Two promises in one book
Romance blends easily. Romantasy puts a love story at the centre of a fantasy world. Romantic suspense sets one inside danger. There are science-fiction romances, paranormal romances, historical romances and mystery romances, and each is read by people who came for both halves.
Two ways to blend
That means two promises. The fantasy reader wants the world, the magic and the war to matter and to be settled. The romance reader wants the love story at the centre and a hopeful ending for the pair. A blended book that keeps only one has short-changed half its readers.
The usual way a blend goes wrong is by taking turns. The quest stops so that the two can talk by the fire; the love story waits while the battle is fought. Each strand is fine and the book feels like two books shuffled together. The reader of either half spends half the time waiting for their story to come back.
Books shelved as romantasy also vary in how central the love story is, and in whether each book of a series ends hopefully or only the last. Decide which you are writing, and let the blurb and the opening say so.
Braid at the turns, and let the world push
Two habits keep a blend whole.
Romance turns on plot turns
- They meetAt the trouble that starts the plot
- Drawn closerBy what the plot forces them to do together
- The breakAt the plot’s worst moment, for a reason the world supplies
- The returnInside the climax, not after it
First, put the big turns of the love story on the big turns of the other plot. The two meet at the trouble that starts the plot, or because of it. They are drawn closer by what the plot forces them to do together. The break comes at the plot’s worst moment, and the return happens inside the climax rather than in a calm chapter after it. Not every scene needs to do both jobs. The turns do.
Second, let a rule of the other genre stand between them. In a fantasy it might be a binding that costs one of them years of life, a rank that forbids the match or a magic that cannot touch the person it loves. In romantic suspense, one of them may have a reason to suspect the other. A rule like this makes the world part of the love story instead of its wallpaper. When the pair finally choose each other, they are also answering the world.
Example
A braid map for a romantasy
Before drafting, a writer maps the big turns of her fantasy plot and writes the love story’s movement beside each one.
Two promises. The fantasy: Wren stops the blight before the harvest moon. The romance: Wren and Casimir choose each other, and the book ends with them together.1
The rule between them: a binding between a witch and a warden doubles the witch’s power and shortens the warden’s life2. Casimir is a warden.
The blight reaches the Thornwall farms. Wren needs a warden’s blood for the cure, and Casimir is the only warden who will give it3. (They meet.)
The cure half works. Each time she draws on his blood she feels what he feels, and he feels what she feels. (They are drawn closer, and neither can hide it.)
The blight takes the city. Wren could stop it by binding herself to him, and she refuses, because she will not spend his life. He takes her refusal for disgust.4 (The break, in the same scene as the plot’s worst moment.)
At the harvest moon he asks her in front of the whole council, and she says yes knowing the price, because he has shown her it is his to spend. The binding stops the blight.5 (The return and the climax are one scene.)
- “Two promises. The fantasy: Wren stops the blight before the harves…”Both promises named in a line each, so she can check that each is kept.
- “a binding between a witch and a warden doubles the witch’s power a…”A rule of the world that stands between the two. Choosing each other will cost something real.
- “Casimir is the only warden who will give it”They meet because of the plot, and the meeting already says something about him.
- “she refuses, because she will not spend his life. He takes her ref…”The break comes from the rule and from what each believes, in the same scene as the plot’s worst moment.
- “The binding stops the blight.”The return and the climax are one act. Neither reader has to wait for the other’s ending.
Before and after
Something true, in a safe house
The one faultThe intimate moment has nothing to do with the danger, so the thriller stops while the romance runs.
The safe house was a holiday flat above a closed café, and the radiator ticked all night. Neither of them slept.
“Tell me something true,” Jonah said from the other end of the sofa. “Anything. I’ve been lying to people for three days.”
Nadia pulled the blanket up to her chin. Outside, a car went slowly past, and they both waited until it had gone.
“When I was nine,” she said, “I wanted to keep a lighthouse. I wrote to every lighthouse in the country. One of them wrote back.”
He laughed, very quietly, and she listened to the sound for a long time after he had gone still.
Both scenes are quiet and close, and both turn on the same request: tell me something true. In the first, Nadia offers a lovely childhood memory. It draws the two of them together, and while it does, the thriller is switched off. Nothing about the danger has changed by the end.
In the second, the true thing is about the dead man. Telling it is the most intimate thing she has done, and it is also the most dangerous, because it gives Jonah a reason to suspect her. One confession turns both plots at once, and the last line leaves the reader worried about the case and the couple together.
The exception
When to break it
Not every book with a love story in it is a blend of equal halves. A fantasy with a romantic subplot is a fantasy: its love story can sit lighter, and it need not end hopefully. A romance with a light mystery may let the mystery be a small thing. What matters is that you know which promise is the main one and that the cover and the blurb agree.
A long series can also spread the love story across several books, with each book giving the relationship one real turn and a pause that holds. Readers who know that in advance will wait; readers who were told this was a standalone romance will not.
And a single quiet chapter in which one strand rests is fine. The trouble is a pattern of resting, not one breath.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Where does the declaration go?
In a romantic suspense draft, the climax is a chase through a flooded marina, where the detective saves the witness from the killer. Two chapters later, in a calm epilogue over breakfast, the two finally say they love each other. A reader says the ending feels like two endings. Which change braids the strands best?
Key takeaway
A blended book makes two promises. Name both, make the big turns of the love story land on the big turns of the other plot, and let a rule of that other genre stand between the two, so that choosing each other means answering the world.
