The reactions everybody has
A writer who has stopped naming feelings reaches for evidence, and the first evidence to arrive tends to be the same. Hearts pound. Breath is caught, held and let out. Stomachs drop, spines shiver, knees go weak, jaws tighten and tears prick.
“Her heart pounded”
These are stock gestures: reactions so common in fiction that they could be handed to any character in any book. Nothing about them is false. Bodies really do these things. The trouble lies elsewhere, and it comes in two parts.
First, each has been used so often that it hardly makes a picture any more. “Her heart pounded” is read as “she was afraid” and passed over. It has become a label in disguise.
Second, a stock gesture tells us nothing about who is having it. A surgeon, a shepherd and a nine-year-old all get the same pounding heart. A moment of strong feeling is one of the best chances a writer has to show what a person is made of, and the stock gesture spends that chance on something the reader already knew.
Finding the reaction that belongs to this person
A particular reaction usually comes from asking questions about the person, and seldom from thinking harder about the body.
- What does their work train?A nurse counts; a carpenter looks at how the door is hung
- What does this resemble?Shouted at as a child: still and polite
- What is within reach?Feeling leaks into what they are holding
- What would they refuse to show?The effort of hiding is better evidence
What does their work train them to do? Under pressure people fall back on what their hands and eyes have practised. A nurse counts. A carpenter looks at how the door is hung.
What have they been through that this resembles? Someone who grew up being shouted at may go still and polite.
What is within reach? Feeling often leaks into whatever the person happens to be holding or doing.
What would they refuse to let show? The effort of hiding is often better evidence than the thing hidden.
When you have a candidate, try the swap test. Give the reaction to another character in the scene. If it suits them just as well, it is fresh but still general. If it would look wrong on anyone else, you have found the one you wanted.
Keep hold of one thing while you do this: the reader must still be able to tell what the feeling is. A reaction can be so private that it reads as a puzzle.
Example
A piano tuner hears a note
A woman is alone, tuning a piano in a house that is supposed to be empty. Watch what she does in place of the gasp and the shiver.
Sunita had the lid of the downstairs piano propped open and was fitting her lever to a pin when a single note sounded on the floor above.
She did not look up.1 The A below middle C, she thought, and flat by a hair2, and the house had been empty since March.
She took the lever off the pin. She laid it on the cloth beside her mutes, square to the edge3, the way she laid it at the end of a job. Then she stood and waited for the note to finish dying, because she had never in her life walked away from a string that was still sounding4.
It did not finish. It grew.
- “She did not look up.”Her first reaction is a refusal. The stock version would have her head snap up. This tells us she is someone who finishes a thought before she lets herself be frightened.
- “The A below middle C, she thought, and flat by a hair”Her trade answers before her fear does. Nobody else in the book could have this reaction, because nobody else would know the note.
- “square to the edge”Fear shown as too much neatness. She is putting her tools in order because the house is not in order.
- “she had never in her life walked away from a string that was still…”A lifelong habit keeps her in the room. The reaction is hers alone, and it also makes the scene worse for her.
Before and after
Pinning the hem
The one faultAileen’s reactions are all stock gestures.
Aileen knelt to pin the hem. Above her the bride was telling the mirror about the breakfast, the carriage, the house he had taken for them in the square. Two summers ago he had walked Aileen home from chapel every Sunday.
“And he says I am to have the blue room for my own,” the girl said. “Do you know the house?”
Aileen’s heart clenched. Her breath caught in her throat and her hands began to tremble. “I know the square, miss,” she said.
“You must come and see it. I shall need curtains.”
A lump rose in Aileen’s throat, and she blinked back tears. “Turn to the window, miss, if you please.”
A dressmaker is fitting a wedding dress for the bride of a man who once walked her home every Sunday. In both versions she hides what she feels, and the spoken lines are identical.
In the first, her feeling arrives as five reactions we have read many times: a heart that clenches, a caught breath, trembling hands, a lump in the throat, tears blinked back. Each is clear. Together they could belong to any heartsick woman in any novel.
The second gives her a dressmaker’s reactions. The pin between her lips saves her from having to answer at once. She sets a pin in the wrong place, which a woman of her skill does not do, and corrects it. She measures a hem she has measured twice. Then comes the thought that only she would have, because only she knows the yardage and who paid for it. We learn how she feels, and we learn that she is proud of her work and has no intention of being seen.
The exception
When to break it
Stock gestures have real uses, and a book with none at all would be tiring.
When the stock gesture earns it
They are quick. In a chase or a fight there is no room for an invented reaction, and “her pulse was going hard” keeps the reader in touch with the body without stopping the run.
They suit small moments and minor characters. A waiter startled by a dropped tray does not need a reaction drawn from his childhood.
In some kinds of story a familiar physical beat is part of the pleasure, the way a chorus is part of a song. A love scene with no quickened pulse anywhere may feel as if something has been withheld.
Sometimes the stock reaction is simply the true one. People do shake. When you keep it, make it do something: “her hands shook so badly that the key scratched all round the lock” is a shake the story can use.
The opposite fault exists as well. If every flicker of feeling becomes an original set piece, the reader stops being moved and starts admiring the writer. Spend the particular reaction on the moments that count.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Whose reaction is it?
A retired goalkeeper is woken in the night by glass breaking downstairs. Which reaction could only be his?
Key takeaway
A stock gesture shows the feeling and nothing else. At the moments that matter, ask what this person’s work, past and habits would make them do, and test the answer by trying it on someone else. Keep the feeling readable, and let the quick, familiar reactions carry the small moments.
