What the lowest point is for
Many stories that end in a hard-won victory pass through a lowest point first, somewhere near the end of the middle. The plan has failed. The thing the character leaned on is gone. No way forward can be seen. Blake Snyder’s beat sheet in Save the Cat! gives it two names: All Is Lost for the blow, and Dark Night of the Soul for the stretch that follows. Romance writers often call it the black moment.
What the lowest point is for
- A way of handling troubleShe controls everything, or he trusts nobody
- It fails, finally and plainlyAll Is Lost, then the Dark Night of the Soul
- A reason to try something elseSo the climax has something new to show
It does two jobs. The obvious one is doubt: an ending we were sure of is not much of an ending.
The second job matters more. From the first chapter your character has had a way of dealing with trouble. She controls everything, or he trusts nobody, or they lie their way through. The dark moment is where that way finally and plainly fails. Until it has failed, the character has no reason to try anything else, and the climax has nothing new to show.
Earned by the character, and then quiet
That second job tells you how to build the scene. The loss has to come from the character’s own flaw or choice. A storm that sinks the boat is misfortune, and a reader feels sorry. A captain who will not turn back because she trusts no judgement but her own, and loses the boat, has had her whole approach tested and broken. A reader feels that, and also understands what must change.
The captain’s chain
- A traitShe trusts no judgement but her own
- A choiceShe will not turn back
- A lossShe loses the boat
A useful check is a chain of three links: a trait we have seen since early on, a choice made in keeping with it, a loss that follows from the choice. If you can remove the trait and the loss still happens, it is bad luck.
After the blow comes the quiet. The character is usually alone, and this is where they begin to see their own part. Keep it short, and keep it concrete. Pages of misery in general terms wear a reader out. An object on a table can do the work of a paragraph.
Example
After the review
A chef has just lost the notice that would have saved her restaurant. Follow the chain from trait to choice to loss.
The restaurant had been closed for an hour when Renee sat down at table nine, where the critic had sat1, and read the review on her phone a second time. The investors had been plain about it: a good notice from this man, or they were out by Friday.
It was not unkind. That was the worst of it.2 It praised the lamb. It praised the room. It said the service had the feel of a kitchen where nobody but one person was allowed to make a decision3, and that by the third course you could taste the waiting.
Stefan had told her that in March.4 He had said it at the pass, in front of everyone, and she had let him work out his notice and hired someone quieter.
His knives were still in the drawer.5 She had not got round to posting them.
- “sat down at table nine, where the critic had sat”The quiet after the blow, given as an action. She puts herself in the customer’s chair.
- “It was not unkind. That was the worst of it.”There is no villain to be angry with. That leaves only one direction to look.
- “a kitchen where nobody but one person was allowed to make a decision”The loss is tied to her trait, by a stranger. It was her need for control that the critic could taste.
- “Stefan had told her that in March.”The choice. She was warned, in public, and she got rid of the person who warned her. The loss could have been avoided, and she is the one who did not avoid it.
- “His knives were still in the drawer.”An object and no named feeling. It also points, quietly, towards what a different approach might look like.
Before and after
Caught by a lift, and caught by himself
The one faultThe loss is caused by bad luck, a stuck lift, and not by anything the character chose.
Mordecai Sayer had the ledger for eleven minutes.
He photographed it in the stairwell and put it back. That was the plan, and it was Jocasta’s plan, and he followed it to the letter. But on the way down the lift stopped between floors, a fault nobody could have foreseen, and when the doors were forced at last the night manager was standing there with two men, and one of them had the phone out of Mordecai’s pocket before he could speak.
They took the phone. They let him keep his keys. From the street he watched the light go on in the office on the fourth floor, where Jocasta was still waiting for his signal.
The first sentence and the last paragraph are almost the same in both versions. A man is caught, loses the evidence, and has to watch the light go on where his partner is waiting.
In the first version he does everything right, and a lift breaks down. The text even says that nobody could have foreseen it. We are sorry for him, and that is all. The scene tells us nothing about Mordecai, and gives him nothing to do differently next time except take the stairs.
In the second version the same disaster comes out of who he is. He has been improving on Jocasta’s plans for six weeks, and tonight he improves on one more. The words “to do the job properly” are his flaw in his own voice. Now the last image has a second meaning. He has not only failed her. He has failed her by not trusting her, and he will have to tell her so.
The exception
When to break it
Some stories are about blows the character did not earn: a war, an illness, an injustice. To make the victim responsible would falsify them. In those books what belongs to the character is the response. Luck can deliver the blow, as long as the character’s own nature decides how deep it goes and what they do next.
Scaled to the book
A tragedy has no recovery. Its dark moment is the ending, or leads straight into it, and the recognition comes too late to use.
Scale the low point to the book. In a light comedy it may be a ruined dinner. A detective in a long series does not need to be broken in every volume.
And do not manufacture one. A separation that rests on a misunderstanding which one honest sentence would clear up tries a reader’s patience more than a mild low point would. If the story has not built a flaw that can break, the fix is earlier in the book, not here.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Whose fault is the low point?
Four low points from four novels. In which one does the loss follow from the character’s own flaw?
Key takeaway
The dark moment is where the character’s old way of handling things fails, in a loss they brought on themselves. Build the chain of trait, choice and loss, then give them a short, quiet scene with something to look at, and let them start to see their part in it.
