What a proposal is for
A non-fiction book can be offered to a publisher as a proposal, sometimes before it is finished. A proposal is a document that argues a case: this book should exist, these people will buy it, and this writer can deliver it. Jane Friedman, who writes about the business of publishing, describes it as a business case, and that is a useful way to hold it in mind. The question it answers is less “is this book good?” than “who needs it, and how do you know?”
A business case
- This book should exist
- People will buy it
- This writer can deliver
The usual parts are an overview, a description of the audience, a set of comparable titles, a note on the author, a marketing plan, a chapter outline and one or more sample chapters. Names and order vary. Where an agent or publisher sets out what they ask for, their own guidelines outrank any template, this one included.
Two habits that carry most of the weight
Be specific about the audience. “Everyone who cooks” rules nobody out, so it tells the person reading your proposal nothing. Try asking who the book is not for. If you can answer, you have an audience. “Tenants in their twenties with one screwdriver” leaves out homeowners and builders, and it is easier to believe for that reason.
Specific, and checkable
Give each claim something a stranger could check. Enthusiasm costs nothing, and anyone can write “there is huge demand”. A figure from your own records, a class you have taught, a piece you have published, a membership you can reach: these are evidence. A small exact number is worth more than a large vague one. Where you have no evidence, the honest course is to cut the claim.
Comparable titles belong to the evidence. They are recent books bought by the readers you hope to reach, and they show that such readers exist. So treat them fairly, and say for each what its readers got and what yours will add. “There is nothing like my book” throws that evidence away.
Example
An overview that argues its case
This is the overview section of a proposal for an invented how-to book. It is a business document, not a piece of the book. The figures are invented, and rounded so that nobody mistakes them for real ones; in a real proposal they would come from the writer’s own records.
Small Repairs is a practical guide for people who rent their homes1 and want to fix the small things that go wrong, without waiting three weeks for a landlord.
The reader is a tenant in their twenties or thirties, in a small rented place or a shared house, who owns a screwdriver and not much else2. They have a dripping tap, a door that sticks and a blind that will not stay up. The home-repair manuals I have examined are written for owners.3 They assume a garage, a budget and the freedom to knock holes in walls.
The book has twenty repairs, each on a double page, each rated for difficulty, and each ending with a paragraph on when to stop and ring the landlord.
I have run a free monthly repair evening at a community hall since 2021. The attendance sheets show about 600 visits4, and the five commonest problems brought in are the first five chapters5. A newsletter that grew out of the evenings has about 2,000 subscribers, most of them tenants.
The manuscript will run to about 45,000 words with 60 line drawings, and can be delivered six months after agreement6.
- “a practical guide for people who rent their homes”What the book is and whom it serves, in the first sentence. Someone reading only this far already knows what is being offered.
- “who owns a screwdriver and not much else”A specific reader. This one detail rules out the keen amateur with a workshop, and tells us what level the book is pitched at.
- “The home-repair manuals I have examined are written for owners.”The gap, stated as something the writer has looked into and without sneering at the other books. The comparable titles section would name them.
- “The attendance sheets show about 600 visits”A claim with evidence. The writer does not say the evenings are popular. There are sheets, and a stranger could ask to see them.
- “the five commonest problems brought in are the first five chapters”Evidence shaping the book. The contents come from what tenants asked for, which is a stronger case than the writer’s hunch.
- “can be delivered six months after agreement”Length, illustrations and a delivery date: the practical facts a publisher would need in order to cost the book.
Before and after
Two audience sections for one book
The one faultThe audience is everyone, and nothing in the section could be checked.
Fishgate will appeal to everyone who loves history, and to anyone who has ever shopped at a market. History is one of the most popular kinds of book, and interest in local heritage has never been higher. Readers of all ages will find something to enjoy in these pages, from students to the retired, and the book would make an ideal gift.
Both paragraphs come from a proposal for an invented local history of a street market, and the figures in them are invented too. The first is written with real warmth, and every sentence of it could be moved to a proposal for any history book at all. Nobody is ruled out. “Has never been higher” is offered with no source, and “an ideal gift” is a hope.
The second names three groups in order of nearness: the traders, the county society, and the wider reader of single-place histories. The first two come with a number and a reason to think the book will reach them, a stall and a journal. The third is tied to comparable titles. The whole audience it claims is far smaller than “everyone who loves history”, and a stranger has grounds for believing in it.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of books never need a proposal. A proposal is a way of making the case for a book before it is all written. A novel, and often a memoir, depends so much on the writing that the finished manuscript has to make that case itself. If you publish the book yourself, nobody will ask for a proposal, though drafting the overview and the audience section remains a hard and useful test of the idea.
Where the template gives
Evidence does not have to be a number. For a specialist it may be a post held; for a memoirist, an essay already in print. If you have no following, say what you have done, and do not inflate what you plan to do.
And sometimes a book truly has no close neighbour. Then say what its readers buy now in its place, and why that falls short.
Conventions here differ between countries and shift over time. Check the current guidelines of each place you send to.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
A believable audience
Four sentences from the audience sections of four proposals. Which one names a specific audience and supports it?
Key takeaway
A proposal argues that a book is needed and that you can deliver it. Name an audience narrow enough to rule people out, attach to every claim something a stranger could check, and use comparable titles as proof that your readers exist.
