Kasia leaves on the shuttle. They promise to write.
Beats 1 and 2 are identical in the two outlines, and both end in the same place: the pump fitted with minutes to spare, mother and daughter on better terms.
In the first outline the two lines take turns politely. The visit happens in the gaps between pump scenes. Each Kasia beat ends at a point of rest (a short dinner, peace over tea), so there is nothing to wonder about while the story is away.
In the second, the lines collide twice. At beat 3 the main plot damages the subplot: the repair costs Kasia her two days. At beat 5 the subplot holds the key to the main plot: the pump cannot be fitted without the daughter who is leaving. The old argument now happens with a clock running, and the wheat depends on how it ends. The detail that Kasia is an engineer was in the first outline too, where it did nothing.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of fiction has no subplot. A short story rarely has room for one, and a tight thriller may be stronger for folding every scene into the main line.
Other ways to braid
Some novels keep two lines apart on purpose and bring them together only at the end: a present-day strand and a historical one, say. The late collision is the design. Such books still give the reader echoes to hold on to meanwhile, such as a shared object or a repeated choice. That is mirror and contrast, done at a distance.
In a series a subplot may stay open across volumes. It helps if it visibly moves in each book, so the reader can tell it has been left open and not forgotten.
And a large ensemble novel may have no single main plot to serve. The lines are equals, and the useful question becomes how each one presses on the others.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Alongside or through?
The main plot: Fiammetta, a chef, has six weeks to win back her restaurant’s lost star before the inspectors return. Which of these subplots presses on that main plot?
Key takeaway
A subplot belongs in the book when it does something to the main plot: presses on it, mirrors it or contrasts with it. Cut away from a line when it has just raised a question, bring the lines into the same room at least twice, and settle the smaller line before the larger one. If a subplot could be lifted out without the ending changing, it has not yet been braided in.
