The day that is different
A story begins when something changes for someone. Until then there is a life, and lives can be interesting, but a reader opens a novel to watch a life get disturbed.
Where the story starts
- Wakes
- Looks at the weather
- Dresses, travels
- Something changesOpen here, or a few lines before
Draft openings tend to begin earlier than that. The character wakes, looks at the weather, dresses, travels. Or the first page explains the family, the town and the last ten years. This is natural. It is the writer warming up, finding the character by following them through a morning. But the reader is being asked to wait through a day that is like every other day, and has no reason yet to care how it goes.
The old name for the alternative is in medias res, Latin for “into the middle of things”. The phrase comes from the Roman poet Horace. In his Ars Poetica he praises the poet of the Odyssey for hurrying his listener into the middle of the story. For a novelist it comes down to this: open at the change, or a few lines before it.
How to find the change
Read your opening and look for the first line after which today cannot go on like yesterday. A stranger walks in. A letter is on the seat. Someone says no. That line is the change, and it is your first candidate for sentence one.
Finding the change
- Find the changeA stranger walks in. A letter is on the seat. Someone says no.
- Find the first wantSomething particular, and something in the way
- Keep what is neededA name, a place, a dead father, moved inside the action
A second test helps. Find the first moment when your character wants something particular and something is in the way. Wanting is what turns a description of a person into a story about them. If the first page ends and nobody has wanted anything yet, the story has probably not started.
Then look at what you would be cutting. Some of it is warm-up and can go. Some of it is information the reader needs: a name, a place, a dead father. Keep those, but move them inside the action, as a clause or a line of speech.
Example
Opening on the change
A ferry-keeper’s daughter is about to lose the ferry. Notice what the reader learns without the story stopping to explain.
The river-wardens came for the ferry licence a week before Thessaly Brakewater was old enough to hold it.1
“It’s my father’s name on the plate,” she said.2 She kept both hands on the rope. The ferry was mid-stream, with a wool merchant and his mule aboard3, and neither of them could swim.
“Your father has been dead since the thaw.”4 The older warden held up the brass seal he had unscrewed from her landing post. “A licence can’t pass to a child.”
“I’m of age in seven days.”
“Then in seven days you may apply for one.”
The mule shifted its weight. Thessaly pulled, hand over hand, towards the bank where the wardens’ boat was tied across her mooring, and began to work out what a person could do in a week5.
- “The river-wardens came for the ferry licence a week before Thessal…”Sentence one is the change. It also carries her name, her age, and what she stands to lose.
- ““It’s my father’s name on the plate,” she said.”By the second line she wants something and is arguing for it.
- “The ferry was mid-stream, with a wool merchant and his mule aboard”The setting arrives while the trouble is happening. We are not shown the river first and the wardens second.
- ““Your father has been dead since the thaw.””This is backstory, and in a first draft it might have been the opening paragraph. Here it is one line of the argument, said by the person using it against her.
- “began to work out what a person could do in a week”The page ends with the want turned into a plan, and with a deadline.
Before and after
An hour early, and on time
The one faultThe opening begins an hour before anything changes.
Dunya Sokolova woke at four, as she did before every early shift, and lay for a minute listening to the rain. It had rained all week. She made coffee in the dark so as not to wake her daughter, ate a slice of toast standing at the sink, and found her keys under yesterday’s newspaper. The bus to the depot was late, and the driver, who knew her, waved her through without paying. She crossed the yard with her collar up.
The envelope was on the driver’s seat when she unlocked her cab at five, and the cab had been locked all night.
She did not touch it. Twenty years of night work had taught her what could be left on a seat. She crouched by the open door and read her own name, typed, and under it a time: 6.10. The depot clock said 5.02.
Inside was a photograph of her daughter’s school gate, and an address across town that she had not driven to in all those years.
She had sixty-eight minutes. She started the engine.
From the envelope onwards the two versions are the same, word for word apart from where the name falls. The first puts a paragraph in front: waking, rain, coffee, toast, keys, the bus, the yard. It is competently written, and the bus driver waving her through is a nice touch. But it is a morning like all her mornings, and the reader has to get through it before learning why this one matters.
The second version opens on the envelope. Look at what was lost with the cut paragraph. That she has a daughter? The photograph tells us. That she works early shifts and knows the depot? The cab and the clock tell us. What has really gone is the rain, the toast and the bus, and the scene does not miss them.
This is a common result. Much of what a warm-up paragraph holds turns out to be either unnecessary or already present in the scene that follows.
The exception
When to break it
Starting in the middle can be overdone. A book that opens mid-chase, with strangers shouting names we do not know, gives the reader action and nobody to worry about. If the change means nothing until we have seen what it disturbs, give us a few lines of the ordinary first. The next lesson, on establishing normal, is about doing that briefly.
When waking is the change
Waking and weather are only weak when they are routine. If she wakes in a room she has not seen before, the waking is the change. If the storm is what sinks the boat, begin with the sky.
Some books choose a slow way in on purpose: a family saga that settles the reader into a house, or a comic narrator whose throat-clearing is part of the joke. Those openings are held up by voice. And a few stories open late and then go back, which is a matter of where the telling starts and not where the events do.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Four places to begin
A novel is about a locksmith who is asked to open a safe for a man she believes is dead. Which of these openings begins nearest to the change?
Key takeaway
Look for the first moment when today stops being like yesterday and someone wants something. Try opening there, or a few lines before. Then go through what you cut, and carry forward only the facts the reader needs, tucked inside sentences where something is happening.
