Plenty happens. She does nothing.
Here is the outline of a chapter. A letter arrives telling Mina that her aunt has died. A lawyer explains the will. A cousin threatens her. A stranger steps in and sees the cousin off. A storm strands her at the house overnight. Plenty happens. Mina does nothing.
Plenty happens
This is a common way for a lead to go missing from their own story. Things happen to them, other people explain and decide, and the lead’s part is to have feelings about it. Such a lead is reactive. A proactive lead wants something and does something about it: makes a plan, asks the awkward question, opens the door they were told to leave shut. The word for this is agency. It means that the character’s choices cause at least some of what happens next.
A quick test for any scene: what did the lead do that changed the outcome? If the answer is “nothing; she was told, she was taken, she was saved”, the scene belongs to someone else.
Why it matters, and what it is not
A character who tries gives the reader something to follow. Trying creates expectation (will it work?) and it shows the person (why this plan and not another?). A lead who waits offers neither. And when the lead’s own choice makes matters worse, the trouble feels earned in a way that bad luck does not.
In practice
- A goal in the scene
- One step not forced on themCould your lead have gone and got the clue?
- Consequences, good or bad
Agency is not the same as winning. A prisoner who cannot leave the cell but decides what to say to the guard has agency. Plans can fail, and failed plans drive a great many plots. Nor does agency mean that the lead never reacts. Stories often begin with a blow from outside, and a period of reeling afterwards is natural. What counts is what the character does next, and how soon.
In practice: give the lead a goal in the scene, let them take at least one step that was not forced on them, and let that step have consequences, good or bad. Where a rescue, a clue or a decision arrives from outside, ask whether your lead could have gone and got it.
Example
In a scene
A passenger is confined to her cabin by an order she did not cause and cannot disobey. Watch what she does with the little room she has.
The quarantine order came over the ship’s speakers at 0400: all passengers to remain in their cabins1 until the port authority cleared the manifest. No time was given.
Ada Lindqvist listened to it twice. Then she got out the passenger handbook, which nobody read, and read section nine2.
At 0420 she pressed the call button. “Cabin 114. Under nine-point-three I’m entitled to a medical visit within the hour if I report a symptom. I’m reporting a headache.3”
A pause. “A medic will attend.”
“Thank you. Will it be Dr Feng?4 I’d like to ask her how many cabins on this deck have reported fever, and she strikes me as someone who’ll answer.”
She put the handbook under her pillow, tidied the cabin so that it looked like the cabin of a person with nothing to hide, and sat down facing the door5.
- “all passengers to remain in their cabins”The blow from outside. She did not cause it and cannot leave. Reacting to it is natural; the question is what comes next.
- “read section nine”Her first unforced step. It is small, and it is typical of her: she goes looking for a lever.
- “I’m reporting a headache.”The plan in action. She cannot go to the information, so she arranges for it to come to her.
- ““Thank you. Will it be Dr Feng?”She has a goal for the scene, which is to learn how many are ill, and she chooses her source.
- “sat down facing the door”She is still confined and has won nothing yet. But the next thing that happens, the medic’s visit, will happen because of her.
Before and after
Handed over, or found
The one faultEvery piece of information is handed to the lead; she does nothing to get it.
The parish register was open on the vestry table when Constable Edith Rowe arrived, and the page for March 1911 had been cut out with a blade.
“Dreadful business,” said the verger. He told her that the vicar kept the only key, that the vicar had been away since Tuesday, and that a Mr Stroud from the land agent’s had been asking after the register last week.
“I see,” said Rowe.
The verger said she had better speak to Mr Stroud, and wrote down the address for her. While he was writing, the vicar’s sister came in and mentioned that she had seen a light in the vestry on Wednesday night.
Rowe thanked them both and went to find Mr Stroud.
Both versions deliver the same four facts: the vicar holds the only key, he has been away since Tuesday, a Mr Stroud asked about the register, and someone had a light in the vestry at night.
In the first version the verger volunteers three of them, the vicar’s sister walks in with the fourth, and the verger even tells Rowe where to go next. Her whole part is “I see” and a thank-you. Any constable would have done, or none.
In the second version Rowe examines the book and finds the grooves. She asks who holds the key. She asks who else wanted the register, and the verger hesitates, which tells her something too. She reads the lamp and works out the night visit before anyone mentions it. The four facts are the same, and she has a fifth that nobody could have handed her: the names pressed into the page behind the gap. Each one was got by her, and we have learned how she thinks.
The exception
When to break it
A reactive stretch is not a fault in itself. After a real blow, such as a death or a defeat, a character who sprang straight into planning would seem made of wood. The pause is honest, and in some books the slow recovery of the will to act is the story. Horror and some thrillers begin with leads who can only run, and grow tense precisely because the choices are so few. Even there, the choices that remain (which door, whom to wake) are worth showing.
When choices are few
Some fiction is about powerlessness: a child in an adult’s war, a servant in a great house, a prisoner. The lead’s agency may shrink to what they notice, what they refuse and what they keep hidden. That is still agency, and showing it matters all the more.
A passive narrator can also serve when the real subject of the book is someone else, a friend or a magnetic stranger being watched. Then the watcher’s judgement is the action. And comedy sometimes runs on a lead who is swept along, where the sweeping is the joke.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Who finds the thief?
Someone has been stealing from the village co-op, and Tomas wants to know who. In which version does Tomas have agency?
Key takeaway
In each scene, ask what the lead did that changed what happened next. Give them a goal, at least one step nobody forced on them, and consequences for taking it. They need not win. They do need to try.
