One sentence, or more than one
Some characters can be summed up in a sentence, and each time they appear they prove the sentence again: the porter who complains, the aunt who feeds everyone. E. M. Forster, in Aspects of the Novel, called these flat characters. They are built round a single idea.
Forster’s test
A round character, in Forster’s terms, is one who can surprise the reader in a way that convinces. That is his test. A character who never surprises is flat. One who surprises without convincing has not become round by it: in his view that is still a flat character, only disguised.
Forster did not treat flatness as a fault, and it is worth following him in that. A flat character is recognised the moment they come back, needs no reintroduction and is easy to remember. A cast made up wholly of round characters would ask a great deal of a reader. A novel can usually do with a few people who can surprise and a larger number who reliably cannot.
How a surprise convinces
A convincing surprise is one the reader could have seen coming and did not. That takes a plant: an earlier moment, usually small, that does not fit the character’s one idea. A miser overpays a street musician. Nobody remarks on it. Sixty pages later he clears a stranger’s debt, and the reader thinks: the musician.
How a surprise convinces
- The plantA miser overpays a street musician, and nobody remarks on it
- Sixty pages laterHe clears a stranger’s debt
- The reader thinks: the musicianCould have seen it coming, and did not
A plant works best when it is brief, shown as an action and left unexplained. Explain it and you have only handed the character a second label. It also helps if the surprising act is carried out in the character’s usual manner, so that they are still recognisably themselves while doing it.
Two faults are worth checking a finished draft for. One is the convenient surprise: a character acts against everything we know because the plot needs a door opened, and no earlier moment prepared it. The other is the lead who never surprises. A protagonist who meets every situation exactly as page one predicted is flat, however much history they have been given. History is information. Roundness is being able to do the unexpected thing and be believed.
Example
A man called the Ounce
A market official with a reputation. Watch for the one moment in the first half that does not fit it.
Clerk Stokes weighed every sack that came through the Corn Exchange, and in nineteen years nobody had seen him round a figure in a seller’s favour1. The farmers called him the Ounce.
On the first market day of the dry year he docked the widow Eklund four pounds for damp2. She did not argue. While she was tying the sack again he took the apple from his own dinner, set it on the tailboard of her cart beside the smallest of her boys3, and went on to the next scale without looking at either of them4.
The harvest failed in August. In October the Exchange posted the names of those in arrears, and the bailiffs went out with the list.
They came back from the Eklund farm with nothing to collect. Her arrears had been paid off in four instalments. The receipts were in the clerk’s own small hand, and each was for the full amount, to the farthing5.
- “nobody had seen him round a figure in a seller’s favour”The single idea. One sentence sums him up, and the nickname seals it.
- “he docked the widow Eklund four pounds for damp”He does exactly what the sentence predicts. So far he is flat.
- “set it on the tailboard of her cart beside the smallest of her boys”The plant. It is small, it is an action, and it does not fit the Ounce.
- “without looking at either of them”No comment from him and none from the narrator. The reader may notice or not.
- “each was for the full amount, to the farthing”The surprise, and the reason it convinces. He has paid her debt, which nobody expected, and he has done it the way he does everything. The apple said he might. The farthing says it is still him.
Before and after
The same act, with and without groundwork
The one faultThe surprise has no groundwork: nothing earlier suggests she could do this.
Officer Rasmussen had worked the night desk at the ferry terminal for eleven years and had not once waved a vehicle through unsearched. Drivers who knew the crossing took the day boat.
At ten past two a refrigerated van pulled in. She read the whole manifest and asked the driver to open the back.
Frozen fish, stacked to the roof. Behind the third pallet a boot heel moved.
Rasmussen kept her torch on it for a moment. Then she stepped down, signed the sheet and handed it back.
“Bay four,” she said. “And turn the unit down. It’s a long crossing.”
In both versions an officer who searches every vehicle finds someone hidden in a van and lets it board. Her last line is the same, and so is everything she does at the van.
In the first version that act comes from nowhere. We have been given one fact about Rasmussen, and she breaks it. A reader may accept it, but only by deciding that the author needed the van on the ferry.
The second version adds one short paragraph and changes nothing else. Every Thursday a deckhand brings two cartons too many, and every Thursday she writes down one. She is still exact: she writes the slip. But there is a place where her exactness gives, and it gives for someone with little. When the boot heel moves, the reader has already seen the part of her that answers it.
The exception
When to break it
Flat is often the right choice. A great deal of comedy runs on characters who cannot change, and the pleasure is in watching the one idea meet a new situation. Fables and a good deal of adventure fiction use figures who stand for a single quality, and rounding them would blur the design. A walk-on who is on the page for six lines seldom wants a contradiction, since that reads as a promise that they will matter.
When flat is right
The groundwork does not have to be noticed in advance. In a mystery it may be laid so quietly that the reader finds it only on looking back. In a first-person story the narrator may simply have misjudged someone, and then the surprise tells us about the narrator. What the reader should not find, on looking back, is nothing.
Round does not mean likeable, or important, or described at length. A minor character can be round in two strokes. And a lead can stay flat on purpose, as steady series heroes often do, if the people around them supply the surprises.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which surprise convinces?
For most of a novel a ship’s cook is shown as a bully who keeps the best rations for himself. Once, early on, he is seen slipping his own bread to the ship’s dog when he thinks nobody is watching. In the last chapter the water runs short. Which action would surprise the reader and still convince?
Key takeaway
A flat character proves one sentence each time they appear, and that is useful. A round one can do something the sentence did not predict and still be believed. To earn that, show a second quality early, in passing, and leave it unexplained. Then put your lead to the same test.
