Memory is a draft
A memory is not a recording. Each time you recall something you rebuild it, and over the years the rebuilding fills gaps, borrows from photographs and family stories, and moves things to where they make better sense. How vivid a memory feels says little about how accurate it is. Some of the sharpest pictures people carry turn out, when checked, to be wrong.
Testing a memory
- Write it as you have itBefore you check anything
- Check the recordLetters, photos, papers, weather
- Go back to the placeIf you can
- Ask who was thereAnd listen without correcting
That does not make memory useless. It makes it a first draft, and a draft can be tested.
Write the memory down first, as you have it, before you check anything. Then test it in three places.
The record: letters, diaries, school reports, photographs with dates on the back, local newspapers, weather records, old maps.
The place: go back if you can. Rooms are smaller, distances shorter, and things you had forgotten are still there.
The people: ask others who were there what they remember, and listen without correcting them. Their version is evidence too.
When the evidence disagrees
Testing will turn up conflicts. They come in three kinds, and each asks for something different.
Three kinds of conflict
A small detail is wrong. The car was blue, not green; the shop was on the other corner. If nothing hangs on it, correct it and move on.
A memory that matters is wrong. You remember snow at the funeral, and there was none. Do not quietly swap in the record, and do not keep the snow as fact. Put both on the page. The gap between what you remember and what happened is often the most revealing thing you have, because it shows what the moment meant to you.
Two people remember it differently, and there is no record. Give both versions and say whose is whose. It is tempting to settle the question in your own favour, because it is your book. Resist it. A reader who sees you set out a rival version fairly will trust you on everything else.
Example
A birthday that was not
A writer remembers a childhood flood as her birthday. Then she checks.
I have always remembered the flood as my seventh birthday.1 I can see the cake on the top stair, where my mother carried it when the water came under the door, and my brother eating the icing off with his fingers while we waited for the boat.
The newspaper does not agree. I found the page in the county library last spring2: the river rose on the night of the fourteenth of March, three weeks after my birthday. There was no cake that night. There may have been a tin of something carried up from the larder3, and a seven-year-old who had decided it was a party.
I have kept the cake, not as a fact, because it is not one, but as what that night was to me4: an occasion. My brother, who was ten, remembers being frightened. He does not remember any icing.5
- “I have always remembered the flood as my seventh birthday.”The memory first, as she has it, and plainly labelled as memory.
- “I found the page in the county library last spring”The test, with its source. The reader can see how she knows.
- “There may have been a tin of something carried up from the larder”A guess, marked as one, at how the false memory might have formed.
- “not as a fact, because it is not one, but as what that night was to me”She keeps the memory for what it carries, and says exactly what status it has.
- “He does not remember any icing.”A third witness, set down without argument. The passage ends on the conflict, not on a verdict.
Before and after
The hard shoulder
The one faultA disputed memory is told as settled, in the writer’s favour.
The van broke down on the motorway outside Leeds, because my brother had forgotten to check the oil. He has never admitted it. We sat on the hard shoulder for four hours while the rain came in sideways, and he ate every one of the sandwiches.
The breakdown, the rain and the sandwiches are the same in both versions. Only the cause has changed.
In the first, the writer decides a question that her brother disputes, and adds that he “has never admitted it”, which makes his disagreement sound like guilt. The reader has only her word, and may start to wonder what else has been settled in her favour.
In the second, both versions stand, and the dispute becomes part of the story: two adults still arguing about a van. It is funnier, it is fairer, and it costs her nothing. The sandwiches remain entirely her brother’s fault.
The exception
When to break it
Not every conflict needs airing. If you and your sister disagree about the colour of a wallpaper and nothing hangs on it, pick one and move on. Readers do not want a footnote for every memory.
Sometimes the evidence is good enough to settle a question, and then you may settle it: say what the evidence is. Setting out a rival version is for when the question is truly open.
And some memories cannot be tested at all: what was said between you and someone who has died, a feeling you never told anyone. These are still part of a true book. Present them as what they are, your memory, and let the reader weigh them with the rest.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The wrong year
A writer has built a chapter round her memory that her father left home the year she started school. An old letter shows he left two years later. The timing matters: the chapter is about how starting school felt. What should she do?
Key takeaway
Treat memory as a first draft. Write it down, then test it against records, places and people. Correct small details, put a meaningful error beside the memory it overturns, and give rival versions fairly instead of settling them in your own favour.
