A second question
A reader asks what happens next. A writer reading asks a second question as well: how was that done?
How was that done?
- Notice an effectYou laughed, or your stomach dropped
- Find the placePut your finger on the lines
- Name the choice“She ends the paragraph on the object”
Reading like a writer means slowing down over a passage that worked on you and looking for the choices behind the effect. Francine Prose’s book Reading Like a Writer is a full-length case for this kind of close reading: word by word and sentence by sentence, asking why each is there.
The method has three steps.
Notice an effect. You laughed, or your stomach dropped, or you trusted a character you had only just met.
Find the place. Go back and put your finger on the lines where it happened.
Name the choice. Say what the author did there, with the author as the subject of your sentence: “She ends the paragraph on the object, not on the feeling.” “He gives the threat to the politest person in the room.”
The third step is what turns admiration into something you can use. “Beautiful” and “gripping” are reactions. They are true, and they are where you start, but you cannot take them to your own page. A named choice will travel.
From notes to practice
Two old exercises take the notes further.
Two old exercises
Copy it out. Writing a paragraph out by hand, or retyping it, takes you through it at writing speed. You notice a comma, a short sentence after two long ones, a word used twice on purpose.
Imitate the shape. Take the skeleton of the paragraph (the number of sentences, their rough lengths, the order of the moves) and fill it with material of your own: a different subject and different words on the same frame. Benjamin Franklin describes teaching himself prose in a similar way in his Autobiography. He made brief notes on essays he admired, set them aside for a few days, rewrote the essays from his notes, and compared his version with the original.
This kind of reading has costs. It is slow: one page can take an evening. It can spoil a first read, so it is often better to read a book once for pleasure and go back to the parts that stayed with you. And what you learn from one book is what that author chose for that story. It becomes a tool of yours only after you have tried it on your own material and seen whether it holds.
Example
One paragraph, read slowly
A woman is clearing her late mother’s house. Read the paragraph once straight through. Then read the notes, each of which says what the author did at one exact place.
The house had been sold with everything in it. The agent said so twice, as though it were a kindness.1 Elowen went through the rooms with a roll of stickers, red for throw out, green for keep, and by noon she had used a whole sheet of red. In the kitchen she opened the drawer beside the stove. String. Candle ends. A bread knife worn to a crescent.2 Her mother’s handwriting on a luggage label: SPARE KEY, GARAGE. There was no garage. There had never been a garage.3 She stood for some time with the label in her hand, and then she peeled off a green sticker and put it, carefully, on the drawer4.
- “The agent said so twice, as though it were a kindness.”The author gives the agent no spoken words, only a report and one comparison. A single clause tells us how the world is treating her today.
- “String. Candle ends. A bread knife worn to a crescent.”Three fragments, each longer than the one before. The prose slows to the speed of someone looking, and only the third object has a history.
- “There was no garage. There had never been a garage.”A flat statement, then the same statement pushed further back in time. The author explains nothing and lets the repetition do the unsettling.
- “put it, carefully, on the drawer”The feeling is given as an action with one adverb. She keeps the whole drawer, not the label, and the author does not say why.
Before and after
Two sets of notes on that paragraph
The one faultThe notes record reactions and do not say what the author did.
1. The line about the agent is brilliant. So true to life.
2. I love the list of things in the drawer. Really vivid.
3. The part about the garage gave me chills.
4. The ending is so moving, and so understated. I wish I could write like this.
Both readers stopped at the same four places, so both noticed where the paragraph was working. The first reader’s notes say how each place felt: brilliant, vivid, chilling, moving. All four are fair. None of them could be used tomorrow, because none says what is on the page.
The second reader looks at the same four places and describes the mechanism. The agent has no dialogue. The list has no main verbs and grows. The statement about the garage is repeated one step back in time. The feeling is an action. Each note makes the author the subject of the sentence and points at words in the passage.
That is the whole difference, and it decides what happens next. The second reader can go to a paragraph of her own and try a growing list of fragments. The first reader can only wish.
The exception
When to break it
Close reading is a study method, and it has limits.
The limits of close reading
It is not for every book. Reading only to take books apart can wear away the pleasure that made you want to write. Read some books simply as a reader.
An imitation is scaffolding. It belongs in the notebook, and its purpose is to absorb a move until you can make it without the model in front of you. If a finished page of yours still follows another writer’s paragraph beat for beat, take it further from the source or cut it. Copying out is for private study only: another writer’s sentences have no place in your manuscript.
Be wary of turning one admired choice into a rule. What works in a quiet literary novel may be wrong for a fast thriller, and the reverse. Note what the choice did in that book, at that point in the story.
Some writers avoid reading in their own genre during a first draft, because other voices leak into theirs. If that happens to you, keep the close reading for the time between drafts.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Reaction or choice?
Four readers have each made a note on the same chase scene. Which note names a choice the author made?
Key takeaway
Read once as a reader, then go back as a writer. Find the lines where the effect happened and say what the author did there, in words exact enough to act on. Then try the move yourself, on your own material.
