The job of a first line
A first line has one job: to get the second line read. The first page has the same job on a bigger scale. It has to get the page turned.
Does it get the second line read?
Two things do most of that work.
The first is an open question. This does not mean a sentence with a question mark. It means something the reader now wants to know and has not been told. “The Ashdown girls buried their mother twice” opens one straight away: why twice? A line such as “It was a cold morning in March” opens nothing. It may be well written, but it is complete, and a reader can put a complete thing down.
The second is voice. Voice is the sound of whoever is telling the story: the words they pick, the things they notice, their attitude to what they are reporting. A plain fact told by a particular person is more interesting than an exciting fact told by nobody.
What the rest of the page does
A strong first line that the page then abandons is a trick, and it wears off by the second paragraph. The rest of the first page should do three things with what the line began.
- Keeps the question openAnd usually makes it larger or sharper
- Keeps the voice goingThe teller of line one, still there in line twenty
- Shows what kind of bookFunny or grave, quick or slow: a promise
It keeps the question open, and usually makes it larger or sharper. It keeps the voice going, so that the teller of line one is still recognisable in line twenty. And it starts to show what kind of book this is: funny or grave, quick or slow, a love story or a murder. That last part is a promise. Someone who enjoys your first page is expecting more of the same, and the book should be the book the page describes.
None of this needs an explosion. A small, exact question is enough.
Example
A first page at work
A coffin-maker begins his story. Watch what each part of the page adds to the first line.
The Ashdown girls buried their mother twice, and I was paid for both funerals.1
The first was in March, in the proper way, with the vicar and a ham2. The second was eleven days later, at night, and I would have refused the work if Martha Ashdown had not put the money on my bench before she said what it was for. I make coffins. I don’t ask what goes in them, as a rule, and it is a good rule, and I broke it3.
What I can tell you is that the second box was lighter than the first4. A carpenter knows the weight of his own work.
- “The Ashdown girls buried their mother twice, and I was paid for bo…”The question arrives in the first seven words: why twice? The second half of the sentence is voice. This narrator thinks first of his fee.
- “with the vicar and a ham”Voice again. A funeral summed up by its clergyman and its food tells us how this man sees the world: practically, and with a dry eye.
- “it is a good rule, and I broke it”A promise about the story to come. He is going to get involved in something he should have left alone.
- “the second box was lighter than the first”The page does not answer the first question. It sharpens it: what, or who, was in the second coffin?
The explainer
Open the bakery door
Agata’s bakery, and the first version of the opening, one sentence at a time. Press a sentence to swap in its rewrite. Each clue lights up in the room as the page stops settling things and starts leaving one open.

Changes left
4 of 4
Words
77 (was 77)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
The same baker, with and without a question
The one faultNothing is left open: the opening describes a settled situation.
Three days before her sister’s wedding, Agata Rossi was busy at the bakery, as she was every June.
She had done hard things for the bakery. She had talked a bride out of a cake shaped like a horse. She had once delivered four tiers up a fire escape. Her sister’s cake was going well, and the best man, whom she used to know, was coming on Friday like everyone else.
She went on with the icing.
The voice is the same in both versions. The horse-shaped cake and the fire escape are in each, and they are what make Agata a person and not a job title.
The difference is whether anything is unsettled. In the first version she is busy, the cake is going well and the best man is coming on Friday. There is a hint that she used to know him, but nothing is asked of her, so the page is at rest. She goes on with the icing, and the reader could stop there too.
In the second version she has been given a task she does not want, involving a man who once walked out. Now there are things to find out. Why is he being un-invited? What happened between them? What will he say? The last line leaves her with the telephone in her hand.
The exception
When to break it
A first line does not have to grab anyone by the collar. Plenty of loved books open quietly, on a voice so sure of itself that the reader trusts it and waits. If your teller is good company, the open question can arrive in the third sentence or the fifth. What a quiet opening cannot do is stay settled for a whole page.
Be wary of the opposite fault as well. A shocking line that has nothing to do with the book that follows, such as a body in sentence one of a gentle family story, makes a promise the book will not keep. Readers who came for the body feel cheated, and readers who would have liked the family story have already left.
Later books in a series are a special case, since people arrive with their questions already open. And while you are drafting, do not wait for the perfect line. Many first lines are found on the way back, once you know what the book is.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which line leaves something open?
Four first lines. Which one leaves the reader with a question they want answered?
Key takeaway
A first line earns the second by leaving something open and by sounding like someone. The first page then widens the question, keeps the voice steady and shows what kind of book this is. Check your own opening by asking what a stranger would want to know after one line, and after one page.
