A machine made of people
Fantasy and science fiction love an institution: the academy of magic, the guild, the starship and its crew, the order of knights, the empire’s civil service. It has ranks to climb, rules to learn, rituals, rivals and a uniform. It gives a young lead a world in miniature.
What an institution is made of
- Its wantTo survive, to grow, to win, to keep a secret
- Its ranksWho decides, who obeys, who climbs
- Its rulesEach one serving the want
- Its secretWhat it would rather nobody knew
What turns an institution from a setting into a force is an interest of its own. The academy needs its graduates for a war it will not admit to. The guild keeps its monopoly by keeping a secret. The ship’s first duty is to the company that owns it, not to the crew. Decide what your institution wants, and its rules stop being furniture: each one serves that want, and someone in the building is paid to enforce it.
Where does your lead stand?
Place the lead in the institution and give them a wish about it. Most institution stories run on one of four. They want in: the outsider at the gate. They want up: the cadet who would be captain. They want out: the conscript, the novice with doubts. Or they want to change it: the reformer, the whistle-blower.
Four wishes
Each wish sets a different engine going, and the wish can change across the book. In, then up, then out, is a familiar arc, and a strong one.
Belonging against conscience
The genre’s key scene comes when the institution’s want and the lead’s collide. The academy asks for a friend’s name. The owners order the crew to leave the survivors. The order commands a knight to hold the gate while the village burns. The lead must choose between belonging and what they want or think right, and either way it costs.
Building to the choice
- What belonging givesA place, a family, a future
- The want showsA rule presses on someone
- The collisionAn order against the lead’s conscience
- The choiceBelonging or what is right, at a cost
Build towards it. Show early what belonging gives the lead: a place, a family, a future. Then the choice to risk it means something.
Example
An order on the captain’s channel
A science-fiction novel. A cadet on a company survey ship decodes an order.
The order came through on the captain’s channel at 06.00, and Cadet Imani Rhee was the one who decoded it, because the signals officer was asleep and she wanted him to find it done1.
Survey Vessel Ansgar to abandon salvage of freighter Kittiwake and proceed at once to the Corran field. Crew of Kittiwake to be logged as lost.2
She read it twice. The Kittiwake had nine people aboard, alive, in a hull losing air. The Corran field was a mineral claim the company had been trying to register for a year.
There were two ways out of the decoding room.3 One led to the captain, who would follow the order, as captains who wanted another ship did4. The other led to the open channel, where anyone on the Kittiwake could hear.
Imani had been on board eleven weeks. Her commission would be signed in six more, if her record was clean.5
- “because the signals officer was asleep and she wanted him to find…”Her place and her wish in one line: a cadet who wants up.
- “Crew of Kittiwake to be logged as lost.”The institution’s want shows in its own flat language: the claim matters more than nine lives.
- “There were two ways out of the decoding room.”The collision, made physical: two doors, two loyalties.
- “as captains who wanted another ship did”The rule is kept by people who belong. The captain’s own ambition keeps the machine running.
- “Her commission would be signed in six more, if her record was clean.”What belonging will give her, set out just before she has to risk it.
Before and after
The evening examination
The one faultThe Collegium has no interest of its own: it is a setting, not a force in Petra’s life.
The Collegium bell rang for the evening examination, and Petra joined the line of first-years outside the Long Hall in her grey gown. Inside, the masters sat at their high table under the portraits of the founders. One by one the students were called up to light the brazier without touching it. Petra lit hers at the second try, bowed, and went back to her seat.
Afterwards there was bread and soup, and the second-years sang the Collegium hymn, badly.
The same hall, the same test, the same soup. In the first, the Collegium is a fine backdrop: gowns, portraits, a hymn sung badly. Nothing in it wants anything from Petra.
In the second, one figure at the high table changes the building. The Collegium is sending its best to the Duke, and the reader can guess why. Petra’s deliberate second try tells us she has guessed too. The same rules now serve a want, and the lead has already begun to work against it.
The exception
When to break it
A cosy institution can be the point. A school story that is mostly friendship, rivalry and the end-of-year match may not need its school to have hidden aims at all, and the pleasure is in belonging. Even then, small collisions help: a rule that keeps two friends apart, a tradition the lead has to keep or break.
An institution can also be wholly good, and the story about earning a place in it. What matters is that it asks something of the lead, so that belonging is worth winning.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Setting or force?
A fantasy novel set in an academy of magic. Which detail turns the academy from a setting into a force in the story?
Key takeaway
Give your institution a want of its own, and let its ranks and rules serve it. Place your lead in it with a clear wish: in, up, out or to change it. Show what belonging gives them, then build to the moment when the institution’s want and their conscience collide, and make them choose.
