Fair on the page
The lesson on truth, memory and other people covers the big decisions: what to disclose, change or cut, and a policy for names. This lesson is about the sentences themselves. Three habits keep a portrait of a real person fair.
Three habits
- What you sawActions and words; guesses about minds marked as guesses
- More than one lightNot only their worst day
- Your own partWhat you said and did, the unflattering parts too
Write what you saw. You witnessed what people did and heard what they said. You did not see inside them. “She stayed away because she was jealous” claims a view of her mind you do not have. “She did not come” is what you know; if you have a guess about why, say that it is a guess, and whose.
Show them in more than one light. Nobody is only their worst day. A father who frightened you may also have taught you to ride a bicycle. Putting both on the page does not excuse anything. It makes the portrait believable, and it makes the hard parts land harder.
Put yourself in the frame. You were in those rooms too. If you leave out what you said and did, the reader notices, and stops trusting the rest.
Before anyone reads it
Sooner or later the people in your memoir, or the people who loved them, may read it. Decide early how you will handle that, rather than the week before it comes out.
A decision for each person
- List the peopleEveryone who appears, however briefly
- Ask what each could loseMost care for those who cannot answer back
- Show, tell, change or cutOne decision per person, made on purpose
- Offer only what you meanFacts, their side, or a say, decided beforehand
List everyone who appears, and ask what each could lose: privacy, standing in the family, a job, peace of mind. Children, people who have died, and people with no public voice cannot answer back, so they deserve the most care.
For each, decide whether to show them pages, tell them in outline, change what would identify them, or cut them. If you show someone pages, decide beforehand what you are offering: to correct facts, to hear their side, or a say over what stays. Then offer only that. A promise you later break does more harm than no promise.
None of this is legal advice. The law on privacy and defamation differs from country to country, and a promise of confidentiality can carry weight of its own. If you are worried that something you have written could hurt someone in a way that leads to a claim, or about a promise you made, take advice from a qualified lawyer, or from your publisher if you have one, before you publish.
Example
A hard father, fairly drawn
A memoir about a childhood in a house where one parent was violent. Watch how the writer handles what she knows and what she does not.
My father hit my brother twice that I saw.1 Both times it was in the yard behind the garage, and both times it was over a tool left out in the rain. I do not know what was in his head.2 My mother said he had been beaten himself, as a boy, for less. I have no way to check that, and he never spoke of it.3
He also taught me to ride a bicycle in one afternoon, running beside me down Mill Lane with his hand under the saddle long after I was steady4, because I had asked him not to let go.
I was not a bystander in that house. The second time, it was me who told him about the chisel.5 I was nine, and I wanted him to know which of us was the careful one.
- “My father hit my brother twice that I saw.”A plain statement of what she witnessed, with its limit built in: “that I saw”.
- “I do not know what was in his head.”She refuses to claim his motives.
- “I have no way to check that, and he never spoke of it.”Something she was told, given to the person who told her, and its status made clear.
- “running beside me down Mill Lane with his hand under the saddle lo…”A second light on the same man. It does not soften the yard; it makes him real.
- “The second time, it was me who told him about the chisel.”Her own part, and not a flattering one. The reader trusts her more for it.
Before and after
The sister who did not come
The one faultThe writer states another person’s motives as fact.
My sister did not come to the hospital. She stayed away because she could not bear to share our mother’s last weeks with me, and because she wanted to be able to say afterwards that nobody had told her how bad it was. She rang once, on the Sunday, and asked for the nurse rather than for me.
Both versions keep the facts that hurt: the sister did not come, rang once, and asked for the nurse. Those are things the writer knows.
The first version then tells us why, twice, as though the writer had seen into her sister’s mind. Perhaps she is right. The reader cannot tell, and the sister, if she reads it, has been convicted without a hearing.
The second version admits that the reasons are the writer’s own and uncertain. It loses nothing in force. The phone call to the nurse is colder for being left unexplained, and the writer comes across as someone telling the truth about her own uncertainty.
The exception
When to break it
Fairness is not the same as balance. If someone harmed you, you do not owe them a sympathetic scene to set against it, and a second light can be left out if putting it in would falsify the book. What you owe the reader is accuracy: keep to what happened and what you saw.
People acting in public, or in a public role, have less claim to have their actions kept private. That does not extend to their families.
Some people will object whatever you write, and some cannot be asked. Telling people is often kind and often wise, and it is still your decision, case by case. What matters is that it is a decision, and not an accident. And if the stakes feel high, that is the moment to take advice from someone qualified to give it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
What you can know
A writer is describing her former business partner on the day the business closed. Which sentence keeps to what she could know?
Key takeaway
Write what you saw and mark what you guess, show people in more than one light, and put your own part on the page. Before anyone reads the book, decide for each person what they could lose and what you will offer, and take advice if you are worried.
