A belief on the move
The lesson on the backstory wound gave a character a Lie: a false rule they live by. An arc is what happens to that belief between the first page and the last.
Three arcs, after K. M. Weiland
The novelist and teacher K. M. Weiland sorts arcs into three kinds.
Positive change. The character starts out believing the Lie and ends by acting on a truth. The story is what it took to shift them.
Flat. The character holds a truth on page one and does not give it up. The story tests it, and the change happens around them: in other people, a town, an institution.
Negative change. The character ends worse off than they began. They may cling to the Lie until it ruins them, give up a truth for a lie, or learn something true that leaves them bleaker.
None is better than the others. They are different promises about where the book is going.
Five points, and a cause for each
A working way to see an arc is to write down what the character believes at five points: the opening, the end of the first quarter, the middle, the lowest point and the last page. One sentence each, in the character’s own words.
Chart the belief at five points
- OpeningOne sentence, in their own words
- First quarterBeside it, the event that moved it
- MiddleSomething the old belief cannot explain
- Lowest pointKeeping it costs more than they can pay
- Last page
Then, beside every sentence after the first, write the event that moved the belief there. A belief does not shift because time has passed, or because the character has thought it over. It shifts when something happens that the old belief cannot explain, or when keeping it costs more than the character can pay.
Three faults are worth looking for in a finished draft. The Lie holds unchanged for most of the book and is dropped in one late realisation. A step is taken in summary (“over that winter she learned to trust them”), so the reader hears about the change and does not see it. Or the steps only go one way. A belief under pressure tends to give a little, harden again, and then break, and the step backwards is often what makes the last step believable.
A flat arc can be charted the same way, with one difference. The sentence stays the same at every point, and what you record beside it is the test: what holding on cost this time.
Example
A chart, not a scene
What follows is a planning note, not a scene. It charts the lead of a fantasy novel at five points. Read the belief in quotation marks first each time, then the cause.
Rhona, keeper of the Sund beacon. Lie: nobody else can be trusted with the light.1
Opening. “If I sleep, a ship dies.” She has kept the lamp alone for six winters. She turns away the apprentice the harbour sends.
First quarter. “I can use his hands. I can’t use his judgement.” Cause: she falls on the ice stair and breaks her wrist2. He trims the wicks, and she stands over him while he does it.
Middle. “He might do, for one night.” Cause: a fever puts her on the floor of the lamp room. She wakes at dawn to find the light burning and the log written up in his hand3.
Low point. “I was right the first time.”4 Cause: he misreads a signal flag and a grain barge grounds on the bar. Nobody drowns. She sends him back down to the harbour.
Last page. “The light is the thing that mustn’t fail. It was never me.” Cause: a storm lasts three nights. On the second she wakes with her cheek on the rail and the flame guttering. She goes down to the harbour herself to ask him back.5
- “Lie: nobody else can be trusted with the light.”The belief, written as one plain sentence. Everything below it is this sentence under pressure.
- “she falls on the ice stair and breaks her wrist”The first cause comes from outside and leaves her no choice. The belief gives only as far as it is forced to: his hands, not his judgement.
- “the light burning and the log written up in his hand”Evidence the old belief cannot explain. She did nothing all night, and no ship was lost.
- ““I was right the first time.””The step backwards. One mistake, and the belief hardens again. Without this step the ending would come too easily.
- “She goes down to the harbour herself to ask him back.”The last belief is given as an action, and it costs her the one thing the woman of the opening would not have paid: asking.
Before and after
The same step, taken two ways
The one faultThe character’s belief changes because she thinks about it. Nothing happens to change it.
The bakery’s first wholesale order was due at the hotel by seven, and at ten past five the second oven tripped the fuse again.
Deirdre stood in the dark with forty trays of unbaked rolls. Through the wall she could hear Enzo opening up the fishmonger’s next door: the shutter, the hose, the radio.
She thought about how long she had been doing everything herself. Since the divorce she had believed that the moment anyone saw her struggling, they would be gone. Standing there, she began to see that this was not true. Enzo had always been friendly. It was time, she decided, to let someone in.
She reset the fuse and got the first oven going. At twenty to seven the rolls were out, and she went next door.
“Could I borrow your van?” she said.
Both versions end with the same question, and asking it is a step in Deirdre’s arc: at the start of her story she would not have asked.
In the first version the step is taken inside her head. Nothing has happened that was not true yesterday, so the reader has no reason to think the belief would give way this morning.
The second version puts an event where that paragraph was. She is seen struggling, at the worst moment, by the man next door. Her belief says he will now go. He catches the tray and stays until the rolls are out. No thought is reported. When she asks for the van, the reader knows what moved her, because they watched it.
The exception
When to break it
Not every lead has to change. A series detective or an adventure hero is often steady by design. That is only a flat arc if the truth they hold is tested. If it is not, there is no arc, and the book may be none the worse.
When the chart bends
The five points are a way of checking a draft, not a template. A short story may show one step, or only the moment before one. A tragedy can turn on a recognition that arrives too late to use, and the lateness is the point. A late realisation is sound, too, when the evidence has been piling up in plain view and only the character has refused to count it.
Slow change can be slow on the page, provided the reader is shown the small events that add up. And an arc can be left open: a character who ends half changed may be truer than one who is cured.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which arc is this?
A young magistrate takes office sure that a judge owes every person the same hearing. Over the book she watches three guilty men walk free on papers she signed. On the last page she accepts a landowner’s gift and tells her clerk that fairness is for people who can afford it. Which kind of arc is this?
Key takeaway
An arc is a belief on the move: towards a truth, held firm against pressure, or away into something worse. Write the belief down at five points, and beside each one the event that put it there. Where you cannot name the event, the reader is unlikely to believe the change.
