The long middle
The second act is the longest stretch of a novel, and the usual place for one to sag. The cause is often simple. The protagonist is given one kind of problem at the first plot point and is still working on that same kind of problem two hundred pages later. The obstacles get bigger, but the reader has seen what a scene in this book looks like and can predict the next one.
Fill in the two blanks
A midpoint shift is the usual cure. Somewhere near the centre, an event changes the nature of the conflict. From there the protagonist faces something of a different kind, and the second half is a different struggle from the first.
Here is a test you can apply to any outline. Fill in two sentences. Before the midpoint, she is trying to ___. After it, she is trying to ___. If the second blank is the first blank plus “harder”, you have an escalation. If the two blanks are different, you have a shift.
What kind of event does it
Two kinds of event tend to produce a shift.
Pride and Prejudice, a little past halfway
- Before the letterShe resists a man she is sure she has judged correctly
- Darcy’s letter“Till this moment, I never knew myself”
- After itShe has to live with having been wrong, and with wanting what she turned down
A revelation: the protagonist learns something that redefines the problem. The search is really a cover-up. The ally is the opponent. The thing they wanted is not worth having.
A reversal of fortune: they win or lose something large, and their position is transformed. The midpoint beat in Blake Snyder’s Save the Cat! is commonly summed up as a false victory or a false defeat. The protagonist seems to have what they wanted, or seems to have lost everything, and neither is the end of it.
Pride and Prejudice has one of the best known. A little past halfway, Darcy proposes, Elizabeth refuses him, and the next morning he hands her a letter. Up to that point her struggle is to resist a man she is sure she has judged correctly. The letter shows her that she has not. “Till this moment, I never knew myself,” she tells herself, and for the rest of the book her difficulty is of another kind: she has to live with having been wrong, and with wanting what she turned down.
Whichever kind you use, the event has to change what the protagonist does. A surprise that astonishes everyone and leaves the plan untouched is decoration.
Example
A search becomes something else
The outline of a mystery, in five paragraphs. Fill in the two blanks as you read.
Sergeant Xanthe Morrow is sent to a fishing town to find a missing harbour pilot, Lazar Whelan.
For the first half she does what a search needs1. She walks his route, drags the inner harbour and questions the crews. The town helps, with boats, flasks of soup, and a hall to work from.
On the ninth day she sends a diver down under the fuel jetty, the one place the crews told her was not worth the trouble2. He brings up Whelan’s pilot bag. In it is a logbook of ships brought in at night3 with no entry at the harbour office, forty of them. The hall she has been working from is rented by the same shipping agent.
After that nobody lends her a boat.4 She stops looking for a man and starts looking at a town5: who signed the lease on the hall, who owns the agent, which of the helpful faces was steering her away from the jetty.
Whelan, when she finds him, is alive, and he is the least of it.
- “she does what a search needs”The first half is one kind of struggle. She is trying to find a man, and the town is on her side.
- “the one place the crews told her was not worth the trouble”The midpoint comes out of her own work in the first half. She sends the diver. Nobody brings her the bag.
- “a logbook of ships brought in at night”A revelation. It does not make the search harder. It shows that the search was the wrong frame.
- “After that nobody lends her a boat.”The conditions change along with the aim. Her allies of the first half are the opposition in the second.
- “She stops looking for a man and starts looking at a town”The two blanks, filled in. Before, she is trying to find Whelan. After, she is trying to find out what a whole town has been doing.
Before and after
Harder, or different
The one faultThe midpoint makes the struggle harder and leaves it the same kind of struggle.
Leif Brannock, a mapmaker’s apprentice, sets out to cross the Glass Desert and bring back water from the well at its centre, because his own town’s well has failed.
First half: he fights the desert. There is the heat, a lamed camel, and a guide who robs him.
Midpoint: a sandstorm hits, the worst yet. He loses two days and most of his food.
Second half: he fights the desert again, with less. He reaches the well, fills his waterskins and turns for home.
The first two paragraphs are the same in both versions.
In the first version the midpoint is a sandstorm. It is a bigger obstacle than the lamed camel, and that is all it is. Fill in the blanks. Before, he is trying to cross a desert. After, he is trying to cross a desert with less food. A reader who has enjoyed the first half is now offered it again.
In the second version he gets what he came for at the midpoint: the well, full. That is a false victory, and it comes with a revelation. His own town’s trouble is caused by this one. Now fill in the blanks. Before, he is trying to survive a crossing. After, he is trying to decide what is owed to two towns, and how to make his own believe him. The struggle has moved from his body to his judgement, and the desert has become scenery.
The exception
When to break it
Not every story has a hinge in the middle, and not every story should.
How large a shift
A short story is often a single movement with no room for one. A survival story or a chase can run on one kind of struggle from start to finish, provided the escalation is steep and the book is short enough that the pattern does not wear out. An episodic novel changes its problem every chapter and has no need of a central turn.
In a book with several viewpoint characters, each line may turn at a different point, and none of them at the centre. “Near the middle” is a loose guide. Nobody should be counting pages.
There is a risk in the other direction. A shift that is too large breaks faith with the opening. A reader who came for a heist and finds a courtroom drama in the second half may feel they have been handed another book. The second struggle should grow out of the first and keep its people, its place and its question.
Last, the false victory and the false defeat become predictable when they are used as a formula. If a reader can see the midpoint coming, look at what it is made of.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which midpoint is a shift?
For the first half of a thriller, a woman hunts the man she believes killed her sister. Which of these midpoints changes the kind of struggle she is in?
Key takeaway
A midpoint shift is an event near the centre that changes what kind of struggle the story is. Test it with two sentences: before, the protagonist is trying to do one thing, and after, another. If the only difference is that things are harder, look for something the protagonist could learn, win or lose that would alter the task itself.
