Only here
Every genre has its big scenes, the ones a book is remembered by. In fantasy and science fiction the best of them could only happen in that world. A duel in which every parry costs a year of life. A chase along the outside of a spinning station, where down changes as you run. A siege in which the river is on the defenders’ side, because someone can speak to it.
The world-out test
A useful test: describe the scene with the world taken out. If it is still the same scene, a fight in a corridor, a chase across rooftops, then the world is scenery there. That is not always wrong. But the set piece is where a book keeps its promise, and a speculative novel’s promise is its difference.
Teach the arena first
A set piece wants speed, and speed cannot stop to explain. So teach the rules beforehand, on something small. Show the gravity faltering in the galley, when a mug drifts off the table. Show the river answering a child’s question long before it is asked to rise against an army. When the big scene comes, the reader already knows how the world works, and the action can run.
Building to the big scene
- Show it smallA mug drifts off the galley table
- Use it onceA minor escape, a small cost
- Raise the stakesNow the rule matters to someone’s life
- The set pieceAt speed, with no stop to explain
There is a pleasure in recognising a rule you were shown. Part of what makes a set piece satisfying is the click of something set up chapters before.
Clear ground and a real turn
Two more things make a big scene work. The reader has to know where everyone is: the ledge, the door, the enemy between them. Spend a sentence or two on the ground before the action starts, then keep it steady.
A set piece that works
- Only hereThe world’s difference is the arena
- Rules knownShown earlier, on something small
- Clear groundWhere everyone is, before it starts
- A real turnSomething won or lost for good
And the scene has to change the story. Something is won, lost or learned that cannot be undone. Spectacle with nothing decided is a pause, however loud.
Example
A road made of river
A fantasy. Earlier chapters showed that Ama can freeze only water she is touching, and that the cold comes out of her own hands: freezing a bucket once left her fingers numb for a day.
The ferry was gone, and the Duke’s riders were a mile behind and closing. Between the bank and the island lay two hundred yards of black river, and on the island, the only boat.1
Ama took off her gloves.2
She knelt at the water’s edge, put both hands flat on the surface, and pushed the cold out of herself. The river went grey, then white, in a strip no wider than a cart, reaching out from her palms3. Her fingers went white with it.
“Walk,” she said. “Don’t run. It’s thinner than it looks.”
They walked. Jory carried the child. Behind them the first rider reached the bank and drove his horse onto the ice, and the horse went through at once, because the ice could carry people, not horses4.
Halfway across, Ama felt the cold reach her wrists. At three-quarters, her elbows. When her feet found the island’s shingle she could not feel her arms at all, and she knew, the way you know you have dropped something in the dark, that this time the feeling was not coming back5.
- “Between the bank and the island lay two hundred yards of black riv…”Clear ground first: where they are, where they have to reach, what is behind them.
- “Ama took off her gloves.”The rule was shown earlier: she has to touch the water. Four words tell the reader what is coming, with no explanation.
- “a strip no wider than a cart, reaching out from her palms”Only here: the escape route exists because of the magic, and its shape sets the action.
- “because the ice could carry people, not horses”A limit, planted in her warning a moment earlier, wins the chase.
- “this time the feeling was not coming back”A real turn. The cost first shown on a bucket now takes something for good.
Before and after
A fight on the outer ring
The one faultNothing in the fight depends on the world; it could happen in any corridor.
Teo caught up with the thief on the outer ring, in the long curve of corridor by the cargo locks. The man turned with a knife. Teo ducked the first swing, got an arm round his neck and drove him into the wall, once, twice, until the knife came loose and clattered to the deck.
By the time the security crew arrived, the thief was sitting against the bulkhead with his hands on his head, and Teo was holding the data spike he had stolen.
Both fights are the same length, in the same corridor, with the same result. The first is well paced, but take the station away and nothing changes: it could be a car park.
In the second, the outer ring’s heavier spin, given in one clause at the start, decides how the fight goes. The thief’s swing carries too far; the knife drops like a spanner. The reader is reminded where they are by what the place does to the bodies in it, and the fight belongs to this book.
The exception
When to break it
Not every big scene has to be strange. A fantasy may hold its strongest moment for a plain conversation in a kitchen, and a science-fiction novel may end with two people on a bench. If the book’s heart is human, its climax may well be too, with the world present as pressure on what is said.
Sometimes a set piece should break the rules the reader knows, on purpose: the magic does what it has never done, because something in the world has changed. That works when the breaking is itself the revelation, and the book goes on to account for it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Only in this world
Four big scenes planned for four speculative novels. Which could only happen in its own world?
Key takeaway
Build your set pieces on what makes your world different, so they could only happen there. Teach the rules on something small beforehand, set out the ground before the action starts, and let the scene change the story for good.
