Asking and earning
At the big moments of a story, the death, the parting, the return, a writer wants the reader to feel a great deal. There are two ways to go about it.
Asking and earning
One is to ask. The language rises to meet the occasion. Intensifiers arrive: utterly, unbearably, so very. Large abstract words arrive: agony, anguish, despair. Figures of speech pile up, hearts shatter, and the narrator steps forward to say that this was the saddest day of her life.
The other way is to earn it. Before the moment comes, the reader is given what they need in order to care. Then, at the moment itself, the writing goes quiet and lets the situation speak.
Asking tends to fail for a simple reason. Words like “unbearable” describe the size of a feeling without giving anyone cause to have it. The reader is told that a great deal is being felt, and watches from outside. When a story asks for more feeling than it has given the reader reason for, that is what people tend to mean by sentimental.
Where the weight comes from
The weight of an emotional moment is nearly all in what came before it.
Where the weight comes from
- Before: exactly what is lostA mother who labelled every tub in the freezer, with orders
- Plant something smallAn object, a habit, a phrase that can come back
- At the moment, do lessPlain words, a small action, stop a sentence early
The reader needs to know what, exactly, is being lost or won. “Her beloved mother” gives them nothing to hold. A mother who labelled every tub in the freezer, with orders, is a person they can miss.
It helps to plant something small and concrete that can come back: an object, a habit, a phrase. When it returns at the moment of feeling, it brings everything attached to it, and the writer does not have to say a word about emotion.
Then, at the moment, do less. Use plain words and things that can be seen. Let the character do something small. End on an action, and stop a sentence earlier than feels safe. The gap you leave is where the reader’s own feeling goes.
Example
Clearing a kitchen
A woman is emptying her mother’s house after her death. Notice what is planted, and how plain the language is when it returns.
Her mother had labelled everything. Amira had grown up with it: masking tape on every tub in the freezer, giving the contents, the month and usually an order. SOUP, MARCH, DO NOT ADD SALT.1 Her brothers used to read them out in their mother’s voice.2
It took Amira the whole of Saturday to empty the kitchen. She did the freezer last, working down through the drawers with a bin bag open at her feet. Peas. Bread ends, for the birds. Stock.3 In the bottom drawer, at the back, there was a single tub with a strip of tape gone grey with frost.
AMIRA’S, it said. LENTILS, THE WAY SHE LIKES. JUNE.4
It was November. She had not been home in June.5 She put the tub on the counter, and after a while she turned the oven on6.
- “SOUP, MARCH, DO NOT ADD SALT.”The setup, and it is nearly a joke. We learn the habit and hear the bossy, loving voice. Nothing here asks us to be sad.
- “Her brothers used to read them out in their mother’s voice.”Now the labels are her voice. Whatever a label says from here on, we will hear her say it.
- “Peas. Bread ends, for the birds. Stock.”The plainest possible language, just before the moment. Three ordinary things, and the reader’s guard is down.
- “AMIRA’S, it said. LENTILS, THE WAY SHE LIKES. JUNE.”The moment. The planted thing comes back, and the only words are the label’s own. No adjective, and no feeling named.
- “She had not been home in June.”The weight, in seven plain words. Lentils made for her in June, and she was not there. The reader does that sum without help.
- “after a while she turned the oven on”It ends on an action and stops. We are not told what she felt as she ate.
Before and after
The gate in spring
The one faultThe language demands feeling that the situation was already providing.
For thirty springs the first caravan up the pass had been Bahar’s, and for thirty springs she had rung her mule-bell three times below the gate, because twice could be anyone.
This year the bell rang three times, and when Mandla had the bar up and the gate dragged back through the old snow, it was a young man who stood there with the lead mule. He had her nose. He had the bell in his hand, not on the harness, and at the sight of it a terrible, crushing wave of grief crashed over Mandla, so vast and so utterly overwhelming that he thought his poor old heart would shatter into a thousand pieces.
“She said you’d want the count,” the young man said. “Forty mules. Same as ever.”
Mandla counted them through with hot tears streaming down his weathered face. Forty. He lowered the bar. Then he went into the gatehouse and took the second cup down off its nail, and stood holding it, and could not think where a thing like that should be kept. It was the most heartbreakingly, unbearably lonely moment of his entire long life.
The two versions have the same setup, the same events and the same closing action. The setup is good in both: thirty springs, three rings, and then a young man with her nose, holding the bell.
The first version does not trust it. At the sight of the bell a crushing wave of grief crashes, a heart threatens to shatter into a thousand pieces, tears stream down a weathered face, and a last sentence announces the loneliest moment of a long life. By the end the reader is looking at the adjectives and has lost sight of the cup.
The second version removes those additions and changes nothing else. Nobody says what has become of Bahar. Nobody says what Mandla feels. A man counts forty mules because he was asked to, and then cannot think where to keep a cup. The reader, who knows whose cup it was, does not need telling.
The exception
When to break it
Restraint is a strong default at moments of high feeling. It is not the only honest way to write.
Other honest ways
Some kinds of story run hot on purpose. Gothic fiction, melodrama, some epic fantasy and some romance use a heightened voice from the first page, and that voice is part of what they offer. In those books a quiet climax might feel like a failure of nerve. Even there the setup still has to be done. What rings false is heightened language used in place of that weight.
A narrator who is an excitable person may gush, and the gushing tells us who they are.
Restraint can fail too. Writing can be so buttoned up that nothing gets through. After pages of control, one direct sentence, “She missed him”, can be the strongest in the book, because it is the only one of its kind.
In either case, ask: has the reader been given cause to feel this, or only told that someone does?
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
At the churchyard gate
Over several chapters a novel has shown a grandfather teaching his granddaughter to whistle through a blade of grass. He has now died. Which line from the day of the funeral trusts that setup to do the work?
Key takeaway
Feeling at a big moment is earned beforehand, by giving the reader something particular to care about and, if you can, a small concrete thing that will come back. When the moment arrives, write it plainly, end on an action and leave room. If the weight is in the situation, the language can stay quiet.
