Built for this lead
Giving the other side a case, and the strength to win a round, is work done scene by scene; the lesson on opposition with a point of view, under Conflict and stakes, covers it. This lesson steps back to the whole book. It asks who the antagonist is, and why this one.
- A goal of their ownSpecific, wanted anyway, and they believe they are right
- A goal that cannot share the worldThe house, the command, the child, the credit
- A grip on the lead’s weak pointHelp made the price of everything, for a lead who cannot ask
A designed antagonist has three properties.
A goal of their own. They want something specific, they would want it if the lead had never been born, and they believe they are right. Ask them, and they would describe a story in which they have the problem and the lead is in the way.
A goal that cannot share the world with the lead’s. Often both want the same thing: the house, the command, the child, the credit. Or one can succeed only if the other fails. If both could win, they are not yet opponents. They are two people who dislike each other.
A grip on the lead’s weak point. Earlier lessons gave your lead a Lie, or a need they cannot see. The antagonist worth having is the person best placed to press on exactly that. A lead who cannot ask for help meets someone who makes help the price of everything.
Six sentences from the other side
A quick test of the design is to tell the story from the antagonist’s side, in their voice, in six sentences: what I want; why I am right; what I did first; what the lead did about it; what I did then; how I mean to finish.
Six sentences, in their voice
What I want1; why I am right; what I did first; what the lead did about it; what I did then2; how I mean to finish.
- Vague? Not yet specific“Power” or “revenge” is not yet a goal
- Hard to write? Waiting in a castleThe middle of the book will be short of pressure
The exercise catches three weaknesses. If the first sentence is vague (“power”, “revenge”), the goal is not yet specific. If the fourth and fifth are hard to write, the antagonist is waiting in a castle for the lead to turn up, and the middle of the book will be short of pressure. An antagonist with a plan keeps moving while the lead is busy elsewhere, and changes course when the lead does something. And if nothing in the six sentences touches the lead’s weak point, the two have collided by accident.
Example
Her side of it
This is a planning note, not a scene: the antagonist of a mystery novel tells her side in six sentences. The lead is a surveyor called Dvorak, whose weak point is that he cannot bear to be wrong in public.
1. I want the new flood bank built along the Easton line1, which puts my family’s farm on the dry side of it.
2. I am right, because that farm has fed this valley for five generations2 and the board’s line would drown it to save a car park.
3. So I had the 1890 survey quietly copied out again3 with the boundary stone forty yards further west, and I put the copy in the county file.
4. When the surveyor, Dvorak, found that his own measurements did not match the file, he said so at an open meeting.
5. I thanked him, and asked the room whether a man who had been out by forty yards should be trusted4 with the rest of the scheme. He has not spoken in public since.
6. The vote is on the ninth, and all I need is for him to go on preferring silence5 to being seen to be wrong.
- “I want the new flood bank built along the Easton line”A specific goal. You could draw it on a map, and she would want it whoever the surveyor was.
- “that farm has fed this valley for five generations”Her reason, and it is not a foolish one. In her own account she is defending something.
- “I had the 1890 survey quietly copied out again”A move of her own, made before the lead knows there is a story. She is not waiting to be found.
- “asked the room whether a man who had been out by forty yards shoul…”Her answer to his move, and it is aimed. Another surveyor might have shrugged this off. Dvorak cannot.
- “all I need is for him to go on preferring silence”Her plan now runs through his flaw. To stop her he will have to do the thing he finds hardest, and that ties the plot to his arc.
Before and after
The same demand, aimed two ways
The one faultThe antagonist’s move would work on anyone. It is not aimed at this lead, who cannot refuse anyone who says they need her.
Tamar had been up since two with a carter’s child. In eleven years she had not once sent away anyone who said they needed her.
Warden Magnus did not sit down. He put the transfer deed on the dispensary table, on top of her open ledger.
“The well and the land it stands on, to the city. Sign it, Tamar.”
“The hospice has drawn from that well for a hundred years.”
“And will stop. If the deed is not signed by the new moon, I will send men to close this house and put your patients out on the road. I can do it. You know I can.”
She looked through the doorway at the eleven beds. Then she pushed the deed back across the table.
“Send them,” she said.
Tamar is a healer, and the first lines of both versions give her weak point: she cannot refuse anyone who says they need her. Both versions then open with the same demand.
In the first, the Warden threatens to close the hospice. It is a strong threat, and it would be the same threat whoever sat at that table. It also hands Tamar an easy, admirable choice. She defies him and loses nothing of herself in doing it.
In the second he makes no threat. He offers her the thing she cannot turn down: forty households asking for her by name. If she goes, the hospice and its well are without her for a month, and he has said that the deed can wait. She is reaching for her bag before he has finished. The pressure only works because of who she is, and to resist it she would have to become someone else. An opponent designed for the lead does that.
The exception
When to break it
Not every story has a person for an antagonist. A mountain, an illness, a failed harvest or a system has no goal and no opinion of the lead, and survival stories and social novels do very well with them. The design question still applies in another form: does this force press on this lead’s particular weakness?
When the design bends
Some antagonists are better left opaque. In horror, and in some thrillers, knowing exactly what the thing wants and why can shrink it. You can still write the six sentences for your own use and keep them off the page. A mystery hides the antagonist’s side until late by design: the plan exists and keeps moving, and the reader sees only its effects.
In a romance the two leads often act as each other’s antagonist, each pressing on the other’s Lie, and a villain brought in from outside can feel like an intrusion.
The fit can also be too neat. An antagonist who matches the lead point for point, with the same wound and the opposite choice in every particular, starts to look like a diagram. One contested goal and one well-aimed pressure are usually enough.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Who is built for Rufus?
Rufus is a young architect who cannot say no to anyone he admires. He wants to finish the library his late teacher began, exactly as she drew it. Which antagonist is best designed for him?
Key takeaway
Design the antagonist for this lead. Give them a specific goal they believe in, make it one that cannot be met if the lead’s is, and aim their pressure at the lead’s weakest point. Then tell the story in six sentences from their side. If they are doing nothing between the lead’s scenes, give them a plan.
