Three shapes
Once you know the story inside your stretch of life, you have to decide what order to tell it in. Most memoirs use one of three shapes, or a mix.
Three shapes for a memoir
Chronological. The story is told in the order it happened, from the start of the stretch to its end. It is the simplest shape and often the strongest, because cause and effect line up with the calendar. It suits a story whose change happens step by step: a year of training, an illness and recovery, a job from first day to last.
Braided. Two strands, usually from two different times, take turns. A present story (clearing a parent’s house) alternates with a past one (the parent’s life, or the writer’s childhood). Each strand changes how the other reads. It suits a story where one time explains another.
Thematic. Chapters are gathered by subject instead of by date: one per house, per object, per job, per person. It suits a question you circle and see from many sides, rather than walk through.
Whatever the shape, something moves
Ask of your story: does the change happen in order, over time? Then start with chronological, and only move away from it for a reason. Does another time explain this one, or does this one give the other its meaning? Try a braid. Is your question something you keep returning to from different directions? Try a thematic shape.
How each shape fails
- Chronological, as a listEvery month gets a chapter, whether or not it changes anything
- Braided, never touchingTwo short books laid side by side
- Thematic, standing stillChapters that could be shuffled like cards
Each shape has a way of failing.
A chronological memoir can turn into a list, where every month gets its chapter whether or not anything changed. Keep only the steps of the story.
A braid fails when the strands never touch. Two stories laid side by side are two short books. The strands need crossings: an object, a letter, a question that one strand raises and the other answers.
A thematic memoir fails when nothing moves forward. Nine chapters on nine houses, each with its own mood, can be shuffled like cards, and the reader can stop after any of them. Something has to build from chapter to chapter: time, understanding, or a question narrowing towards its answer.
Example
A braid that touches
A writer clearing her late mother’s house finds the record of a café her mother ran for one year. She plans a braided memoir.
Two strands, alternating.
Now (odd chapters): the eleven weeks in 2023 when I cleared my mother’s house, room by room1.
Then (even chapters): 1979, the year she ran a café on the quay, told from her letters and from what her friends remember2.
1. The kitchen. I find the café’s order book in the bread bin.3
2. March 1979. She signs the lease without telling my father.
3. The front room. A photograph of the café with its windows boarded up.
4. August 1979. The best month: a queue to the harbour wall.
5. Her bedroom. A letter to her sister: “I was good at it.”
6. November 1979. The café closes. She never says why.4
7. The empty house. I take the order book home.
Where they meet: each Now chapter finds an object that opens the next Then chapter. The Then strand ends with the closure, the Now strand with what I keep, and the question of why she gave it up runs under both5.
- “the eleven weeks in 2023 when I cleared my mother’s house, room by…”The present strand has its own clock and its own order, so it moves forward on its own.
- “told from her letters and from what her friends remember”The past strand names its sources. In a braid about someone else’s life, the reader needs to know how the writer knows.
- “I find the café’s order book in the bread bin.”A crossing: the object found now opens the chapter set then.
- “She never says why.”The past strand ends on an open question, which the present strand carries.
- “the question of why she gave it up runs under both”One question binds the two strands. That is what makes them one book.
Before and after
Five houses
The one faultNothing moves forward across the chapters.
A memoir in rooms. Each chapter is one house we lived in before I was sixteen.
The flat over the bakery: warmth, and the smell of bread.
The farm cottage: cold, and my first dog.
The terrace on Ash Street: the neighbours and their parrot.
The caravan: one wet summer.
The council house: my own room at last.
Both outlines are thematic: one house per chapter, in the order the family lived in them. The first gives each house a mood and stops. Each chapter could stand alone, and the reader has no reason to go from the farm cottage to Ash Street except that it comes next.
The second keeps the same houses and the same order and adds one thread: why the family kept moving. Each house now gives a little more, the whispering, the man at the door, the other name, until the letter at the end. The shape is the same. Now something moves through it.
The exception
When to break it
Shapes mix. A chronological memoir can open with a single scene from near the end and then go back to the start. A thematic memoir can run in rough date order underneath its subjects. Use whatever mix serves the story, as long as the reader can tell where they are in time.
Some books are collections of linked essays rather than one story, and each piece can stand alone by design. That is a different form, with its own pleasures. Even then, the order of the pieces is a choice, and a good order usually builds.
And you may not know your shape until you have drafted. Many writers draft in order, because that is how memory hands the material over, and find the shape in revision. Choose a working shape now. It can change.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Two strands that never meet
A writer’s braided memoir alternates her own first year of teaching with her father’s years as a sailor. Readers of the draft say it feels like two books. What is the most likely fix?
Key takeaway
Tell the story in order when its change happens in order, braid two times when one explains the other, and gather chapters by theme when you circle a question. Whatever the shape, make something move forward from chapter to chapter, and make braided strands touch.
