Given, chosen, done
The Character lesson on introducing someone dealt with a first entrance. This lesson is about describing a person anywhere in a book, and about which kind of detail to reach for. What can be said about someone’s appearance falls into three kinds.
Three kinds of detail
Given. Height, build, the colour of eyes and hair, the shape of a face. Nobody chose these, so they say little about the person. They help a reader to picture, and a few go a long way.
Chosen. Clothes, grooming, what is carried and how it is kept: a pressed cuff, a watch worn on the inside of the wrist, a bag held shut with a hair tie. Each of these is a decision, and decisions characterise.
Done. How a body is used: the walk, the hands, how much room someone takes at a table, where they look when they speak. This is description that moves. It can be threaded through a scene without stopping it.
A description built wholly on the first kind reads like a form. The person appears in the second and third.
Who is looking?
A description also tells the reader about the describer. In a story told through a character, we see people as that character sees them. A tailor reads a stranger’s seams. A nurse reads colour and breathing. A small child sees knees and hands.
Who is looking?
Decide who is looking and what they would notice first, and the description sorts itself. It follows that one person can be described twice in a book, by two observers, and look different each time.
The one whose eyes we are using
The hardest person to describe is the viewpoint character. People do not think about their own chestnut hair. The usual escape is the mirror: she catches her reflection and takes stock of her features for the reader’s benefit. The device has been used so often that it tends to be noticed before the face is.
The viewpoint character
There are quieter ways. Friction: the body meets the world and we learn its shape. She ducks under the beam; his sleeves stop short of his wrists. Other people: someone reacts, compares, mistakes her for her sister. Purpose: she does look at herself, but for a reason that belongs to today, such as whether the bruise is covered.
Ask, too, how much the reader needs. A feature that will matter later (height, in a book with a fight in it) should arrive early, before the reader has pictured something else. Much of the rest can be left to them.
Example
A stranger, read by a thief
A pickpocket is working a railway station. Notice what she looks at, and what the passage leaves out.
Bette gave every arrival off the boat train two seconds.1
The man in the grey overcoat got four. The coat was good wool and a size too large, bought for him or bought when he was heavier2. He carried a doctor’s bag in his left hand and kept the right in his pocket, and every few steps the elbow drew in3. His shoes had been resoled, and polished by someone who cared more about the polish than he did4. He walked like a man counting platforms.
At the barrier he stopped, set the bag between his feet and got his ticket out with the left hand, awkwardly. The right stayed where it was.
Not money, then, Bette thought. Nobody guards a wallet that hard.5 She let him go by, and went on wondering what it was.
- “Bette gave every arrival off the boat train two seconds.”The observer comes first. Everything that follows is what someone in her trade would look at.
- “a size too large, bought for him or bought when he was heavier”A chosen thing, read for its history. The passage gives no colour of hair or eyes at all.
- “every few steps the elbow drew in”Something done. The description is moving, and she is reading it for a purpose.
- “polished by someone who cared more about the polish than he did”One clause, and there is another person in his life.
- “Nobody guards a wallet that hard.”The description ends as a judgement in her voice. We have learned what he looks like and how she thinks.
Before and after
Out of the mirror
The one faultThe viewpoint character stops in front of a mirror to list her own features.
Fernanda had twenty minutes before the interview. She stood in front of the hall mirror and looked at herself. She was thirty-four and tall, with broad shoulders from her years of rowing. Her dark brown hair fell in waves to her collar, and her eyes were hazel with flecks of green. A small scar ran through her left eyebrow. She was wearing her one good suit, a navy one, which was a little tight across the back.
She picked up her keys and went out.
The first version halts the story so that Fernanda can be inventoried: age, height, shoulders, hair, eyes, scar, suit. She is alone, in a hurry, and has no reason to notice any of it. Hair and eyes are the given kind, and nothing comes of them.
The second version has no mirror and keeps what matters. The suit and the shoulders arrive together as friction: a stitch goes when she reaches up. Her height is in a child’s neck, tipping back twice. The scar comes through another person, with a small history attached, and the child’s answer gives her something to carry into the interview. Her age and the colour of her hair and eyes have gone, and the passage admits it: nothing in this scene needed them. If a later scene does, they can arrive there.
The exception
When to break it
A mirror is not forbidden. It earns its place when the looking is the event: a character seeing herself in a wedding dress, after an illness, in a uniform for the first time. Then what she sees, and how she takes it, is the scene. The device fails when the mirror is only a way of handing over a list.
When the list belongs
Some stories want the given features, and want them early. A romance may linger on eyes, hands and mouth because attraction is its subject. A wanted notice is an inventory by nature and can be used as one. A portrait painter or a casting agent would itemise a face, and the list then tells us about them.
There is a fairness check worth running. If only some characters have their skin colour, size or age remarked on, the narration is treating everyone else as the default. List who gets such a mention and who does not, and see whether the pattern is one you intend.
You may also describe very little. Plenty of novels do not say what the lead looks like, and leave the face to the reader.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Tall, without saying so
Which of these lets the reader know that the narrator is tall, without her stopping the story to tell us?
Key takeaway
Reach past what a person was given to what they chose and what they do. Let the observer decide which details are noticed. For the viewpoint character, leave the mirror alone and let the world show their shape: a doorway, a sleeve, somebody’s glance. Give early any feature that will matter later, and trust the reader with the rest.
