From problem to commitment
The inciting incident puts a problem in front of the protagonist. For a while after that they can still treat it as somebody else’s business. They ask advice, put it off, try the cheap fix, hope it goes away.
Incident to doorway
- The inciting incidentA problem in front of the protagonist
- Somebody else’s businessAsk advice, put it off, try the cheap fix
- The first plot pointA doorway of no return: does the door shut?
The first plot point is where that stops. The protagonist steps into the main conflict and the way back closes. In the three-act shape it is the break between setup and confrontation. Syd Field called it plot point one. Joseph Campbell, writing about myth, called it the crossing of the first threshold. Some teachers call it a doorway of no return, which is the most useful name of the three because it tells you what to check: is there a door, and does it shut?
The stretch between incident and commitment is where a reader learns what the protagonist stands to lose. That knowledge is what makes the next step count.
A choice, and what it costs
Two things turn an event into a commitment.
Event into commitment
- A choiceAnother option is open, and we see it not taken
- Made as an actionA ticket handed back, a name signed
- A visible costNot “there would be consequences”: a torn boarding chit
The first is a choice. Another option has to be open, and the reader has to see the protagonist not take it. The choice is strongest as an action: a ticket handed back, a name signed, a thing said in front of people.
The second is a visible cost. Going through the door means giving something up, and the reader should see what. “There would be consequences” is not a cost. A torn boarding chit is.
What about a protagonist who is forced in: conscripted, kidnapped, framed? Compulsion can open the story, but look for the choice inside it. A person dragged onto a cart is cargo. A person who climbs up in someone else’s place has committed, though the cart goes to the same war.
The weakness to watch for in your own draft is the protagonist who is carried through the door by other people’s decisions. The plot advances and they have not yet done anything, and it is hard to back a character who has put nothing in.
Example
Twenty minutes before the shuttle
A doorway moment from a science-fiction novel. Find the other option, the act, and the cost.
The transfer shuttle left Ceto Station at six, and Lucasta Imari had a seat on it. Second engineer on a liner. It was the posting she had put in for three times.1
At twenty to six she was still in the hydroponics bay with the station’s water report open on her slate. Her brother had asked her to look at the numbers before she went, as a favour. There was nitrate where there should be none. Somebody was dosing the supply, in amounts small enough to pass for error, and had been doing it since the new contractor came.
She could send the report to the administrator and go.2 He would file it. She knew what filing looked like here.
Her bag was by the hatch. She picked it up, walked to the shuttle gate and held out her boarding chit to the steward.
“Give the seat to standby,” she said.3 “I’m staying on.”
He tore the chit in half4, as the regulations required, and dropped the pieces in the bin. The gate light went from green to amber. She stood and watched until it went red5.
- “It was the posting she had put in for three times.”The cost is set up before the choice, so we know what the seat is worth when she gives it away.
- “She could send the report to the administrator and go.”The other option, stated plainly. It is a reasonable one, which is what makes this a choice.
- ““Give the seat to standby,” she said.”The commitment is an action with a witness. She does not decide in her head and tell us later.
- “He tore the chit in half”The cost made visible. One torn slip stands for the posting, and it cannot be mended.
- “until it went red”The door shuts on the page. She makes herself watch it.
Before and after
Carried, or climbing
The one faultThe protagonist is carried into the main conflict. She decides nothing.
The summons had been on the mantel for nine days. The Queen’s wardens were taking one hedge-witch from every parish for the war in the north, and in this parish there were only two, Margot Tarn and her grandmother.
Margot had not decided. She was still not deciding on the tenth morning, when the wardens’ cart stopped at the gate. A sergeant read out her name.
Her grandmother put a parcel of food into her hands. Somebody lifted her bag over the tailboard, and then lifted her, and the cart moved off before she had found a place to sit.
By noon the parish was behind the hill.
Both versions end with Margot on the cart and the parish behind the hill. The plot is in the same place.
In the first version it gets there without her. The sergeant reads her name, her grandmother hands her a parcel, somebody lifts her bag and then lifts her. Every verb belongs to another person. She “had not decided”, and she never has to.
The second version changes one fact: the name read out is her grandmother’s. Now there are two options in front of her, and she takes one, aloud, to a sergeant. She climbs up by herself. The cost is standing at the gate saying her name, and she does not look round at it.
It is the same event, and in the second version she chose it.
The exception
When to break it
Some stories need a protagonist who has no say. A soldier is drafted, a child is sent away, a woman wakes in a locked room. That is a fair way to begin. The commitment then tends to arrive later than usual, at the point where the character stops trying to get back to the old life and starts trying to win the new one. It helps to know where that point is in your draft.
Late, early or inside
Fast thrillers often fold the inciting incident and the commitment into one event near the first page. The gain is speed. The price is that the reader never saw the ordinary life, so they cannot feel what is being given up, and the writer has to supply it on the run.
In a quiet novel the choice may be inward, a decision not to write a letter. It still wants one outward sign that a reader can see.
In many tragedies the commitment is the mistake, and the cost stays hidden until much later.
An eager protagonist needs no reluctance, and the stretch of doubt can be cut. The cost is then the one thing that shows the step matters, so it needs to be clear.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which is the commitment?
A retired sea captain is asked to find a ship that vanished with all hands. In which of these does he commit to the main conflict?
Key takeaway
At the first plot point the protagonist enters the main conflict and cannot simply go back. Make it a choice by showing the other option, make it an action that someone could witness, and put the cost on the page as a particular thing given up. If the plot would reach the same place with your protagonist asleep, they have not committed yet.
