What a romance offers
The word “romance” is used loosely for any story with love in it. As the name of a genre it means something narrower. Romance Writers of America has described a romance novel by two things. The love story is central: the main plot is about people falling in love and struggling to make it work, whatever subplots run alongside. And the ending is emotionally satisfying and optimistic.
What the reader is offered
- A central love storyThe main plot is falling in love and making it work
- An optimistic endingHappily ever after, or happy for now
- The question is howNot whether these two will get together
Writers and readers often call that ending a happily ever after, or a happy for now when the pair are together and hopeful and nothing more is settled. Either keeps the promise. A wedding is not required. A parting, however beautiful, makes a different kind of book.
So the reader of a romance begins knowing how it will end. That sounds like a handicap for the writer, and it is the reverse. Nobody is asking whether these two will get together. They are asking how, and what it will cost, and that puts all the weight on the two people.
Two people, four reasons
If the ending is known, the interest has to come from resistance. Each of the two needs a reason to hold back, and it should be a reason of their own: something they would have to give up, risk or stop believing in order to choose the other. Each also needs a reason to give way, and the reader should see it happen. “She was drawn to him” is a report. What he did at the auction that she could not stop thinking about is a reason.
One obstacle or four reasons
That makes four reasons, two apiece. When one is missing the story tilts. If only one of them has an obstacle, the other becomes a prize waiting to be collected.
One rough description of the shape, in general use and not from any one book, is four movements: the two meet, they are drawn closer, something breaks them apart, and they find their way back. Gwen Hayes’s Romancing the Beat is one book-length guide to the beats in more detail. Treat any such map as a description of what tends to happen when two people with good reasons to resist are put in each other’s way.
Example
A first meeting with all four reasons in it
Two strangers at a house-clearance auction want the same piano. Look for what each wants, what makes each an obstacle to the other, and what each does that the other cannot ignore.
Lot forty-one was an upright piano with a cigarette burn on the lid, and Jelena had already worked out what it would fetch with the burn gone.
“You’ll want to check the D above middle C,”1 said the man beside her. He had bid against her twice on the bookcase and lost. “It sticks in damp weather.”
“Then you’ve just cost yourself the piano. I’d have paid more not knowing.”
“You’d have found out by Friday and thought worse of me.” He kept his eyes on the auctioneer. “It was my mother’s. My brother sold it with the house.”2
Jelena had rent due and a workshop with nothing in it.3 She looked at his raised hand, which was not quite steady, and at the burn, which she now knew somebody had made.
“Sixty,” she said, and hated how sorry she sounded.4
- ““You’ll want to check the D above middle C,””He tells a rival bidder about a fault, against his own interest. This is her reason to weaken, and it is something he does.
- ““It was my mother’s. My brother sold it with the house.””His want, and it is the opposite of hers. She wants the piano to sell. He wants it because it cannot be replaced.
- “Jelena had rent due and a workshop with nothing in it.”Her reason to resist. She cannot afford to be kind, and the scene says so in money.
- ““Sixty,” she said, and hated how sorry she sounded.”She bids against him anyway, so the conflict is real, and she is sorry, so the pull is real too. Both sit in one line.
Before and after
One obstacle or two
The one faultOnly one of the two has a reason to hold back.
The garrison would march at first thaw, and everyone at the ford knew it. Iker had told her so himself in the autumn, to be honest with her, and had gone on mending her ferry rope all winter as if honesty settled the matter.
“The ice is going,” Nomsa said. She had brought him bread, as she did most mornings.
“Ten days. Perhaps twelve.” He tested the splice and did not look up. “I gave my oath for seven years. I have served four.”
“I know what you gave.”
“Then you know I can’t ask you anything.”
“You could ask,” she said. “I’d wait the three years. I’d wait longer. There’s nothing for me to weigh, Iker. I have only ever wanted you to stay.”
He pulled the splice tight and found he had no answer to that.
The two versions are the same until Nomsa’s last speech. In the first she offers to wait and says there is nothing for her to weigh. That is a generous thing to say, and it empties the scene. The only obstacle left is his oath, so the love story has one question, which is whether he will ask, and she can do nothing in it but wait for him.
In the second version she has a crossing to keep and a brother who would lose it. Now each of them would have to give up something that is theirs. His oath and her ferry pull in different directions, neither is in the wrong, and the reader cannot see the way through. The last line has not changed, but it means more: in the first version he has no answer to her kindness, and in the second he has no answer to a problem as hard as his own.
The exception
When to break it
The four movements describe a tendency, and good romances leave parts of it out. Some have no break at all: the pair come together in the middle of the book and face an outside trouble side by side, and the tension comes from whether the two of them can hold. Some start long after the meeting, with a couple who are already married and have to find each other again.
Parts a romance can leave out
A lead can also be sure from the first page. That works when the book is about the other person’s resistance and the certain one still has something to lose by waiting.
The ending is the part with least give. A love story that ends in death or parting can be a great book, as Romeo and Juliet is a great play, but it makes a different promise, and it helps to tell the reader which one they are getting. If your story needs the sad ending, write it, and call it a love story.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which ending keeps the promise?
A love story between a ship’s cook and a harbour pilot has been the main plot of a novel. Which of these endings fits the description of a romance given in the lesson: a central love story with an emotionally satisfying and optimistic ending?
Key takeaway
A romance promises a love story at the centre and a hopeful ending for the pair. Because the ending is known, the interest lies in the resistance. Give each lead a reason of their own to hold back and let the reader watch each one find a reason to give way.
