What a trope promises
Romance readers often choose books by trope: enemies to lovers, fake dating, forced proximity, second chance, a marriage of convenience, the grumpy one and the sunny one. A trope is a familiar situation with a name, and the name works like a menu. It tells a stranger which pleasure is on offer before they open the book.
What a trope is made of
- The situationRivals, a fake relationship, one room left
- The pleasureThe scene the reader comes to this trope for
- The causeWhy it happens to these two, and why now
- The costWhat the situation makes hard for each of them
Each trope has its own. Enemies to lovers offers sparring that slowly turns into respect, and the moment one of them defends the other to a third person. Fake dating offers a pretence that has to be performed in public until one of them forgets it is a pretence. Second chance offers an old hurt reopened by two people who know exactly where it is.
A trope is not a cliché. A cliché is a trope with nothing behind it: the situation is there because the genre has it, not because these two people brought it about. The trope itself is fine. The person who picked your book for it will notice if the cover names it and the book never delivers the scene they came for.
Fresh is not the same as different
The tempting way to freshen a trope is to break it: the enemies become friends by chapter three, the fake relationship is never tested in public. That throws away the thing the reader came for. Freshness comes from inside the trope, in three places.
Freshening a trope
- Name the pleasureThe scene the reader came for
- Give it their causeSomething one of them wants, fears or did
- Make it costWhat the situation puts at risk for each
- Turn one partWho proposes it, what it is for, how it ends
The cause. Why are these two pretending, sparring or sharing a room? If the answer is a storm, a bet or a booking error, the situation could have joined any two people. If the answer is something one of them wants, fears or has done, it could only happen to them.
The cost. A fake relationship that costs nothing is a game. One that means lying to your own mother is a story.
One turn. Change one element of the trope (who proposes it, what it is for, how it is meant to end) and keep the pleasure. One turn is usually enough. Change everything and the trope disappears; change nothing and the reader has read this book before.
Example
A trope planned from the inside
A writer plans her fake-dating romance before drafting. She names the pleasure first, then finds the cause, the cost and the turn.
Trope: fake dating. The pleasure: a pretence that has to be performed in public, again and again, until one of them forgets it is a pretence.1
Why these two, why now: Priya needs a partner at her sister’s wedding because her family still think she gave up her job for a man, and she has let them think it2. Tom needs to be seen with someone settled because the trustees deciding whether he keeps his late father’s café think he is too restless to run it.
What it costs: every public appearance is a lie Priya tells her own mother3. Tom has to play the steady man he is not sure he is.
The turn: usually the one with less to lose proposes it. Here Tom has more to lose, and he still lets Priya set the rules, including the rule for how it ends.4
The moment it stops being pretend: at the wedding, Priya’s mother asks Tom what he loves about her daughter, and he answers too quickly and too exactly, and Priya hears it5.
- “The pleasure: a pretence that has to be performed in public, again…”She starts with what a reader picks up a fake-dating book for, so she can check later that the book delivers it.
- “her family still think she gave up her job for a man, and she has…”The cause is Priya’s own old lie. Nobody else would need this pretence for this reason.
- “every public appearance is a lie Priya tells her own mother”A cost with a face on it. Each scene of the pretence now hurts a little.
- “Here Tom has more to lose, and he still lets Priya set the rules,…”One turn. The trope is intact, and the change already tells us something about Tom.
- “he answers too quickly and too exactly, and Priya hears it”The pleasure, planned as a scene with a particular moment in it, not a summary.
Before and after
One room left
The one faultThe shared room is a convenience of the weather; nothing either of them chose or is brings it about.
The snow had closed the moor road by four o’clock, and the Black Hart had one room left.
“One room,” said the landlord, “and one bed, and I’ll not turn a lady out into that.”
Captain Rowe looked at Miss Fenwick. Miss Fenwick looked at the fire.
“I shall sleep in the chair,” he said.
“You will do no such thing. You have been in the saddle since dawn.” She took the candle from the landlord. “We are neither of us children, Captain. We will manage.”
Both scenes end with the two of them sharing a room, and the dialogue is the same. In the first, the snow and the landlord decide it. Rowe and Miss Fenwick are where any two travellers would be, and the reader enjoys the set-up without learning anything about either of them.
In the second, Miss Fenwick decides it. She gave her room away knowing what that would leave, and Rowe’s line tells us he knows that she knew. The same trope now says something about her generosity, and perhaps her daring, and it hands him a question to carry up the stairs.
The exception
When to break it
Some books play a trope perfectly straight, and their readers are glad of it. A comfort read can deliver exactly the scenes it promised with no turn at all, and the pleasure is in the familiar done with warmth and skill. Even then, the cause and the cost are what make the familiar scenes feel lived.
A comedy can lean on convenience on purpose. A farce in which the storm, the double booking and the wrong suitcase all arrive at once is enjoying the trope as a trope, and the reader is in on the joke.
And a book can set up a trope in order to break it, so long as what replaces it is a pleasure of its own. Signal that early, through the voice or the blurb, so the reader who came for the trope is not left waiting for a scene that will not come.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Fresh without losing it
A fantasy romance is built on enemies to lovers: two envoys from rival cities, sent to the same court to argue over one treaty. The writer worries the trope feels worn. Which change makes it fresh and keeps what the trope offers?
Key takeaway
A trope is a promise of a particular pleasure. Keep the pleasure, give the situation a cause and a cost that belong to these two people, and turn one part of it so the book is unmistakably yours.
