Down the ladder
Compare two sentences. “A bird sat on a fence near some buildings.” “A magpie sat on the chain-link above the scrapyard.” The first could be set anywhere, so the reader sees almost nothing. The second can only be one place.
Down the ladder
- Animal
- Dog
- Terrier
- A wire-haired terrierWith one ear that would not stand up
Most nouns sit on a ladder. At the top are the general words: animal, vehicle, food, building. Lower down the words narrow: dog, then terrier, then a wire-haired terrier with one ear that would not stand up. Each step down gives the reader more to see and costs you very little, often no extra words at all. “Tree” and “birch” are one word each.
A general word asks the reader to do the imagining for you. They fill in a default bird and a default fence, and the default is the same grey picture in every book. A particular word hands them something they have not pictured before. It also carries a quiet second message: the author has been here and looked.
Three places to look
Three kinds of vagueness are easy to find in a draft.
Three places to look
General nouns: flowers, tools, a drink, some papers. Ask which one. Dahlias, a claw hammer, cold tea, the gas bill.
Soft numbers: several, a few, a while, a lot of money. Ask how many. “Eleven minutes” is funnier, sadder and easier to believe than “a while”.
Verdict adjectives: nice, old, beautiful, strange, expensive. These report your opinion of the thing and leave the thing out. Ask what made it so. An “old” coat might have a lining mended in three colours of thread.
Concrete also means physical. Poverty, chaos and luxury cannot be seen. A saucepan catching drips in the hall can. When a sentence is built on an abstraction, look for the object that would prove it.
Example
A shelf and a violin case
A police sergeant is looking for one item among many. Notice where the exact detail falls, and where it does not.
The lost-property shelf at Calder Street station held eleven umbrellas, a child’s left shoe, and a cake tin that nobody had dared to open since March1. Sergeant Amara Voss went straight past all of it2 to the violin case.
It was the cheap kind, pressed cardboard under black cloth3, with a luggage tag from a coach company that had closed two winters ago. One of the brass catches had been replaced with the bent handle of a teaspoon4. She did not need to open the case to know it was Peverell’s. He had mended his glasses the same way.
- “eleven umbrellas, a child’s left shoe, and a cake tin that nobody…”A count, a particular shoe and a tin with a history. Three quick items make the shelf real, and none of them is “various objects”.
- “went straight past all of it”The background is given in one sentence and then left behind. Exactness is not the same as lingering.
- “pressed cardboard under black cloth”“Cheap” alone would be a verdict. The materials are the proof of it.
- “the bent handle of a teaspoon”The detail that belongs to this case and no other. It is also the one the plot turns on, which is why it gets the most room.
Choose, do not pile
Being specific is not the same as being thorough. Name every object in a room to the same degree and the reader gets a catalogue, with no way of knowing what matters. Spend exactness where you want attention and let the rest stay quick: “the usual office furniture, and on the desk a jar of sea glass.”
Choose, do not pile
Before and after
One night shift, twice
The one faultEvery noun and quantity is general, so nothing can be pictured.
Halfway through the night shift something went wrong with one of the systems. Mirren put down her food and went to look. Some of the plants in the growing area had changed colour, and there was liquid on the floor near some equipment. She checked a few readings. They were bad, and had been for some time. She picked up a tool and went to wake someone.
Both versions have the same six sentences in the same order, and the same things happen. The first is built from the top of the ladder: something, one of the systems, food, some of the plants, liquid, some equipment, a few readings, a tool, someone. It is clear enough to follow and impossible to see. It could be a greenhouse, a submarine or a brewery.
The second moves each of those words down. Now there is an alarm with a sound, a meal, a crop, a colour, a leak with a source, a number and a name. It is only a few words longer. Notice too that the exact version is more worrying: “zero, and had for six hours” frightens in a way that “bad for some time” cannot.
The exception
When to break it
General words are sometimes exactly right. When a narrator would not know or care about the particular, the general word is the honest one. A child sees “a bird”, a birdwatcher sees a wheatear, and a woman running for her life sees neither. The level of detail should match who is looking and how much attention they have to spare.
When the general word is honest
Summary runs on general words as well. “They ate, slept and set out at dawn” needs no menu. And vagueness can be an effect in itself, as in a fable (“a king had three sons”) or in a horror scene, where “something” moving in the cellar is worse than any named thing.
Exactness can also mislead. A detail given precisely looks important, so a reader may wait for the wire-haired terrier to matter. If it will not, one step down the ladder is enough.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which flowers, which container?
A draft says: “She put some flowers in a container.” Which revision makes the sentence specific without padding it?
Key takeaway
Move the words that matter down the ladder: the exact object for the general noun, the count for “several”, the proof for the verdict. Do it where you want the reader’s eye, and let everything else stay quick.
