Three openings that stall
Memoirs tend to stall at the start in three familiar ways, each of them natural when you are writing your own life.
Openings that stall
The birth certificate. “I was born in…” Your life began there, so it feels like the place to start. But the reader does not yet know why your life matters, and a date and a town do not tell them.
The family tree. Grandparents, where they came from, what they did. Some of it may matter later. On the first page it is a queue the reader has to stand in before anything happens.
The reasons. “I have wanted to write this for a long time.” This is the writer warming up, and it is honest, but it talks about the book instead of beginning it.
All three come from the calendar, or from the writer’s nerves. A memoir’s opening has a different job: to put the reader inside a moment, let them feel the question the book will ask, and let them hear who is telling it.
Choosing the moment
A memoir’s first page usually needs three things.
What the first page holds
- A momentOne place, one time, something happening
- The questionFelt, not stated: a secret, a gap, a want
- The tellerA line that lets the reader hear who is telling it
A moment. One place, one time, something happening. The reader is somewhere before they are told anything.
The question, or its seed. Not stated as a thesis, but felt: a secret, a gap, a want, something that does not add up.
The teller. A line or two that lets the reader hear who is telling this, and from how far away.
Three kinds of moment often work. The turn itself, told first, before the book goes back to show how it came about. The moment the want began. Or a small moment that holds the whole question in miniature: a drawer opened, a test passed, a towel fetched.
Write down three candidates and test each against the three needs. Then draft the one that passes, and fold in only the background the reader needs to follow it: a clause, a date, a relationship. The rest of the family tree can come later, in small doses, when the story calls for it.
Example
An opening that does all three
The first page of a memoir about a mother and daughter.
The examiner asked me to pull over by the post box1, and I knew before he spoke that I had passed, because he had stopped writing. I was fifty-two.2 My daughter had passed the same test, in the same town, nineteen years before, and I had sat in the passenger seat for every one of her practice drives and never once told her that I could not drive3.
I am still not sure why I hid it for so long4, or why I finally learned in the year she stopped speaking to me5.
- “The examiner asked me to pull over by the post box”A moment, at once: a car, a post box, a man with a clipboard.
- “I was fifty-two.”One short fact that turns an ordinary scene into a strange one.
- “never once told her that I could not drive”The seed of the question: a secret kept from a daughter for nineteen years. The background arrives inside a single sentence.
- “I am still not sure why I hid it for so long”The teller, in the present tense, admitting what she does not know. The reader now knows what the book is trying to find out.
- “the year she stopped speaking to me”A second question opened in passing. The reader will want both answered.
Before and after
The receipts drawer
The one faultIt opens with family background instead of a moment.
My grandfather opened the ironmonger’s on Dock Street in 1931, and built the counter himself. My father took the shop over after the war. I was born in the flat above it, the second of three children, and by the time I was twelve I was weighing out nails on Saturdays. That was the year my father started keeping a bottle in the receipts drawer.
Both versions hold nearly the same facts: the grandfather’s counter, 1931, the flat above the shop, the second of three, the nails, the bottle in the receipts drawer.
The first gives them in the order of the calendar, so the bottle, which is what the book is about, arrives last, in summary, as one more fact.
The second starts with the bottle, seen by a twelve-year-old on one particular Saturday. The grandfather and the flat are still there, folded into the moment, and now they matter: the counter he built is where his son is drinking. Nothing has been added. The opening has been turned round so that the reader meets the story before the history.
The exception
When to break it
Sometimes the background is the story. A memoir about inheriting a farm, a name or a family trade may need its generations early, and a writer with a strong voice can make a family tree compelling. The test is whether the reader is already leaning forward by the end of the first page.
A brief note before the story starts, about names changed or memory, is a different thing from a preface of reasons, and many memoirs carry one. Keep it short and put it before chapter one, not inside it.
And plenty of good memoirs open quietly, in an ordinary moment. Quiet is not the problem. Delay is. An ordinary breakfast that holds the question is a better opening than a dramatic event that does not.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which first line?
A memoir is about the year the writer, then fifteen, found out that the man she called her uncle was her father. Which first line gives the best start?
Key takeaway
Open a memoir in a moment, not with a birth, a family tree or your reasons for writing. Choose a moment that lets the reader feel the book’s question and hear who is telling it, and fold in only the background they need to follow it.
