Lesson 3 of 21
The Market · stone 3Intermediate5 minute read

Mystery

A puzzle solved fairly: clues the reader is shown, false trails that are honestly explained, and a reveal the reader could have reached.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Market: a busy square of stalls under striped awnings.
The Market · Genre conventions, stone 3 of 21

A puzzle the reader could solve

A mystery offers its reader a puzzle and a fair chance at it. The second half of that sentence is what separates the genre from a story that merely has a secret in it.

Every fact the solution depends on is shown to the reader before the detective explains.

The idea is usually called fair play. S. S. Van Dine put it first in a list of twenty rules he published in 1928: the reader should have the same opportunity as the detective to solve the mystery. In practice it comes down to one test. Every fact the solution depends on is shown to the reader before the detective explains. The detective may keep her conclusions to herself for most of the book. She may not keep the facts.

Three working parts follow from that. A clue is a fact that points to the truth. A red herring is a fact that points away from it, and turns out to have an innocent explanation. The reveal is the scene where the clues are put together. The reader’s pleasure there is double: surprise at the answer, and the sense that they were shown everything and still missed it.

Hiding a clue without lying

If the facts have to be shown, the craft lies in showing them so that they are not weighed. Flagging is the thing to avoid. “She noticed something odd about the cup” tells the reader to stop and think, and the clue is spent.

Show a clue so that it is not weighed, and give a red herring room and noise, with its innocent explanation owed later.

There are honest ways to make a true statement easy to pass over. Put the clue in the middle of a list, where items are skimmed. Follow it at once with something louder: a shout, an arrival, a joke. Let a character give it a wrong meaning, so the reader files it under that meaning. Or split it, so that one half appears in chapter three and the other in chapter twelve and neither means anything alone.

A red herring works the other way round. It is given room and noise, and somebody in the scene is excited about it. The fair-play test applies to it as well. When the false trail is dropped, the story owes the reader the innocent explanation, so that looking back they can see they were misdirected and not cheated.

Example

One clue, one false trail

Much later in this novel it will matter that Mrs Lindgren’s visitor was left-handed. The boot prints belong to the gardener, who came to the step that morning and went away again. Watch how the page treats each.

The second cupmystery

Inspector Abena Quaye stood in the doorway of the breakfast room and let her eyes go round it once before anything was moved.

A newspaper, folded to the crossword. A rack with two slices of toast, uneaten. Mrs Lindgren’s cup at her place, and across the table a second cup with its handle turned to the left and the spoon laid on that side1. A marmalade jar, lid off. A wasp walking round the rim.2

“Ma’am!” Constable Maddocks was at the garden door, pointing down. “Boot prints. Big ones, coming right up to the step, and fresh.”3

“So they are.” She went and looked, because he was pleased with them. Size eleven or so, with a split in the left heel.

“Find me whoever does the garden,”4 she said.

  1. “a second cup with its handle turned to the left and the spoon laid…”The clue, stated in plain words. It is the fourth item in a list of six, and nobody remarks on it.
  2. “A wasp walking round the rim.”A small moving thing, placed straight after the clue. The eye follows the wasp.
  3. ““Boot prints. Big ones, coming right up to the step, and fresh.””The false trail gets everything the clue did not: a shout, an excited constable, a paragraph to itself.
  4. ““Find me whoever does the garden,””The inspector follows the prints honestly. They will get their innocent explanation, so the reader has been misdirected and not lied to.

Before and after

The fact the reader did not see

The one faultThe solution rests on a fact the reader was not shown.

Weaker versionDry cuffs (first version)

The misters in Pod Two came on every ten minutes, and by the second time Officer Nandini Bose’s collar was stuck to her neck. Trays of seedlings ran the length of the pod under violet lamps. One tray stood empty.

“I was here the whole shift,” said the technician, a big, tidy man called Goran. “Six hours. I never left the pod, and nobody came in.”

Nandini looked at the empty tray, and at the door log, which agreed with him.

“You weren’t in here six hours,” she said. “You weren’t in here for one. Look at your cuffs. Nobody stays dry in this pod.”

Showing the weaker version.

In both versions the officer catches the technician in a lie, and her reasoning is the same: anyone who had spent six hours under those misters would be damp. In the first version the reader hears about his dry cuffs only when she accuses him. They were given the misters and her wet collar, but not the one fact that settles it, so they had no way of getting there first.

The second version adds two short sentences. He folds his arms, and his cuffs are crisp. That is all. It comes straight after his alibi and before she looks at the door log, which seems to clear him, so it is easy to pass over. When she speaks, they can look back four lines and find that they were told.

The exception

When to break it

Fair play is the convention of the puzzle mystery, and a crime story can choose to play another game. In some stories the reader watches the crime being done in the first chapter and knows who did it; the interest is in how the detective will get there, or in why it was done. In others the investigator never fully solves the case, and the book is about what the search does to her. Neither owes the reader a solvable puzzle, because neither offered one.

If your book invites the reader to solve it, show them what the solver needs.

Even within the puzzle tradition, the old lists mixed fairness with taste. Van Dine’s twenty rules also ruled out a love interest, more than one culprit and long passages of description. A love story or two culprits working together does nothing to make a puzzle less fair, so those rules are preferences you are free to weigh for yourself. The fairness is the part this lesson is about. If your book invites the reader to solve it, show them what the solver needs.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Which one is unfair?

By the fair-play test in the lesson, which of these treats the reader unfairly?

Key takeaway

In a mystery the detective may hide what she thinks, but the story shows the reader every fact the solution uses. State the clue plainly and let its surroundings hide it. Give the false trail the noise, and explain it honestly when it is dropped.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

A clue table for your mystery

List every fact your solution depends on, and check that the reader is shown each one before the reveal.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.