Wound, belief, behaviour
Every morning, Hanne checks the stove three times before she leaves home. You could give her a paragraph about the fire when she was nine. Or you could let her check the stove, be late again, and lie about why.
The chain runs one way
- The woundA parent who left; a promise broken in public
- The belief, or Lie“People leave, so do not need them”
- The behaviourHanne checks the stove three times, and is late again
Most people carry something from before the story began: a parent who left, a promise broken in public, one winter with nothing to eat. In talk about craft this is often called the backstory wound. Some books call it the character’s ghost, because it keeps turning up in the present.
The wound matters less than what the character concluded from it. A child whose father walked out might decide: people leave, so do not need them. That conclusion is sometimes called the Lie the character believes. It is a false or half-true rule about the self or the world, and it was sensible once. It kept the child safe. The trouble is that the adult still obeys it.
The chain runs one way: a wound, then a belief, then behaviour. Most of the time, only the last link needs to be on the page.
Put the belief to work
A Lie earns its place by driving choices in the present. If your character believes “I am only worth what I earn”, we should see it when she is offered a day off, when a friend pays for lunch, when she falls ill. Each scene gives the belief something to do. After three or four such moments a reader can state the Lie without having been told it.
“I am only worth what I earn”
The wound itself needs far less room than a first draft tends to give it. A flinch, an object kept, a subject changed: these make the reader curious. A long early flashback answers a question before anyone has asked it. Often the past is best told late and briefly, at the point where the character can no longer avoid it.
A useful test is to write the Lie as one plain sentence in the character’s own words. “I’m fine on my own.” “If I’m perfect, nobody can send me away.” If you cannot do it, you may have a sad event but not yet a belief.
Example
In a scene
A man offers the woman he is seeing a key to his door. Nothing about her past is explained. Look for the belief, and for the three words that hold the wound.
Theo held out the key on his open palm. It was new-cut and still had the hardware shop’s paper tag on it.
“So you don’t have to wait on the step when I’m late.”
“I don’t mind the step.”1 Nell took her coat from the back of his chair. “It’s a nice step.”
“Nell.”
“I’ve a key to my own place. I know where everything is there.” She was buttoning the coat, and had started one button out2. “You’d want it back, later3, and then there’s the whole business of giving it back. I’ve done that.4 I’d rather not have it to give.”
He put the key on the table between them.
She looked at it while she redid the buttons. On the way out she straightened his doormat with her foot, the way she did every time5, so that it sat square to the door.
- ““I don’t mind the step.””The belief acts before it explains itself. She turns the key down lightly, as if it were a matter of taste.
- “had started one button out”Her hands give away what her voice is hiding.
- ““You’d want it back, later”The Lie, put the way she would put it: as a plain fact about the future. Whatever is given gets taken back.
- “I’ve done that.”The wound, in three words. There is no flashback. A key was once handed back, and for now that is all we need.
- “she straightened his doormat with her foot, the way she did every time”She looks after a place she will not let herself belong to. What she needs is on the page beside what she believes.
Before and after
Explained or enacted
The one faultThe belief is explained in a paragraph of backstory and then plays no part in what the character does.
Kessler checked Amari’s harness, then his own, then the anchor.
He had not always been this careful. Six years ago on the Dreisl face his climbing partner had tied the anchor, and Kessler had trusted it without looking, and the partner had been wrong. Kessler had spent a night on a ledge beside a dead man. Since then he had believed that anything he did not check himself would fail, and that relying on another person was the same as asking to be killed.
“Anchor’s good,” Amari said. “I set it.”
“All right.” Kessler clipped in.
They went over the edge of the dam together, forty metres above the spillway, with nine minutes until the guard came round.
The first version tells us everything: the climb, the dead partner, the exact belief that came of it. Then Amari says the anchor is good, and Kessler says “All right” and clips in. A man who believed what we have just been told would not do that. The belief lives only in the backstory paragraph. Cut that paragraph and the scene would be unchanged.
In the second version the paragraph is gone, and the belief is in everything Kessler does. He reties an anchor that was already sound. He spends time they cannot spare. He rigs a second rope to a different bolt. The past is one word, “Dreisl”, which explains nothing and makes us want to know all of it. The reader could now write his Lie for him: if I did not tie it myself, it will fail.
The exception
When to break it
Not every character needs a wound, and a story is not a case history. Some leads are steady from first page to last and change the people around them instead. They hold a truth, not a Lie; plenty of series detectives and adventure heroes work this way. Comic characters often run on a fixed foible with no origin given, and explaining it would kill the joke.
When the wound can wait
The belief need not come from one terrible event. A long childhood of small lessons, or simply the place and time in which someone grew up, can teach a false rule just as well, and may convince more than a single trauma does.
And a flashback is sometimes the right tool: when the past event is a strong scene in its own right, when the reader has been made to want it, or when the book is built on two timelines. The caution is against explaining too early. It is not against showing the past at all.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is the Lie?
When Imre was eleven, his mother pawned his violin to pay a debt she had sworn was settled. Which of these is his Lie?
Key takeaway
A wound leaves a belief, and the belief shapes what the character does now. Write the belief as one sentence the character would say, then give it work to do in present scenes. Keep the past brief until the reader is asking for it.
