A label and the evidence
“Tessa was angry.” That sentence names a feeling. The name is a label: a single word that sums up what is going on inside someone. This lesson calls words like angry, afraid, relief and shame named emotions.
- The bodyHer neck went red
- ActionShe stacked the plates so hard that the bottom one cracked
- Speech“No, you sit. You’ve had a long day.”
- ThoughtEleven years, and he still did not know where the plates went
A label is a conclusion. Somebody has watched Tessa, added things up and handed you the total. The other way to write the moment is to give the reader the things that were added up, and let them reach the total themselves. Those things are the evidence, and they come from four places.
The body: what happens to a person without their choosing it. Her neck went red.
Action: what the person does. She stacked the plates so hard that the bottom one cracked.
Speech: what they say, and what they leave out. “No, you sit. You’ve had a long day.”
Thought: what runs through their head, in their own words. Eleven years, and he still did not know where the plates went.
Showing feeling means building the moment out of evidence like this, so that the reader knows what Tessa feels although nobody has said the word.
Why go to the trouble?
Two reasons.
General and particular
The first is that evidence is how we read people in life. Nobody hands us a label. We see the red neck and the cracked plate and we know. A reader who works a feeling out from the evidence has taken part in the scene, instead of being handed its result.
The second is that a label is general and evidence is particular. “Angry” covers a thousand different kinds of anger. A woman who offers her husband a chair in a voice like a slammed door has one kind, and it is hers.
There is one condition. The feeling still has to be clear. Try this test: if a stranger read only your evidence, could they name the feeling? If they could not, the cure is more evidence, or better evidence. Adding the label back on top of evidence that is already working tells the reader twice.
Example
Four kinds of evidence
A boy is waiting for his turn at a music audition. No feeling is named anywhere in the passage. As you read, notice where each piece of evidence comes from.
There were six chairs outside the music room and Deepak had tried four of them1. He unscrewed the cap of the valve oil, though he had oiled all three valves at home, and oiled them again2. A drop ran down his wrist.
“Is it hot in here?”3 he asked the girl with the cello.
“Not really.”
He nodded as if that settled something. His tongue kept sticking to the roof of his mouth4, and a trumpet player needs a wet mouth. Bar nineteen.5 If he could get past bar nineteen, the rest would play itself. Behind the door somebody else’s scale climbed, cracked on the top note and started over.
- “Deepak had tried four of them”Action. He cannot settle, and we watch him not settling. Nobody has to say “restless”.
- “oiled them again”Action again, and a telling kind: something he does although it does not need doing.
- ““Is it hot in here?””Speech. He does not say “I’m nervous”. He asks about the room, and the girl’s answer tells us the heat is his alone.
- “His tongue kept sticking to the roof of his mouth”The body, doing something he has not chosen and does not want.
- “Bar nineteen.”Thought, in his own words. We learn exactly what he is afraid of without the word “afraid”.
Before and after
The same wedding, twice
The one faultEvery feeling is named for the reader.
The seating plan stood on an easel by the marquee door. Layla found her own name at table nine, and then, two places along, his. She was shocked. She had been told he was working abroad until October. As she read the card a second time she grew anxious, and under the anxiety there was a small, unwelcome excitement.
“Table nine,” said her aunt, arriving at her shoulder. “Lovely. You’re near the band.”
“Lovely,” said Layla, who was now thoroughly miserable.
The first version is clear and tidy, and it is not badly written. Its one weakness is that Layla’s feelings arrive as labels: shocked, anxious, excitement, miserable. We are told four results and shown none of the working.
The second version keeps the same events and the same two lines of speech. Each label has been swapped for evidence. For “shocked” she reads the card again, like a bill that has come to too much. For “anxious” she counts the names between his and hers. The “small, unwelcome excitement” has become a hand that goes to her hair before she can stop it. And “miserable” is now a thought about hiding in the toilets, which also happens to be funnier.
Notice that the second version is longer. Evidence usually is. That is the price, and it is one reason not to pay it for every feeling in a book.
The exception
When to break it
Naming a feeling is not a mistake. It is a tool with its own uses.
When to name it
Name the feeling when it is small and the story needs to keep moving. “She was glad of the coat” does not deserve a paragraph of evidence.
Name it in summary, when you are covering a week in a few lines: “He was miserable all that winter.”
Let characters name their own feelings in speech or in thought whenever it suits them. “I’m not angry,” said through closed teeth, is good evidence in itself.
Name a feeling when it is unusual and the reader would guess wrong: “What he felt, watching the coffin go down, was closer to embarrassment than grief.” Here the exact label is the surprise.
And many books for young children name feelings often and on purpose, because learning those names is part of what such books are for.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one shows it?
A footballer has just been sent off. Which sentence shows what he feels without naming it?
Key takeaway
A named emotion gives the reader your conclusion. Evidence from the body, from action, from speech and from thought lets the reader reach it, and makes the feeling belong to one particular person. Save evidence for the feelings that matter, check that a stranger could still name them, and do not add the label on top.
