Why middles sag
A beginning has a natural shape, because something changes. An ending has one too, because something is settled. The middle is half the book or more, and its only given shape is “and then, for a long time, it was difficult”.
The test for a middle chapter
So the middle is where drafts sag. A sagging chapter is seldom an empty one. People travel, argue, search, fight. But when the chapter ends, the character knows what they knew before, has what they had, and risks what they risked. The reader senses that nothing would be lost if the chapter were skipped, and the pages begin to feel long.
The test for a middle chapter is simple to state: the situation at the end is different from the situation at the start. Three kinds of difference do most of the work.
Three ways to change the situation
A reversal turns something the character was relying on against them. The plan works and the result is worse than failure. The ally delivers, and names a price.
Three ways to change the situation
- A reversalThe ally delivers, and names a price
- New informationThe old enemy is no longer the real one
- Rising costGoing on takes something that cannot be got back
New information changes what the problem is. The character, or the reader, learns something, and after it the old goal is no longer the right goal, or the old enemy no longer the real one.
Rising cost means that going on now takes more than it did. The character has to spend, break or give up something they cannot get back, and so turning round gets harder with every chapter.
Two cautions for anyone outlining. First, bigger is not the same as different. Three interrogations, each angrier than the last, read as one event told three times. Change the kind of trouble, not only its size. Second, the strongest complications are caused by what the character did in the chapter before. Then the middle is a chain, and a chain is hard to put down.
Many writers also plan one large turn near the centre of the book, often called the midpoint, where the character’s whole understanding of the problem shifts. It is a reversal or a discovery like the others, given more weight.
Example
Five chapters, five changes
This is a working outline for part of a novel’s middle, one short paragraph per chapter. For each chapter, look for what is different at the end.
Chapter 9. Sigrun reaches the border fort with the forged pass. The captain accepts it, then tells her the pass obliges her to carry the fort’s dispatches east, the way she has just come1.
Chapter 10. On the road back she reads the dispatches. They order the arrest of every salt-carrier in her home valley, her brother among them.2
Chapter 11. She burns the dispatches. A rider from the fort overtakes her that night. The captain kept copies, and she is now a named deserter3.
Chapter 12. She trades her mule, her only means of carrying salt4, for a guide over the high pass, the one route the riders will not take.
Chapter 13. From the top of the pass the guide shows her the valley. The salt works are already burning. Her brother’s arrest was never the plan.5 Clearing the valley was.
- “then tells her the pass obliges her to carry the fort’s dispatches…”A reversal. The forged pass worked, and its working is the problem.
- “They order the arrest of every salt-carrier in her home valley, he…”New information. Her goal has been to get across the border. After this line it cannot be.
- “she is now a named deserter”This follows from her own act in the same chapter. The cost of going on has risen, and she raised it.
- “She trades her mule, her only means of carrying salt”Rising cost, paid in something she cannot get back. She has given up her living to keep moving.
- “Her brother’s arrest was never the plan.”New information again, and larger. This is the kind of turn many writers place at the midpoint: the story is about something bigger than she thought.
Before and after
The same five chapters, flat and moving
The one faultEach chapter ends where it began: the detective knows nothing new and is no worse off.
Chapter 14. Detective Ferrant interviews the victim’s business partner, who says he was at home and knows nothing.
Chapter 15. She interviews the victim’s sister, who says she was abroad and knows nothing.
Chapter 16. She interviews the night porter, who is rude, says he saw nobody and knows nothing.
Chapter 17. She goes back to the business partner, who is angrier this time and still knows nothing.
Chapter 18. Her superintendent warns her that she is running out of time.
Both outlines put the same people in the same rooms in the same order: partner, sister, porter, partner again, superintendent.
In the first, each interview fills a chapter and returns nothing. The witnesses vary in manner, one at home, one abroad, one rude, one angry, and that variety can hide the problem while you are writing the scenes. In outline it is plain. Chapters 14 to 17 could be cut to a sentence, and chapter 18 would follow just as well.
In the second, every interview changes something. Chapter 14 ties the partner to the sister. Chapter 15 gives them a shared secret. Chapter 16 turns the case over: the victim arranged for the porter to be away. Chapter 17 costs Ferrant her safety, because the man she is pressing has a friend above her. Chapter 18 is no longer a warning. It is the bill.
Nothing was added to the cast or the setting. The chapters were given outcomes.
The exception
When to break it
“Changes the situation” does not have to mean the plot. A chapter can leave the main problem where it was and change a marriage, a loyalty, or what the reader understands about someone. In a quiet literary novel most of the middle may move in that way. What a chapter cannot do for long is change nothing at all.
After two or three hard turns, a slower chapter lets the weight land. Readers need to see what a loss means to the character before the next one arrives, and a chapter given over to that is not sagging.
Stories built as episodes, such as a road novel, a comic series or a string of cases, run on chapters that are nearly complete in themselves. Their pull comes from the company and the voice. Even there, something usually builds from one episode to the next.
Rising cost also has a ceiling. If every chapter raises the stakes, by the twentieth the reader stops believing in them. Vary the kind of pressure before you raise the amount.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which chapter moves?
Four chapter summaries from the middles of four novels. In which one is the situation different at the end?
Key takeaway
For each chapter in your middle, be able to say what is different at the end: something relied on has turned, something has been learned that changes the problem, or going on has started to cost more. Vary the kind of trouble, and let each complication grow out of what the character did last.
