Two layers
Every piece of personal writing has two layers. The situation is the set of circumstances: who was involved, where and when, and what happened. The story is what the writer came to understand by living through those circumstances and thinking about them afterwards.
Two layers
The pair of terms comes from the critic Vivian Gornick, whose book The Situation and the Story (2001) takes them as its title. This lesson puts them in its own plain words. They are useful because they pull apart two things that drafts tend to blur. “The summer we sold the farm” is a situation. It is not yet a story, however dramatic the summer was.
A draft with only a situation reads as a sequence: this happened, then this. The events may be remarkable, and the reader will still wonder why they are being told. The story is the answer to that.
Testing a story sentence
A good working habit is to write one sentence for each layer. The situation sentence is easy. The story sentence is where the trouble lies, and three tests help.
Three tests
- Insight or event?“In the end she forgave me” is an event
- Could someone disagree?“Family is important” cannot be argued with
- Needs this situation?If it fits other events, it is a moral
Is it an insight, or another event? “In the end she forgave me” is an event. It belongs to the situation.
Could someone disagree with it? “Family is important” cannot be argued with, which is a sign that it says very little. “I had mistaken my father’s silence for disapproval when it was shyness” might be wrong, and that is why a reader will want to see the evidence.
Does it need this situation? Try pinning it on a different set of events. If it fits just as well, it is a general moral. An insight that is really yours carries some trace of where it came from.
One situation can hold more than one story. Which you choose decides which scenes stay in, so choose on purpose.
Example
Both layers in a short essay
An invented personal essay, complete in four paragraphs. The first three are situation. Watch where it turns.
In the spring of my third year as manager of the print room, the firm told me to cut one post out of five1. I had until the end of the month to choose.
There was never any doubt which post. Vince had been late with every large job since Christmas, and twice I had stayed behind to finish his work so that nobody upstairs would notice. He was also the only one of the five I saw outside the building. We had been to each other’s houses. His daughter called me by my first name.
I told him on a Friday, in the stockroom, among the reams.2 He took it better than I did. What he said, when I had finished, was, “You could have told me in January that I was slipping.”3
He was right, and it took me most of a year to see why I had not. I had covered for him because I wanted him to go on liking me.4 I had called that kindness. It had cost him three months in which he might have put things right.5
- “the firm told me to cut one post out of five”Situation: who, where, when and what. Nothing here has been understood yet. It has only happened.
- “I told him on a Friday, in the stockroom, among the reams.”Still situation, now as a moment in a place. A story needs events like this to stand on.
- ““You could have told me in January that I was slipping.””The hinge. It is an event, a thing said, but it is the event that hands the writer her story.
- “I had covered for him because I wanted him to go on liking me.”The story. It is about the writer, not about the lay-off. It could be argued with, and it could not be moved to any other situation.
- “It had cost him three months in which he might have put things right.”The insight is tied straight back to a fact of the situation, the months from January to spring. That tie is what stops it floating off as a moral.
Before and after
The same memory, two last paragraphs
The one faultThe closing reflection is a general moral that would fit any family memory.
Every Saturday for six years I drove my grandfather to his chess club above the library and sat in the car outside for two hours with a book, because he would not let me come in. He said the others would think he needed minding. At five I watched him come down the steps with one hand on the rail. I got out to open the door, and each week he told me he could manage a car door.
After he died, the club secretary sent a card. It said the members would miss him, and that he had talked about me constantly: my job, my new place, whatever book I was reading that week in the car.
It made me realise how precious our time with family is, and that we should not take the people we love for granted.
The first two paragraphs are identical, and they are good: a concrete situation with a surprise in it. Only the endings differ.
The first ending could be stapled to a piece about a wedding, a quarrel or a holiday. It names no car, no card and no grandfather. Nobody could disagree with it, and it tells us nothing the writer had to live six years to find out.
The second ending could belong only here. It uses the car and the stairs, and it answers the card. It also says something that might be wrong: perhaps the old man simply liked his privacy. Because it is a reading of the evidence and not a saying, the reader goes back over the Saturdays and tests it.
The exception
When to break it
The story sentence is a tool for you. It does not have to appear in the finished piece. The essay tradition often states its insight outright, as the print-room piece does. A memoir built from scenes may do better to let the order of the scenes carry it, and keep the sentence in the notes.
The sentence is a tool
Nor do you need it before you start. Fixing the story too early can leave you with a moral, because a moral is all anyone has before the thinking is done. Draft the situation, then ask what you now see that you did not see then.
Some true writing is properly almost all situation: a family chronicle, a piece of reporting, a record made so that something is not lost. And a story may be an honest admission. “I still do not know why I stayed” can be what a piece is for, if the piece has earned it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which is the story?
A writer gives this as her situation: “The two years my mother and I ran a market stall after my father left.” Which of these could be her story sentence?
Key takeaway
The situation is what happened and the story is what you came to understand. Write a sentence for each. The story sentence should be an insight, should be open to argument, and should fit no situation but yours.
