Three problems that arrive together
As soon as you write about your own life, three problems arrive together.
- Memory is unreliableYou say winter; your brother says August
- Shaping changes thingsCompressed months, rebuilt speech, composites
- The people are realThey will have to live beside the book
Memory is unreliable. You are sure it was winter, and your brother is sure it was August.
Shaping changes things. To make a readable book you compress months, rebuild speech, and may be tempted to fold several minor people into one. A person made that way is called a composite.
The people are real. They did not ask to be in a book, and they will have to live beside it.
There is no single rulebook for any of this. Writers, publishers and different kinds of non-fiction draw their lines in different places. What can fairly be asked of you is that you decide on purpose, apply your decisions evenly, and let the reader know what they are.
One thing this lesson is not: it is not legal advice. The law on privacy and on defamation differs from country to country. If you fear that something you have written could lead to a legal claim, take that question to a qualified lawyer or to your publisher. What follows is about craft and conscience.
Three moves and a policy
For any troublesome piece of material you have three moves.
Three moves
Disclose. Keep it, and tell the reader what it is: “as I remember it”, “my sister tells this differently”, or a note saying that speech is reconstructed.
Change. Alter what would identify someone (a name, a town, a job) and say that you have. Changing a detail in silence, or changing what happened, is a different act, because the reader now believes something false.
Cut. Leave it out. A true book is under no obligation to contain every true thing.
Deciding case by case, late at night, is tiring and gives uneven results. A policy is easier: a few sentences, written early, on names, composites and reconstruction. It is common to print one as an author’s note.
For each person in the book, three questions are worth asking. Does the story need this about them, or is it only vivid? Could they be recognised, by strangers or by the people whose opinion they care about? Can they answer back? Children, the dead and people with no public voice cannot.
Example
A policy in under two hundred words
This is the author’s note from the front of an invented memoir. It is not part of the story. It tells the reader the terms on which the story is told.
This is a true account of the four years I taught at a boarding school I have called Eastcombe. That is not its name.1 I have changed the names of all pupils and of most staff, and I have altered the home towns of two pupils whose stories would otherwise identify them2.
The matron in chapters 3 to 9 is one real woman. The three housemasters I served under have been merged into one3, Mr Lister, because their differences do not matter to this story and their privacy does.
Conversations are reconstructed from memory and from the diary4 I kept in my second and third years. Where I quote a letter, I have the letter.
My account of the night of the flood differs from that of a colleague who was also there. I have given mine and, in chapter 11, said where his departs from it5.
One former pupil asked me to remove a chapter about her family. I have done so.6
- “That is not its name.”Names: the reader is told at once that the school is disguised, and the next sentence extends that to pupils and staff.
- “I have altered the home towns of two pupils whose stories would ot…”A changed name is sometimes not enough. Here a second detail is changed, and the change is disclosed along with the reason.
- “have been merged into one”A composite, owned up to. The note also says who is not a composite, so the reader knows how far to trust the matron.
- “Conversations are reconstructed from memory and from the diary”Reconstruction, with its basis. The next sentence marks off what is on firmer ground.
- “said where his departs from it”A disputed memory is neither hidden nor settled by force. Both accounts are in the book.
- “I have done so.”A cut made at someone’s request, disclosed in four words and with no detail that would undo it.
The explainer
Keep his name out of it
The lane behind the bus depot, and the first version of the memory, one sentence at a time. Only one sentence needs changing. Press it to swap in its rewrite, and watch what the piece still has without his name and his secret.

Changes left
3 of 3
Words
127 (was 127)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
What the story needs
The one faultA minor figure is fully identified and a private fact about him is published, though the piece does not need either.
The person who finally taught me to parallel park was not an instructor. It was Graham Yates from number 14, whose carpet shop had gone bankrupt the spring before, though he told everyone on the street that he had sold it. He had time on his hands that year and a patience I had not met in three paid teachers. We used the lane behind the bus depot. He stood two bins a car’s length apart, waited at the edge of the lane with his arms folded, and said nothing at all until I had finished, however badly. Then he would walk once round the car, look at the gap, and say, “Closer than last time.” It was, every time, by about the width of a hand.
Only the second sentence differs. The first version gives a surname, a house number and a business failure the man had chosen to keep from his neighbours. Everyone on that street will know who is meant, and they will now know something he had not told them.
Ask what the piece is about. It is about a patient neighbour and a nervous driver. The bankruptcy explains why he had time, and the second version keeps “time on his hands that year” without the cause. Nothing the reader needs has gone. “Whom I will call” tells them the name is changed.
The first version is true, as far as we are told. That does not make this piece the right place to say it.
The exception
When to break it
Each standard answer fails somewhere.
Where the answers fail
Changing names protects nobody in a family or a village, where everyone knows who the eldest sister is. Then the real choice lies between cutting and accepting that she will be recognised.
Marking uncertainty can be overdone until nothing in the book stands firm. One note at the front may carry the whole load.
Discretion is not owed equally. Sometimes what a person did to you is the story, and to disguise them would falsify it. The questions then shift to accuracy and fairness: have you kept to what you saw, and let them be more than their worst day? If you fear the consequences, that is the moment for a lawyer.
Showing the manuscript to the people in it is generous and catches errors. It also hands them a say. Decide beforehand what you are offering: correction of facts, or more.
And some publications accept no composites at all. Check the standard of the place you are writing for.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Two aunts, one character
To keep the cast small, a memoirist has written her two real aunts as one. Which course keeps faith with the reader?
Key takeaway
You can disclose, change or cut, and the reader should be able to tell which you have done. Write a short policy on names, composites and reconstruction, mark what you only half know, and keep nothing about another person by default.
