Lesson 1 of 8
The Gardens · stone 1Foundation6 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 7 (Making it vivid)

Show versus tell

Showing gives the reader evidence and lets them reach a feeling or judgement on their own; telling states the conclusion. Both have a job, and the skill is knowing which a moment needs.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Gardens: a walled kitchen garden full of different leaves, fruit and textures, with someone sketching on a bench.
The Gardens · Description and imagery, stone 1 of 8

Evidence and conclusion

Telling gives the reader a conclusion: Hedda was furious. Showing gives the evidence and leaves the conclusion to them: Hedda put the kettle down so hard that the lid jumped off.

Both sentences deliver the same fact; they differ in who does the work.

Both sentences deliver the same fact. They differ in who does the work. When you tell, you do the judging and the reader receives the verdict. When you show, the reader watches something happen and reaches the verdict alone. The verdict is then the reader’s own, and they have had to take part in the scene to reach it.

The advice is often passed on with an image of moonlight glinting on broken glass, usually attributed to Chekhov. The popular wording is a paraphrase of a letter, not a quotation, but the point holds: give a reader the glint and they will supply the moon.

What counts as evidence

Evidence is anything a witness in the room could report: what a person does, what they say, what they fail to do, and what the things around them look like. “He was nervous” is a conclusion. “He checked his ticket, put it away, and took it out again” is evidence.

Evidence is anything a witness in the room could report.

A quick test: look for the words that name a feeling or pass a judgement (angry, kind, beautiful, awkward, tense). Each one is a conclusion. Ask what you saw in your head that made you choose the word, and consider writing that down in its place.

A common fault is not telling on its own. It is doing both. “She slammed the door, furious” shows the anger and then explains it, as if the reader could not be trusted with a slammed door. If the evidence is good, cut the label. If you feel the label is needed, the evidence is probably not strong enough yet.

Example

A scene with no verdicts

A man is leaving a hospital. The passage does not say how he feels or what he has been told.

The exit barrierliterary

Gideon fed the ticket into the machine at the hospital exit. It came back out. He turned it over and tried again, then a third time with the stripe facing up, which was how he had put it in to begin with1.

The car behind him sounded its horn, once, politely2.

He found coins in the door pocket and counted them into the slot. One fell. He got out, knelt on the wet concrete and felt under the car until his fingers closed on it. When he stood up he had the coin in one hand and, in the other, the appointment card with Thursday’s date on it3. He could not remember picking that up.

The barrier lifted. He sat with the engine running and both hands on the wheel4 until the horn sounded again, less politely.

  1. “then a third time with the stripe facing up, which was how he had…”Three tries at a simple task, and the third is the same as the first. We conclude that his mind is somewhere else, and nobody has used the word “distracted”.
  2. “once, politely”The rest of the world is carrying on as normal. The contrast with him is evidence too.
  3. “the appointment card with Thursday’s date on it”The one hint of a cause. A hospital, a card and a date: the reader joins them up and starts to guess what Thursday is for.
  4. “He sat with the engine running and both hands on the wheel”What a person fails to do is evidence. The way out is open and he does not take it.

Telling has a job too

Showing costs words. A shown moment takes a paragraph where a told one takes a line, so a story that shows everything crawls. Telling is the right tool for ground that does not need a scene: time passing, a journey, a routine, a fact the reader simply needs. “They drove north for three days” is telling, and it is exactly right if nothing on the road matters.

Showing costs words, so tell the ground between and show the moments that matter.

So the working question is whether this moment deserves the reader’s close attention. If it does (a turning point, a strong feeling, a first meeting), show it. If it does not, tell it and move on.

Before and after

The same moment, told and shown

The one faultThe narrator states each feeling and judgement, and gives the reader nothing to see.

Weaker versionThe first blade (first version)

Tamsin carried her first finished blade across the forge yard to where Master Oswin sat. She was very nervous, and she badly wanted to impress him.

Oswin took the knife. He examined it with great care and was not satisfied with the edge.

“The edge wanders,” he said.

Tamsin was crushed. She had worked on the knife for a long time, and she was especially proud of the handle.

Then Oswin did something kind, which showed that he thought she had promise. “Tomorrow,” he said, “you start on the next.”

She was relieved and happy.

Showing the weaker version.

The events and the spoken lines are the same in both versions. In the first, every beat arrives as a verdict: very nervous, not satisfied, crushed, something kind, relieved and happy. We are told how to feel about a scene we have not been allowed to watch. “Did something kind” is the clearest case, because the kindness itself has been left out.

The second version swaps each verdict for what a person in the yard would have seen. The twice-washed hands are the nerves. The thumbnail that stops halfway is the judgement. The whetstone nobody else may touch is the kindness and the promise together. Her feelings at the end are not named at all, and they are not in doubt.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Telling is the better choice more often than the slogan admits. Use it to cross time and distance, to pass on a fact the story needs but nobody would dramatise, and to deal with minor characters and repeated events in a line.

A strong narrating voice can also tell with pleasure. Fairy tales, fables, comic novels and much first-person fiction lean on a narrator who sums people up in a sentence. The judgement is part of the entertainment, because we are learning about the narrator as well as the person judged.

And sometimes plainness hits hardest. After a page of evidence, one short told sentence (“She did not go back”) can land with more force than another image would. What rarely works is telling the one moment the scene exists for.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Evidence or verdict?

Which of these sentences shows, giving the reader evidence and no conclusion?

Key takeaway

Telling hands the reader a conclusion. Showing hands them the evidence and trusts them to reach it. Show the moments that matter, tell the stretches that only need crossing, and when the evidence is doing its job, leave the label off.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Try it on your own pages

Choose a passage from your own book where this matters: show versus tell. Read it against the checklist, then revise the weakest part.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.