The same lake twice
A man walks round a lake on the morning his divorce comes through, and again a year later on the morning of his wedding. It is the same lake, and it will not be the same paragraph. The first time he sees the jetty with a plank out and the one swan that has the whole water to itself. The second time he sees the light in the reeds and two children failing to skim stones.
The same lake twice
Mood in description comes from this fact: a feeling selects. Someone in the grip of something notices what answers to it and walks past the rest.
T. S. Eliot gave the method a name that has stuck. In an essay on Hamlet, collected in The Sacred Wood, he argued that art conveys an emotion by finding its “objective correlative”. In plain terms, the writer finds things outside the character, such as objects, a situation or a run of events, that add up to the feeling, so that a reader who is given the things arrives at the feeling without being told. The lesson on show versus tell did this with people’s behaviour. Here the evidence is the world a character looks at.
Three controls and two restraints
Selection. Of the forty things in view, which five would this feeling pick out? Dread goes to exits and to whatever is out of place. Homesickness goes to things that are nearly like home. Relief notices what worry had stopped seeing.
- SelectionWhich five of the forty things in view?
- VerbsWashing can hang, drip, snap or wave
- ComparisonFear and joy find different likenesses for one streetlamp
- Leave the feeling unnamed
- Leave some details neutralA plain chair among the charged ones
Verbs. Objects in a description are always doing something, even if they only stand. The verb you give them carries mood more quietly than an adjective does. Washing on a line can hang, drip, snap or wave, and those are four different afternoons.
Comparison. A figure comes from the mind that makes it, so a frightened observer and a happy one will find different likenesses for the same streetlamp.
Then the restraints. Leave the feeling unnamed. If the things are right the name is not needed, and if they are wrong it will not rescue them. And leave some details neutral. When every object in a room is cracked, withered or in shadow, the reader stops feeling the mood and starts to see the author arranging it. A plain chair among the charged details makes the others believable.
Context does part of the work. The reader usually knows what has just happened, and that lets the description be lighter than you might expect.
Example
Eleven years of one lane
A woman has just signed the last paper clearing a debt she has carried for eleven years. She walks home the way she always does. No word in the passage says how she feels.
Patience came out of the solicitor’s office with the envelope inside her coat and took the back lane home, as she had every working day for eleven years1.
Somebody had painted the gate of number nine. It was a hard, cheerful yellow, and it had run a little at the hinges. Had it been yellow yesterday?2 A cat she knew by sight was asleep on the coal bunker with all four feet in the air3. The lane had a smell after rain that she had forgotten it had4, of wet brick and the bakery’s back door.
At the corner the puddle was there, the one that never drained. She had walked round it for eleven years. She looked both ways, and then she went through the middle of it, in her good shoes, not fast5.
- “as she had every working day for eleven years”Context. The lane could not be more familiar, so anything she notices today is noticed because of the state she is in.
- “Had it been yellow yesterday?”Selection. Relief sees what worry had stopped seeing. The gate is probably not new. Her attention is.
- “asleep on the coal bunker with all four feet in the air”An object for the feeling: a creature with nothing to guard against. No comment is made on it.
- “that she had forgotten it had”Her senses are coming back. Nothing in the lane has changed.
- “she went through the middle of it, in her good shoes, not fast”A small event completes it. Relieved, happy and free are all absent from the passage, and none of them is missed.
Before and after
A dormitory, told and carried
The one faultThe feeling is named, three times, and the things described do nothing to carry it.
It was Caio’s first night in the apprentices’ dormitory, and he was terribly homesick. The room was long, with twelve iron beds in two rows and a window at each end. There was a stove in the middle and a row of pegs along one wall. The blankets were grey. The other boys were already asleep. He felt lonely and sad, and he missed his family very much.
The first version states the feeling at the start and twice more at the end: homesick, lonely and sad, missed his family. Between those statements the room is listed neutrally. Beds, windows, stove, pegs and blankets would look the same to a boy who was delighted to be there.
The second version names no feeling. It keeps the room and changes what is noticed in it. The other boys’ breathing is measured against a brother’s. The blanket has been folded by a stranger’s rule, and he cannot bring himself to disturb it. The stove makes the wrong sound. Each detail is the room as a homesick boy would meet it, and the last sentence carries a whole kitchen he is not in.
One detail has been left alone: the long room, the twelve beds, the two windows. That plain sentence is what lets the reader trust the others.
The exception
When to break it
Naming the feeling is sometimes the stronger choice. After a paragraph of charged detail, one plain sentence (“She was afraid”) can land harder than another image. Some fiction does both at once. The Poe passage in the exercises is an example: he gives you the bleak walls and tells you about the gloom as well.
When the scene disagrees
The scene does not have to agree with the character. A funeral on the first warm day of spring, with someone mowing a lawn two streets away, can hurt more than rain would. Weather that obligingly matches every mood is an old habit of fiction and an easy one to notice. Counterpoint still works by selection, because grief is what hears the lawnmower.
Not every description needs a mood. Some of it is there to tell the reader where the door is.
The method also has a limit. Objects can carry dread, ease, grief or longing fairly reliably. They are less good at fine distinctions, such as envy as against resentment. Where the exact feeling matters and the context has not fixed it, a line of thought or speech may have to do the job.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
The car park
Bodhi has just been dismissed after twenty years at the depot. He walks out to the staff car park. Which sentence carries what he feels without naming it?
Key takeaway
A feeling selects what a character notices. Choose the few things this feeling would pick out, give them verbs that lean the right way, and leave the feeling unnamed. Keep a detail or two neutral so that the rest stays believable, and let what the reader already knows do part of the work.
