Two ways to say who is speaking
A reader of dialogue needs one thing before anything else: to know who is talking. There are two common ways to tell them.
Two ways to say who is talking
A dialogue tag names the speaker with a speech verb: she said, Daly asked. An action beat is a sentence of action placed in the same paragraph as the speech: Daly turned the book round. “Then who wrote this one?” The beat needs no speech verb. By convention a paragraph belongs to one speaker, so readers take the person acting to be the person talking.
“Said” is the usual tag because readers tend to pass over it. It works like punctuation: it does its job and the eye moves on. Tags such as snarled, retorted or gushed, and adverbs such as angrily, are louder. They help when they carry something the spoken words cannot. They get in the way when they repeat what the words already show.
What a beat can do that a tag cannot
A tag only attributes. A beat attributes and does a second job at the same time. It can show where people are in the room, keep an object in play, mark a pause, or let a character do something that sits oddly against what they have just said. That last use is the most valuable. Someone who says “I’m fine” while lining up the pencils is telling the reader two things at once.
What it costs to say who spoke
- Nothing at allTwo people, clear turns
- “said”Read like punctuation
- A beat“I’m fine,” while lining up the pencils
Beats cost more than tags, though. Each one is a sentence the reader has to picture, so a beat on every line slows the scene and starts to look like fidgeting. When only two people are talking and the turns are clear, the cheapest attribution is none at all. Several lines in a row can run without a tag or a beat.
Example
In a scene
A shopkeeper is being asked about her dead father’s accounts. Six lines are spoken. Count how many carry a tag.
Inspector Daly put the ledger on the counter between them.1 “Your handwriting?”
“My father’s,” said Nora Pell2. “I only add up.”
“The last entry is Thursday.”3
“He was alive on Thursday.”
Daly turned the book round so that it faced her. A column of figures ran down the page in brown ink, and halfway down the ink changed to blue. “Then who wrote this one?”
She did not look at it. She straightened the jar of pencils by the till, though it was already straight.4 “We ran out of the brown,” she whispered5.
- “Inspector Daly put the ledger on the counter between them.”A beat. It names the speaker before he speaks and puts the ledger where both of them, and the reader, can see it.
- “said Nora Pell”A plain tag, placed at the first natural pause so that we know who is answering before the line is over.
- ““The last entry is Thursday.””No tag and no beat. Two people are taking turns, so the reader knows this is Daly.
- “She straightened the jar of pencils by the till, though it was alr…”A beat that works against the line that follows. It does what “she said nervously” would do, and the reader gets to notice it for themselves.
- “she whispered”The one stronger tag in the scene. It stays because volume is not something the words can show.
Before and after
The same scene, tagged two ways
The one faultThe tags and adverbs tell the reader how every line was said.
The ferry was already loading when Imogen found him at the rail.
“You weren’t going to say goodbye,” she accused bitterly.
“I left a note,” Callum retorted defensively, keeping his eyes on the cars rolling up the ramp.
“On the fridge. Under the magnet shaped like a lobster,” she scoffed.
“It’s the only magnet we have,” he protested weakly.
“Had,” she corrected coldly. She held out her hand. The magnet sat in her palm, one claw chipped. “You should take it. I never liked it,” she lied.
He took it. He turned it over twice, as if the back might say something different from the front. “The next ferry’s at four,” he offered hopefully.
“I know when the ferries are,” she snapped angrily.
The spoken words are the same in both versions, and so are the actions. In the first, every line arrives with an instruction: accused bitterly, retorted defensively, snapped angrily. The reader is told how to take each line before they have had a chance to take it. Worst here is “she lied”, which hands over the one thing in the scene worth working out.
In the second version most lines carry no tag, because two people are taking turns. “Said” appears twice, at points where the reader could use a reminder of who is speaking. The feeling has not gone anywhere. It sits in the chipped magnet and in what he does with it.
The exception
When to break it
None of this is a law. “Said” is a default, and plenty of good books depart from it. Reach for another verb when it tells the reader something the words do not: whispered and shouted carry volume, and “she lied” can be exactly right when you want the reader to know more than the other character does. An adverb earns its place when it contradicts the line, as in “Lovely,” he said flatly.
Comic writing and books meant to be read aloud to children often use lively tags on purpose, because the performance is part of the pleasure. And with three or more people in a scene you will need more tags, not fewer. Clarity comes before quietness. If a line would leave the reader guessing who spoke, tag it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Tag or beat?
Which of these attributes the line with an action beat and not with a dialogue tag?
Key takeaway
Attribution has one essential job, which is telling the reader who is speaking, and it does that job best when it is hardly noticed. Use “said” when the reader needs a name, a beat when the action adds something, and nothing when the turns are already clear. Let the spoken words carry the feeling.
