Lesson 1 of 10
Dialogue Harbour · stone 1Foundation5 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 8 (People talking)

Dialogue as action

Each speaker wants something and uses words to get it.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

Dialogue Harbour: two piers facing each other, with boats passing between.
Dialogue Harbour · Dialogue, stone 1 of 10

Talk is something people do

People in life talk for all sorts of reasons, including none at all. People in fiction have less room. A line of dialogue earns its place by doing something to the person who hears it.

A line of dialogue earns its place by doing something to the person who hears it.

So the most useful question to ask of any line is not “what does this say?” but “what is the speaker trying to get?” The answer can be small. To be forgiven. To end the conversation. To borrow the car. To be told they were right all along. A character who wants one of these and uses words to go after it is acting, as surely as if they had crossed the room and taken the keys.

This is why a quarrel over a parking space can hold a page and an accurate briefing on the history of the kingdom often cannot. In the first, two wants are in collision and we read on to see who gets their way. In the second, information is being handed over and nobody is at risk of anything.

One want, several tactics

What a speaker wants tends to stay put through a scene. How they go after it changes, and each way of going after it is a tactic. They ask. When asking fails they flatter, or bargain, or change the subject, or lean on guilt, or threaten.

In the lesson’s example the want stays put while the tactic changes, and each switch tells us the last one failed.

The switch from one tactic to the next is what gives a conversation its shape. Each switch tells the reader that the last attempt failed and that the speaker cares enough to try again.

The other person is not a wall. They want something too, even if it is only to be left alone, and their replies are moves of their own. Good dialogue reads like a rally: each line answers the one before and sets a problem for the one after.

Example

Four tactics at a gate

Sorrel is carrying medicine and has missed curfew. Watch what she wants, which does not change, and how she goes after it, which changes three times.

The Salt Gatefantasy

The curfew bell had stopped ringing by the time Sorrel reached the Salt Gate, and the warden was already lowering the bar.

“Is there any chance you could hold that a moment?”1 she said.

“There was a chance. It rang nine times.”2 He dropped the bar into its bracket.

“You’re Garrick’s brother, aren’t you? He said you were the only one on the wall who could be reasoned with.3”

“Garrick says a lot.”

Sorrel shifted the basket to her other hip. “There’s a ham in here I’ll never finish alone.”4

He looked at the basket, then at the lit window of the watch-house behind him. “The captain checks the bar at ten.”5

“Then he’ll find it down. It only has to be up for as long as it takes me to walk through.” She waited. “Or I can sleep on your step, and in the morning the apothecary can ask the captain why her fever bark spent the night outside.”6

The warden breathed out through his nose. Then he lifted the bar.

  1. ““Is there any chance you could hold that a moment?””She opens with the cheapest tactic, a plain request. Her want is clear from this first line: to get through the gate.
  2. ““There was a chance. It rang nine times.””His refusal is a move as well. He wants to keep to the rule and stay out of trouble, and he says so by pointing at the bell.
  3. “He said you were the only one on the wall who could be reasoned with.”Asking failed, so she flatters him. The want is the same. Only the tactic is new.
  4. ““There’s a ham in here I’ll never finish alone.””A third tactic: a bribe, offered without the word being used.
  5. ““The captain checks the bar at ten.””This is not a no. His objection has shrunk from the rule itself to the risk of being caught, which tells Sorrel, and us, that he is giving ground.
  6. ““Or I can sleep on your step, and in the morning the apothecary ca…”The last tactic is a threat, and it is aimed at the one thing he has shown he wants: no trouble with the captain.

Before and after

The same room, with and without a want

The one faultNobody in the scene wants anything from the other person.

Weaker versionThe piano (first version)

The piano stood where it had always stood, against the wall their father had never got round to painting.

“The valuer comes on Friday,” Dominic said. “He does furniture and instruments.”

“That’s useful.” Judith lifted the lid. Two of the high keys had lost their ivory. “It hasn’t been tuned since Mum died.”

“Eleven years. He kept saying he would.”

“He did say that.”

“It might fetch four hundred. The valuer will know.”

“Four hundred sounds about right.” She pressed a key and it gave a flat, furred note. “It’s a heavy thing to move.”

“It took four men to bring it in.”

“I remember. I was seven.”

Dominic wrote piano on his list, under wardrobe and above clock.

Showing the weaker version.

Both versions have the same room, the same piano and nearly the same facts: the valuer, the eleven years, the four hundred, the four men. The first is tidy and readable, and nothing happens in it. Dominic and Judith pass facts back and forth and agree with each other. You could cut any line and the scene would not notice.

In the second, Dominic wants the piano sold and Judith wants to keep it, and every fact becomes something to push with. “Eleven years” turns into an argument for selling. The four men turn into an argument against three flights of stairs, and Judith answers it. Neither of them says “I want the piano”, yet you could name what each is after in a sentence. The scene now ends on a pen that does not write, which is a different place from where it began.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Not every line has to be a blow in a fight. A scene in which each sentence is a thrust or a parry becomes tiring, and it starts to feel staged. People pass the salt. A single easy line can let a tense scene breathe, and a short stretch of agreement can be what the story needs after a hard chapter.

Some scenes put two people on the same side. Friends plan, lovers make up, a parent sits with a frightened child. There the pressure usually comes from outside the conversation, and the talk can be generous.

And people are not chess players. A character may not know what they want, or may want two things that cannot both be had, and their lines will wander accordingly. That wandering is worth keeping. The question to ask of a flat scene is whether anyone in it is after anything, not whether everyone is winning points.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Who is after something?

A shift worker asks a supervisor, “Is that the new timetable?” In which reply is the supervisor using words to get something from the listener?

Key takeaway

Before you write an exchange, know what each speaker wants from the other. Let them go after it, let the first attempt fail, and let them try another way. If you can name each person’s aim and see the approach change at least once, the dialogue is doing something.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Try it on your own pages

Choose a passage from your own book where this matters: dialogue as action. Read it against the checklist, then revise the weakest part.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.