A stretch of life is not yet a story
Once you have chosen the stretch of life your memoir covers, you still have a heap of things that happened in it. Some were important, some were vivid, and most of them were both at once. A heap does not pull a reader through two hundred pages. A story does.
The parts of the story
- The wantWhat your past self chased, concrete enough to win or lose
- The troubleWhat stood in the way
- The turnThe event after which you could not go on as before
- The changeWho you were at the end that you were not at the start
The story inside a life has the same working parts as the story in a novel, with one difference: the main character is you, as you were then.
The want. What your past self was chasing, concrete enough to be won or lost. Often it is not what you would say now. A twenty-year-old who “wanted to find herself” may, on a closer look, have wanted her mother to stop ringing on Sundays.
The trouble. What stood in the way: other people, money, illness, your own habits.
The turn. The event after which you could not go on as before.
The change. Who you were by the end that you were not at the start, said plainly enough to point to.
Finding it
You will rarely find the story by staring at the whole stretch. Work from the parts instead.
From a heap to a story
- Name what you wanted thenSomething another person could give or refuse
- Find the turnOften smaller than you expect
- Name the changeIn one sentence
- Go back to the heapKeep only what bears on those parts
Start with the want, because everything else hangs on it. Ask what you were trying to get, keep or prove, and keep asking until the answer is something another person could have given you or refused you.
Then look for the turn. It is often smaller than you expect: not the funeral but the phone call before it, not the wedding but the morning you nearly did not go.
Then name the change in a sentence. If you cannot, the story may not be finished, or it may be a different story from the one you thought.
Last, go back to the heap. Keep what bears on the want, the trouble, the turn or the change. A memory that bears on none of them belongs to another book, however much you love it.
One stretch of life can hold several stories. A year of nursing a parent can be about the parent, about a marriage strained by the nursing, or about a career let go. Each gives a different book. Choose one.
Example
Four years on a market stall
A writer has chosen her stretch: the years she ran her aunt’s flower stall. Before drafting, she writes the parts down.
The stretch: four years running the flower stall at Corrigan Street market, from the week I took it over from my aunt to the week I handed back the keys1.
What I wanted then: for my aunt, and everyone on the row, to see that I could keep the stall going without her. Not to sell flowers. To be seen to manage.2
The trouble: I was bad at it. I bought too much in the wrong colours, I could not haggle, and the regulars still asked after her.
The turn: the March she came out of hospital and stood at the end of the row watching me serve, and did not come over3. She was not waiting to take it back. I had been performing for an audience of one, and she had stopped watching.
The change: by the last year I ran the stall for the stall’s sake, and giving it up was my own decision4.
What stays out: the flat, the man I was seeing, my brother’s wedding, unless one of them bears on the stall5.
- “from the week I took it over from my aunt to the week I handed bac…”The stretch has two edges, so it is clear what falls inside it.
- “Not to sell flowers. To be seen to manage.”She corrects the obvious want to the real one. Being seen to manage can be granted or refused by other people, so it can drive scenes.
- “stood at the end of the row watching me serve, and did not come over”The turn is a small, exact moment, not a whole season. It can be written as a scene.
- “giving it up was my own decision”The change answers the want: she no longer needs to be seen.
- “unless one of them bears on the stall”The test for what stays out comes from the story, not from how much each memory matters to her.
Before and after
One summer, with and without a want
The one faultThe notes name no want for the past self, so none of the events can be a turn.
The summer of 1962, at my grandfather’s boatyard on the estuary. I was thirteen.
In June I arrived on the bus with one suitcase. I learned to caulk a hull and to row against the tide. In July a ketch came in for a new keel, and the owner’s son and I became friends. In August a storm took out the slipway, and I helped my grandfather winch the ketch clear. At the end of the summer he drove me to the bus and gave me his folding rule.
The events are the same in both versions, and in the same order. The first reads as a list: this happened, then this. Each line is pleasant, and none matters more than another.
The second adds one line, and the summer becomes a story. The cousin who is always asked sets up the trouble. The storm becomes a test. The folding rule at the bus stop becomes an answer, or very nearly one, and the reader wants to know which. Nothing has been invented. A want has been named, and the events have lined up behind it.
The exception
When to break it
Some memoirs are portraits: of a parent, a place, a village that has gone. The writer is a witness, and the want and the change may belong to the person being remembered. The parts are still useful. They have moved to someone else.
Not every life turns cleanly. The change may be small, or still under way, or a change in understanding rather than in circumstances. That is allowed, as long as you can say what it is. What is not allowed, in a true book, is inventing a turn the life did not have. If there was none, write the book that shows the waiting.
And the want does not have to be stated on the page. It is a tool for choosing. Many memoirs do not say it outright and let the reader feel it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
A want that can drive a book
A writer is planning a memoir about the two years she spent looking after her father at home. Which line names a want that could drive the story?
Key takeaway
The story inside a life has a want, a trouble, a turn and a change, and its main character is you as you were then. Find the want first, make it something another person could give or refuse, and keep only the memories that bear on the story.
