Everyone has a job
One useful way to hold a cast in mind is by what each person is for. A secondary character earns a place by doing something to the lead’s story that nobody else in the book does. Four jobs cover most of the ground, and each is measured against the lead.
- AllyHelps towards the want, and usually pays for it
- ObstacleStands between the lead and the want
- TempterThe want, at the price of the need; often friendly
- FoilSame situation, a different choice
Ally. Helps the lead towards the want, and usually pays something for it.
Obstacle. Stands between the lead and the want. The antagonist is the chief of these; a book has many smaller ones.
Tempter. Offers the lead the want, or an easier road to it, at the price of the need. Tempters are often friendly.
Foil. Shares the lead’s situation and makes a different choice. A foil need not affect the plot at all. The job is to show, by contrast, what the lead’s choice means.
One character can hold two jobs, and can change jobs. An ally who turns obstacle late in the book can do more damage than any enemy, because the lead trusted them.
A foil needs shared ground
Put a cautious lead beside a reckless stranger and the reader learns little, because everything about the two differs. Put her beside another apprentice of the same master, the same age, offered the same bribe, who takes it, and the single difference stands out. The more the two have in common, the more that one difference says.
Beside a cautious lead
So match the foil to the lead in situation (rank, trade, loss, temptation) and part them on the one choice your book is about. Then keep the narrator out of it. Shown both choices, a reader compares them unprompted. A sentence that begins “Unlike her friend” does the comparing for them.
The cast audit
In a finished draft, list every named character and write the job beside the name. Look for two things.
The cast audit
Two people doing one job: two confidants, two sceptical bosses, two comic friends. Each has half a character’s worth of scenes. Merging them gives one person with twice the page time, and sometimes a useful contradiction, since the merged character has to hold both sets of lines. The other repair is to keep both and change one job, so that the second confidant becomes a tempter.
A name with no job: someone present and pleasant who does nothing to the lead’s want or need. That may be scenery, which is fine if it is written at the length of scenery.
Example
Same desk, same offer
Two clerks are asked to sign something. Notice how much the passage says they share before either of them acts.
Mr Ibbotson called the two junior clerks in together, which he had not done before, and shut the door.
“The Corvid’s cargo was tallied on Thursday,” he said. “The tally wants two witnesses. You were both in the building.” He turned the sheet round and laid a pen on it.
Eliska and Fabian had started on the same Monday three years ago, on the same wage, at facing desks1. Neither had been down to the quay on Thursday. Both knew it.2
Fabian looked at the figure at the foot of the sheet, and then at Mr Ibbotson, who had a say in who was kept on at Christmas3. He picked up the pen. He signed quickly, the way he signed for parcels.4
Eliska read the sheet from the top. She was still reading when Fabian went out.
“I’d want to see the hold,” she said.5
- “started on the same Monday three years ago, on the same wage, at f…”Shared ground, laid down firmly. Whatever differs next cannot be put down to circumstance.
- “Neither had been down to the quay on Thursday. Both knew it.”The same knowledge and the same temptation. The foil is offered exactly what the lead is offered.
- “who had a say in who was kept on at Christmas”The pressure falls on both of them equally. Fabian’s choice is one a reader can understand.
- “He signed quickly, the way he signed for parcels.”The foil’s choice, reported without judgement.
- ““I’d want to see the hold,” she said.”The lead’s choice. Because Fabian signed first, the reader knows how easy the other road was and what this one may cost. No sentence compares the two.
Before and after
Two friends, or one
The one faultTwo characters do the same job: both friends give the same advice, and neither adds anything the other lacks.
Suresh had the buyer’s offer for the orchard folded in his shirt pocket when he reached the pump, and both of them were waiting.
“You can’t sell,” said Josefa. “Your mother planted those trees.”
“She’s right,” said Lan. “You’d regret it within the year.”
“It’s a lot of money,” Suresh said.
“Money goes,” said Josefa.
“And the trees wouldn’t come back,” said Lan.
He took the offer out and looked at it again. Josefa shook her head. So did Lan.
In the first version Josefa and Lan are both allies of the orchard. They take turns to say one thing, and at the end they shake their heads in turn. Remove either and Suresh hears exactly the same case.
The second version gives all the lines to Josefa and changes nothing else. No argument has been lost. The scene is shorter, the reader has one name fewer to carry, and Josefa, with twice the lines, has begun to sound like a particular person who will not let a point go.
Merging is one repair. The other is to keep Lan and change her job. Suppose she says, “Take it. I would. You could buy the boat.” Now she is a tempter, the two friends are pulling Suresh in opposite directions, and the scene has an argument in it. Either repair works. What does not work is two people sharing one job.
The exception
When to break it
Jobs are an editing tool, and a cast built from nothing else reads like a diagram. Lives contain people who are simply there, and some novels want that texture: a village, a regiment, a large family at a wedding. Two aunts who say the same thing can be the point, if the point is that the lead is outnumbered. The audit asks you to notice doubling. It does not forbid it.
Where jobs stop helping
Merging has costs. A detective plausibly has more than one colleague, and a lead whose single friend is confidant, tempter and comic relief can seem to live in a very small world. A merged character also has to be one believable person. If the two halves cannot share a body, separate their jobs.
Foils can be too neat. One who exists only to choose wrongly, and is punished for it on schedule, turns a novel into a lesson. A foil’s choice works best when it is defensible, and it may even turn out well for them.
In a series, a character with no job in this book may be holding a place for the next. That is a fair reason to keep them, in little room.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is the foil?
Freya is a cautious young cartographer, hired to map a disputed border honestly. Which of these four people in her story is her foil?
Key takeaway
Know what each secondary character is for: ally, obstacle, tempter or foil, measured against the lead’s want and need. Build a foil on shared ground, with one difference. Then audit the cast. Where two people do one job, merge them or give one of them another, so that no two are interchangeable.
