Four kinds of thread
Every story opens things that it will later have to close. The MICE quotient, set out by the novelist Orson Scott Card, sorts those things into four kinds of thread. Each kind is defined by what opens it and what closes it. The short definitions here are this lesson’s summary of his.
What opens it, what closes it
- MilieuOpens on entering a place; closes on leaving, or settling
- IdeaOpens with a question; closes when it is answered
- CharacterOpens on being unhappy with who they are; closes on change
- EventOpens when normal order breaks; closes when order returns
Milieu. Opens when a character enters a place. Closes when they leave it, or settle there.
Idea. Opens with a question. Closes when the question is answered. Some teachers call this thread Inquiry, which says the same thing more plainly.
Character. Opens when a character is unhappy with who they are, or with the role they have been handed. Closes when they change, or accept that they will not.
Event. Opens when something knocks the world out of its normal order. Closes when order returns, or a new order settles.
This is practical knowledge. Once you can say which threads you have opened, you know what your ending owes the reader: an exit, an answer, a change, a settlement. A thread you forget to close is a loose end. And every thread adds length, which is one reason a short story usually carries one or two and a novel can carry many.
Nesting
Threads tend to satisfy most when they close in the reverse of the order they opened: last opened, first closed. The approach is often credited to the writer and teacher Mary Robinette Kowal, and the usual picture is a set of brackets. Open a Milieu thread, then an Idea thread inside it, and the tidy close is the Idea first and the Milieu second: ( [ ] ).
( [ ] )
- Open the MilieuThe frame of the whole story
- Open the IdeaA question inside it
- Close the IdeaLast opened, first closed
- Close the MilieuThe ending lands on the largest promise
The reason is weight. The first thread opened is usually the frame of the whole story, and readers treat it as the largest promise. Close it last and the ending lands on the largest thing. Close it early and whatever remains can feel like business the story forgot to finish.
Example
Three openings in three paragraphs
The start of a fantasy novel. Each paragraph opens one thread.
Nobody crossed the Holm causeway after the autumn tides1, so when Brigitta Havel walked out along it with her mother’s surveying chain over her shoulder2, the keeper of the last house on the shore came to his gate to watch her go.
She had not wanted the chain. She had wanted the post at the Cartographers’ Hall, the desk by the north window, and her name on a map that hung where people could see it. What she had instead was her mother’s unfinished survey and her mother’s reputation, which was for being wrong.3
The island’s church came into sight before the island did. Its tower stood where every chart in the Hall showed open water.4
- “Nobody crossed the Holm causeway after the autumn tides”A place with a clear way in. Milieu threads are easiest to see when the place has an edge.
- “walked out along it with her mother’s surveying chain over her sho…”Milieu opens: she enters the island. It will close when she crosses back, or decides to stay.
- “What she had instead was her mother’s unfinished survey and her mo…”Character opens: Brigitta is unhappy with the role she has inherited. It will close when she makes the role her own or puts it down.
- “Its tower stood where every chart in the Hall showed open water.”Idea opens. No question mark, but the question is plain: why are the charts wrong? Opened last, so by nesting it is answered first, before Brigitta changes and before she leaves.
Before and after
The same boarding party, closed in two orders
The one faultThe outer thread closes before the inner one. She leaves the ship with the question still open, and the answer turns up afterwards.
Petty Officer Ragna Veldkamp went through the Halcyon’s airlock at 0412 with a torch, a camera and forty minutes of air.
The galley was the first strange thing. Six trays sat on the long table, the food on them furred with frost, the spoons laid down mid-meal. Six crew, the register said. No bodies. No suits missing from the rack. So where had they gone?
She searched four decks and found nothing that answered it. In the hydroponics bay she photographed everything, as she had been trained to, until her air alarm chirped. Then she went back through the galley without looking at the trays, cycled the lock, and pushed off towards her own ship’s lights.
Two days later an analyst on the cutter enlarged one of her photographs. The escape hatch in the hydroponics bay had been cut open from the outside, neatly, and beyond it a docking collar of no pattern anyone knew was still clamped to the hull. Somebody had come for them. Somebody with a ship.
Both versions open the same two threads in the same words: Milieu when Ragna goes through the airlock, Idea when she asks where the crew went. Both contain the same answer.
In the first version she leaves the ship with the question unanswered. That closes the Milieu thread, the frame of the story, and the reader leaves with her. The answer then arrives two days later, at a desk, from an analyst we have not met. It is the same fact, but the place that gave it its chill is gone.
In the second version she finds the collar while she is still aboard, with her air running down. The Idea thread closes inside the Milieu thread. Then she leaves, and the story ends as its frame shuts. The analyst is not needed. Nothing else has been changed.
The exception
When to break it
MICE is a way of looking at a draft, not a recipe for one, and the fit is often rough. A quest may be Milieu and Event at once. Two threads can close in a single scene. Do not lose sleep over a label. What matters is noticing what you have opened.
Where the brackets bend
Nesting bends as well. Long novels open and close small threads all the way through, and only the handful of large ones need to nest. A writer may leave the outermost thread open on purpose: the horror story whose question is not answered, the series volume that settles its own trouble and leaves the larger one standing. Readers accept that when it is plainly a choice.
Sometimes closing out of order is the point. A story that answers its mystery and then stays on for a quiet chapter about the detective is saying that the person mattered more than the puzzle. If the detective’s unhappiness was opened first, that ending was nested all along.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
What closes the question?
A story opens with this thread: why has a lamp been lit every night in a lighthouse that has stood empty for a year? Which event closes that thread?
Key takeaway
Each thread has a matched pair: enter and leave, ask and answer, discontent and change, disruption and settlement. List the threads your opening starts, in order, and check that your ending closes each one, most recent first. Where it does not, either you have found a loose end or you have a reason, and it is worth knowing which.
