Two sets of feelings
Every scene involves two sets of feelings: the character’s and the reader’s. The earlier lessons in this element treated them as one: show the character’s fear well and the reader will share it.
Three ways to move a reader, after Maass
But the two can be pulled apart, and some strong effects live in the space between them. A child packs happily for what she has been told is a holiday, and the reader, who knows better, can hardly bear it. A man congratulates himself on his own tact, and the reader winces for everyone else in the room.
Donald Maass, in The Emotional Craft of Fiction, sorts the ways of moving a reader into three. A story can tell what a character feels. It can show it and let the reader infer. Or it can bring the reader to feel something the character does not, which he calls “other mode”.
So ask two questions of any scene that matters. What does she feel here? And what do I want the reader to feel? Sometimes the answers will match. Make that a decision.
Where the gap comes from
A gap between reader and character has one of two sources.
Where the gap comes from
Knowledge. The reader knows a fact the character does not. The character acts sensibly on what she knows, and the reader watches with the missing piece in hand. This is dramatic irony, which has a lesson of its own under Subtext.
Judgement. Reader and character have the same facts and weigh them differently. He thinks he was being generous; we can see that he was being controlling. Nothing is hidden; the character simply draws the wrong conclusion.
Either way, the feeling has to come out of the situation. Three things spoil it: a narrator who leans in to say that this is ominous, or sad; a character who conveniently notices too much and starts to share the reader’s unease for no reason of her own; and a fact planted so faintly that the reader misses it.
Plant the fact plainly and early, then let the character be true to what she knows.
Example
A father helps
A retired man has spent the day in his grown-up daughter’s kitchen while she is at work. He is content throughout. Notice what you feel, and which details make you feel it.
Cyril had the whole kitchen done by three. He had started with the cupboard over the kettle, where Joyce kept mugs, glasses and a jar of dried pasta all on the one shelf, and once you had seen that you could not leave the rest1. The plates now lived by the cooker, where a person needed them2. The spices were in alphabetical order. He had thrown out a quantity of things that were plainly finished with: an inch of oil, some bent birthday candles, a postcard stuck to the fridge door, so faded you could hardly make out the writing3.
He put the kettle on and sat down to wait for his daughter’s key in the lock. She would be tired. She was always tired, and no wonder, living like this. He had left one cupboard as it was, so that she could see the difference4.
- “once you had seen that you could not leave the rest”His reasoning, in his own voice, with no comment from the narrator. The reader begins to judge differently from here.
- “where a person needed them”His certainty again. He means any sensible person. We hear that he means himself.
- “a postcard stuck to the fridge door, so faded you could hardly mak…”The detail that opens the gap. To him, faded means finished with. To the reader, a card kept on a fridge until it fades is something that mattered to her.
- “so that she could see the difference”He is looking forward to her face. So are we, with a different feeling, and the scene stops before she arrives.
Before and after
A bath, and a man in a car
The one faultThe narrator tells the reader to be worried.
Across the road, the man in the grey car wrote down the time the upstairs light came on, as he had the two nights before.
The lock on the back door had been sticking all week, so Sinead left it on the latch and went up. It was a mistake she would have cause to regret. She ran a bath. She poured a glass of the good wine and balanced it on the edge with a book she had been meaning to start since the spring. The water was exactly right.
She read a page. She read it again, for the pleasure of knowing that nobody in the world needed her until morning. An ominous stillness had settled over the house. Somewhere below a floorboard ticked, the way the old boards did when the heating went off. She turned the hot tap with her foot and slid down until the water closed over her ears. It was the last peaceful moment she would know for a long time.
Both versions give the reader a fact in the first sentence that Sinead does not have: a man is watching the house, and it is his third night. That sentence comes from outside her head, but it only reports what is happening across the road. Both versions then follow her through an evening of real contentment.
In the first version the narrator steps in three more times, to forecast and to judge: “a mistake she would have cause to regret”, “an ominous stillness”, “the last peaceful moment she would know”. Each tells the reader something they had already worked out, and pulls them out of the bathroom to listen to the author.
The second version cuts those three sentences and nothing else. Now every pleasant detail is frightening without help. The door left on the latch, the floorboard she explains away, the water closing over her ears: she is right to enjoy them, on what she knows, and we cannot enjoy any of them.
The exception
When to break it
Most scenes in most novels keep reader and character together, and that is no fault. A book made entirely of gaps holds its people at arm’s length.
Keep the gap in hand
A gap also has a shelf life. If the reader knows something for too long and the character still has not seen it, sympathy turns into impatience: how can she not notice? Let the character catch up before that happens, and make the catching-up a scene.
Nor is the narrator’s nudge a fault in every book. Some books are told by a storyteller who stands outside the action and says openly what is coming. Used from the first page as part of the voice, a line such as “It was the last summer they would all spend in that house” can be very fine. So can a narrator looking back on her own younger self: “I did not know it then.” What jars is the nudge dropped into a scene otherwise told from close inside one character, in a voice the book has not prepared us to hear.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The bear in the pocket
A boy of six is helping his mother pack “for an adventure”. From the chapter before, the reader knows the family is being put out of its home. The scene is told from close inside the boy. The writer wants him to stay happy and the reader to ache for him. Which closing line serves that best?
Key takeaway
For each scene that matters, decide what the character feels and what you want the reader to feel, and whether those are the same. If they differ, open the gap with a fact the reader has or a judgement the reader can make. Then keep the character true and the narrator quiet.
