Two debts the climax has to pay
The climax is where the book’s main question is answered. Will she get the child back? Will he tell the truth? An answer on its own is not enough. Readers judge an ending by how the answer was reached, and “earned” is the word for an ending reached honestly.
- To the characterDecided by a choice that draws on what the story put them through
- To the readerEverything that decides the outcome was on the page earlier
An earned climax pays two debts. The first is to the character. The outcome is decided by something the protagonist chooses to do, and the choice draws on what the story has put them through. After the dark moment the old approach is finished, and the climax is where we see the new one, at a price.
The second debt is to the reader. Everything that decides the outcome was on the page earlier. Aristotle makes both halves of this point in the Poetics: events strike hardest when they come unexpectedly and yet follow from what went before, and a plot should be resolved from inside itself and not by a god lowered onto the stage. That device has kept its Latin name, deus ex machina.
Three cheats, and the work that prevents them
Unearned endings come in three main kinds.
Setup and payoff, done backwards
- Write the climax first
- List what it depends onAn object, a skill, a fact, a debt between two people
- Plant each one, well beforeInside a scene that seems to be about something else
- “I should have seen that”
Rescue: someone or something else solves it. The cavalry arrives, or the mentor steps in.
Coincidence: chance solves it. The villain slips. Chance may make trouble for a character at any point, and readers accept that. They stop accepting it when chance takes the trouble away.
Withheld fact: the solution rests on a skill, an object or a rule that the reader was not shown. The narrator “had the key all along”.
The remedy is setup and payoff, and in practice it is done backwards. Write the climax first. Then list what it depends on, which is often three or four things: an object, a skill, a fact, a debt between two people. Go back and plant each one, well before the end, inside a scene that seems to be about something else. A setup that does a second job, such as making us laugh or showing a character’s shame, does not look like a setup.
The balance is fine. Plant too openly and the reader is ahead of you. Plant too faintly and the payoff feels like a cheat even when it is not. The reaction to aim for is “I should have seen that.”
Example
A whistle, set up in chapter two
Earlier in this novel we watched Brenna’s mother work sheepdogs by whistle, and we heard in passing that the Duke buys his hounds from hill breeders. Brenna has spent three years at court hiding where she comes from.
The hounds came over the ridge in a line, eleven of them, with the Duke’s huntsmen a field behind. The children were still out on the ice.
Brenna had a knife, which was no use, and a court gown, which was less.1 She had also, for three years, had a story about a merchant father in the south2, and she had told it so well that the Duchess’s own ladies had stopped asking.
She put two fingers in her mouth.3
The whistle went out flat and hard across the lake, the long note and the two short, the one her mother had used to turn dogs on a hillside at half a mile4. The lead hound checked. Then all eleven wheeled left as if on one rope and dropped to their bellies in the snow.
Behind her, one of the ladies laughed, and stopped.
“Hill-bred,” the Duchess said.5 It was not clear whether she meant the dogs.
- “Brenna had a knife, which was no use, and a court gown, which was…”The obvious means are ruled out first. Whatever saves the children will have to come from somewhere else.
- “a story about a merchant father in the south”The reader is reminded what she stands to lose, just before she spends it.
- “She put two fingers in her mouth.”The choice. It is hers alone, and it has a paragraph to itself.
- “the one her mother had used to turn dogs on a hillside at half a mile”The payoff of chapter two. When we first saw the whistle it was showing us a childhood she was ashamed of. It did not look like a weapon.
- ““Hill-bred,” the Duchess said.”The second setup pays off, and the cost arrives in the same line. The hounds obeyed because they are hill dogs. The court now knows that she is hill-bred as well.
Before and after
The same station, with and without a choice
The one faultThe outcome is decided by someone else: the sister speaks to him, and the heroine does nothing.
The train to the coast left at 6.40, and at 6.31 Gwendolen was still standing in the ticket hall with her speech in her pocket.
She had written it out, which was what she did. Three drafts. She had been writing things out for Declan for two years, cards and notes and one long email she had deleted, and in all that time she had not said a single unprepared word to his face.
He was at the barrier with his back to her, feeling for his ticket.
Then his sister came through the crowd, took him by the sleeve, said something in his ear and pointed. He turned round. He put the ticket back in his coat and walked across the hall to where Gwendolen stood, and she did not have to say anything at all.
The first three paragraphs are identical. They set the clock, and they state the heroine’s flaw exactly: in two years she has not said one unprepared word to him.
In the first version the sister crosses the hall and settles everything in his ear. The lovers are united, and the final clause even presents it as a mercy that Gwendolen “did not have to say anything at all”. That mercy is the trouble. The book has been asking whether she can speak without a draft, and the ending arranges things so that the question need not be answered.
In the second version she leaves the speech in her pocket and says something clumsy, too loud, in front of a stranger with a bicycle. It is the one act the opening paragraphs told us she could not manage. We are not told whether he stays, and the climax does not need that. Her question has been answered, and she paid for the answer in dignity.
The exception
When to break it
A rescue can be earned. If help arrives because of something the protagonist did earlier, such as a kindness in chapter three or an enemy spared, then the rescue is a payoff, and the protagonist caused it. What matters is where the help comes from.
Earned in other ways
A tragic or ironic ending turns the pattern over. The character fails to change, makes the old choice once more, and loses. That is earned in the same way, because it follows from who they are.
Comic novels sometimes end on an outrageous coincidence and expect you to enjoy the nerve of it. That is a bargain struck with the reader from page one.
The classic detective story withholds on purpose. The detective’s reasoning is kept back until the reveal. It is fair so long as the facts were shown and only the inference was held.
And in a quiet novel the climax may be a decision not to act, or a sentence finally said. The scale differs. The two debts are the same.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which ending is earned?
A novel about a town under siege could end in any of these ways. Which ending is earned?
Key takeaway
An earned climax is settled by the protagonist’s own hard choice, made in a way they could not have managed at the start, using only things the reader has already seen. List what your ending depends on, then go back and plant each item early, in a scene that is doing some other job.
