Three kinds of false trail
A red herring is a trail that leads away from the truth. The lesson on mystery, under Genre conventions, gives the basic rule: give it noise, and explain it honestly when it is dropped. This lesson is about building herrings that earn their pages.
Where false trails come from
- Another secretSomeone hides something real that is not the crime
- A fact read wronglyTrue, with an ordinary cause nobody looked for
- A trail the culprit laidFalse on purpose, and so a clue to who laid it
Most false trails are one of three kinds.
The suspect with another secret. Someone lies, hides or behaves guiltily, and what they are hiding is real but is not the crime: an affair, a debt, an illness, a theft from the till. People with secrets act like people with secrets, so these trails are believable, and they come straight out of character.
The true fact read the wrong way. Blood on the shears, mud on the boots, a car seen at the wrong time. The fact is true. Its ordinary cause is simply not the obvious one.
The trail the culprit laid. False evidence, put there on purpose. This kind is worth most, because once it is seen as laid, it becomes a clue to whoever laid it.
Every herring has its own true story
A false trail is fair when it has a true story of its own, one that existed all along and accounts for everything that made it look guilty. Write that story in your planning notes beside the culprit’s timeline. Where was the choirmaster really? Why was there blood on the shears? Who wrote the letter, and why does it look like the widow’s hand?
When the trail is dropped, tell its true story, briefly. A herring that is simply waved away (“that turned out to be nothing”) leaves the reader feeling that they were played with rather than misled.
The best true stories pay twice. The innocent secret, once confessed, turns out to have kept a witness quiet: the man who lied about his evening was somewhere he saw something. The laid trail, once exposed, tells the detective that someone close to the case wanted her looking the wrong way.
Example
A herring that pays twice
A detective has spent a week on a man who lied about where he was on the night of the killing.
Kemi had been sure of Mr Adair for a week. He had lied about Thursday night, and lied badly1, and in her experience men who lie badly have something worth lying about.
She put the parking ticket on the table between them. Tannery Lane, 21.40.
He looked at it for a long time. Then he said, “My wife thinks I was at choir practice.”2
“And you weren’t.”
“I was at a flat on Tannery Lane. Her name is Ruth Kell. You can ask her. Please don’t ask my wife.”
Kemi wrote the name down. A week’s work went out of the room with it, and the sergeant who had warned her off Adair would enjoy that.3 She looked at the ticket again.
“Tannery Lane runs behind the boatyard,” she said.4
“Yes.”
“Did you see anything at the boatyard? Around ten.”
He hesitated, and for the first time it was not the hesitation of a man protecting himself. “A van. White. Backed right up to the slipway with its lights off. I didn’t say, because then you’d have asked me why I was there.5”
- “He had lied about Thursday night, and lied badly”The noise. A lie is a strong signal, and the reader has followed it for a week alongside her.
- ““My wife thinks I was at choir practice.””The true story arrives in one line. It is ordinary and human, and it explains the lie completely.
- “A week’s work went out of the room with it, and the sergeant who h…”The cost. Time lost, and some standing with a colleague, which the next chapters can use.
- ““Tannery Lane runs behind the boatyard,” she said.”She does not stop at the collapse. The true story puts him somewhere, and she asks what he could see from there.
- “I didn’t say, because then you’d have asked me why I was there.”The second payment. His secret is why a witness stayed silent, and the herring hands the case a new line.
What chasing it costs, and what dropping it gives
A false trail should cost the investigator something to follow: days the clock will not give back, a friendship, a wrong accusation that someone will remember, a risk taken for nothing. A chase that costs nothing is a detour, and readers notice detours.
And its collapse should move the case. A cleared suspect makes the field smaller, so say who is left. An innocent secret, once told, may come with something the person had been keeping back. A laid trail points at the layer. If the detective ends the chapter exactly where she began it, the herring has used up pages and given nothing back.
Thrillers use the same tools under other names: the wrong enemy, chased while the real one moves closer; the friend who seems to betray and turns out to have been protecting. The tests are the same. It has a true story, it costs something, and its fall changes the board.
Before and after
Crossed off, and then what?
The one faultDropping the false trail changes nothing in the case.
The cufflink in the conservatory had kept Inspector Hale busy for a fortnight. It belonged, as it turned out, to the Major, who had lost it at the summer party in June and been too embarrassed to say so, the cufflinks having been a gift from a woman who was not his wife.
Hale crossed the Major off his list and went back to the beginning.
Both versions give the cufflink a true story, and a good one: a lost keepsake from an affair, which explains why the Major kept quiet.
In the first, Hale crosses him off and goes back to the beginning. Two weeks of the book have been spent, and the case is exactly where it was.
In the second, the same crossing-off narrows the field to two, and the second sentence notices a lie that was sitting in plain view. The herring has paid for its pages. The reader leaves the paragraph with a sharper question than they brought to it.
The exception
When to break it
Some herrings are never fully explained, on purpose. A paranoid thriller may leave the reader unsure to the end whether the man on the stairs was following her, because the book is about that uncertainty. That works when the uncertainty is the point, and it reads as carelessness when it is not.
A comic herring, chased with energy and dropped with a laugh, has a place in a cosy mystery, where readers come partly for the company. Even then, the laugh is the payment.
And herrings can be overdone. When every character has a guilty secret, the reader stops weighing any of them. A few well-built false trails do more than a crowd of thin ones.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which herring earns its pages?
Four ways a draft drops the same false trail: the housekeeper, who was seen burning papers the morning after the death. Which works best?
Key takeaway
Build each red herring from a true story of its own: another secret, a fact misread, or a trail the culprit laid. Make it cost the investigator something to chase, tell its true story when it falls, and make the fall move the case: a smaller field, a new fact, a new line.
