Lesson 9 of 13
The Archive · stone 9Intermediate5 minute read

The two I’s in practice

Where the teller speaks in a chapter, how much, and what each intervention adds.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-14

The Archive: a columned stone library, with tall shelves and a reading table seen through its open doors.
The Archive · Non-fiction and memoir track, stone 9 of 13

Where the teller stands

The lesson on the two voices sets out the idea: a memoir is told by the self who lived it and the self who now tells it, and the reader needs to know which is speaking. This lesson is about using them across a real chapter: where the teller speaks, and how much.

The teller speaks at the edges of scenes, so each scene runs whole.

The teller has three good places to stand.

The frame. A few lines at the start or the end of a chapter, in the present, from the desk: the photograph you are holding, the house as it is now. A frame tells the reader that someone is looking back, and from where.

The seam. The gap between one scene and the next, or after the last. The scene has finished, the reader has felt it, and the teller can say what it meant, what came later, or what someone else remembers.

The aside. A single marked sentence inside a scene, when a fact cannot wait. Use it sparingly, and never at the turn.

Let the turn run

Every scene worth writing has a moment where something shifts. That is where the reader is most inside the past, and it is where a teller’s voice does most damage. Break in at the turn with “I see now that…” and the reader is pulled out of the room just as the room mattered most.

A teller’s line moved from the turn to the seam lets the reader feel the moment before learning what it was.

So let the turn run, and speak afterwards. The same sentence, moved to the seam, often reads twice as strongly, because the reader has felt the moment first and now learns what it was.

Then ask of every teller line: does it add something the scene could not hold? A later fact, someone else’s version, a doubt about your own memory, a judgement you could only make with time. If a line only tells the reader what they have just watched (“I was hurt”, “it was a hard day”), cut it. The scene already said it, and better.

A quick test: cover the teller’s lines and read the chapter. If nothing is lost, they were repeating. If the scenes stop making sense, the teller has been doing the scenes’ job.

Example

A frame, a scene and a seam

A chapter from a memoir about leaving home. Watch where the teller speaks and where she stays quiet.

The Thursday ferrycontemporary

I still have the ticket.1 It lives in the drawer with the spare keys, a pale-green stub from the Thursday ferry, and when I come across it I put it back without reading it.

I was nineteen and leaving home for the first time. My father drove me to the harbour in the van, because the car had failed its test, and neither of us said much on the way. At the barrier he got out, lifted my case from the back and stood holding it, as if he had forgotten what came next2.

“You’ve got your ticket,” he said.

“Yes.”

“Show me.”

I showed him. He read it as though it might be wrong. Then he handed me the case, got back into the van and drove off. He did not wait for the boat to go.3

For years I told that as a story about a cold man.4 I told it at parties. It was my sister who pointed out, much later, that he had never in his life watched anything leave5: not a bus, not a train, not my mother’s coffin going out of the church door.

  1. “I still have the ticket.”The frame. Present tense, an object on the desk now: the reader knows someone is looking back.
  2. “as if he had forgotten what came next”Inside the scene, the past self sees only what a nineteen-year-old would see.
  3. “He did not wait for the boat to go.”The scene ends on its turn, with no comment. The reader is left with the hurt she felt then.
  4. “For years I told that as a story about a cold man.”The seam. The teller speaks only once the scene is over.
  5. “he had never in his life watched anything leave”What the teller adds is a later fact from someone else. It changes the scene without retelling it.

Before and after

Opening the kiln

The one faultThe teller breaks into the scene at its turning moment.

Weaker versionOpening the kiln (first version)

My grandmother opened the kiln on the third morning, and I stood behind her with the tray. The first bowl came out cracked straight through. So did the second. That was the morning she decided to stop, though it would be a year before she told anyone. She lifted out the third and turned it in her hands. It was whole. She set it on my tray without a word and reached in for the next.

Showing the weaker version.

The two versions have the same words. Only one sentence has moved.

In the first, the teller cuts in between the cracked bowls and the whole one. The reader is told the outcome before the moment has happened, so the whole bowl, which should be a small reprieve, arrives already spoiled.

In the second, the scene runs to its end. The reader sees two failures and a success, and a woman who says nothing and keeps going. Then the teller speaks, and the whole bowl turns over in the memory: it was not enough. The sentence is the same. Its place gives it its force.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

An aside inside a scene can be right when the reader would otherwise misread the moment badly: the man at the door is the father you have not yet mentioned, the place is the one you will lose. Keep it to a clause, mark it plainly, and keep it away from the turn.

Some memoirs are built on interruption. An essayistic memoir may move constantly between then and now, and the movement is the point. The test there is different: does each move add, or does it repeat?

And some chapters need no teller at all. If the scene says everything and the next chapter picks up the thread, silence at the seam is a choice too.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Where the teller waits

A memoir scene builds to the moment the writer’s brother hands back the ring she gave him. The writer wants to add one sentence from the present: that she later learned he had already sold the watch she gave him the year before. Where will that sentence do least harm?

Key takeaway

Let the teller speak in the frame, at the seams between scenes, or in a rare marked aside, and let each scene run through its turn untouched. Keep only the teller’s lines that add something the scene could not hold.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Find the teller in your chapter

Highlight every teller line in one chapter of your memoir, check where each one sits, and keep only those that add.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.